Cork AUL 2012/13
Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
-
-
was also at this game and taught glenthorn were unlucky deserved something from it,but at the end of the day kilumney showed why they are one of the best teams around even when they went down to ten they didn't panic and got their reward.i cant see them losing it now.the ball is not a bomb........Comment
-
As you say always 2 sides no probs with that . But in regards to what I posted I'll stand over nothing to gain by fibbing on here . Not going to fall out with anyone over a game of ball but you might want to reword your last quote . As a club team etc we go out to win every game we are involved in to suggest that the Coachford game was our season is insulting to Knockavilla club . Nobody gets an easy game off us and if they beat us they have earned it . I might remind you your no stranger at pionting the finger at an odd official or 2
. As I said in my post he didn't get the big decisions wrong but he got a lot of the small ones wrong and they add up and annoy players . Rant over .... For now .
Comment
-
its a liverpool v man u thing one game seems to bring out your best i respect your club lad .im not going to fall out either kid .As you say always 2 sides no probs with that . But in regards to what I posted I'll stand over nothing to gain by fibbing on here . Not going to fall out with anyone over a game of ball but you might want to reword your last quote . As a club team etc we go out to win every game we are involved in to suggest that the Coachford game was our season is insulting to Knockavilla club . Nobody gets an easy game off us and if they beat us they have earned it . I might remind you your no stranger at pionting the finger at an odd official or 2
. As I said in my post he didn't get the big decisions wrong but he got a lot of the small ones wrong and they add up and annoy players . Rant over .... For now .
Comment
-
Comment
-
Lads, we can moan and groan about refs but it is the same moans from a decade ago and will be the same in a decades time unless we do something. Looking at the eight Prem and Prem A fixtures for next week, I don't know one guy, only had another guy once so won't comment. Leaves six, 3 are ok. They make mistakes but overall get most things right. The key is that you can talk to them and they will explain decisions. We mightn't like it but at least there is respect. Two of the others make the same mistakes again and again. The key is that they mightn't even know that they do cos who tells them? The last guy is rising through the ranks, but I know teams don't rate him.
People need to realise that we are not looking to hang anyone- just looking for value for our money. The opinions of the teams are not taken into account.
I plan to suggest a form of refs report from teams , set mail address or standard form for example. We send in our opinions and they are reviewed once a month by league and representative from refs association together. After a while, a pattern will emerge of teams who report only when they lose and other redundant opinions, but also other patterns will emerge. The league can see what refs/teams don't get on and it might help them avoid confrontation. Common errors by the same ref can help the refs society advise the ref. win for everyone.
Ask your clubs what they think before AGM and let me know in pm if you want.
Saw a teenager ref a game yesterday. Got 90% of his decisions right. Looks a prospect.
Did I hear Robbie Walsh and his manager had a dressing room confrontation after the Street game?Just remember, every kick makes me stronger and more determined. Indians always come back!Comment
-
Horse I know it's something which has annoyed you for some time, but lets be honest it's when teams lose, the ref suddenly becomes the problem, same story all the time, when things don't go teams ways they abuse the ref, you're right they don't get it right all the time and there should be a simple scorecard but I'll guarantee you one thing it will become a tool for fellas to slate these refs, which will put fellas off even wanting to become refs.Comment
-
I agree with you Radio, but in some cases a performance of the man in the middle has undoubtedly effected the result. That's why owner of scorecard scheme in AUL ( disciplinary sec for example) and ref representative meet first. They become the filter for the drivel. By the time it reaches the official you would hope it has been "translated" to constructive criticism. If refs can't handle constructive criticism from those who pay them, then you shouldn't take our money.Just remember, every kick makes me stronger and more determined. Indians always come back!Comment
-
Ya or maybe get the refs to design the card themselves with only key areas to be rated, and rate by score as oppose comments, comments could have a negative effect. If a ref knows he's scoring low in for example communicating his decisions, it'll be easier for him to try improve on that. I'd support your cause anyway Horse!Comment
-
can a ref take a player out during a half time team talk to talk to the player he was told he had no reason in the team talk and do it when the game restarted .and i dont think he can insult a player.Ya or maybe get the refs to design the card themselves with only key areas to be rated, and rate by score as oppose comments, comments could have a negative effect. If a ref knows he's scoring low in for example communicating his decisions, it'll be easier for him to try improve on that. I'd support your cause anyway Horse!Comment
-
Comment
Comment