Originally Posted by
EalingGreen
It's quite simple, really.
Over on OWC, there is an interesting thread about the increasing number of English, Germans, Austrians, Czechs etc who are now members of the GAWA. They usually have no family connection etc with NI, but join in because they enjoy the whole experience. I'm sure it is the same with the Boys in Green.
Which essentially reflects the fact that you can support whichever team you like, even a National team. That is, it is am matter of choice.
Whereas, who you play for is most definitely NOT a matter of choice. After all, no-one can "choose" where he, or his parents/grandparents are born, and these are the basic criteria for determining which country you play for.
And although I am forced to accept that FIFA do not apply their Rules in the Irish situation in accordance with the above general principles, I still believe that there being two teams in Ireland, if you (or your parents/grandparents) are born within the territory/jurisdiction of one Association, you should represent that Association, but if you are born within the territory/jurisdiction of the other, then you should represent the other Association.
Of course, I don't expect you to agree, or even like, that stance, but I would hope you can accept that it is consistent, even principled.