Oscar Traynor Cup 2008/09

**abbeyvale** · 28/10/2008, 8:28 AM

Originally Posted by oscar

Gilmartin,Sherlock,Goggin,Cummins(AA) McGarry,Hartnett,Purcell,Boyle,Phelan(Pike) Sheehan,Mullins,Russell(Regional) Grant,Harrington(Fairview) Burke(Mungret) D Ryan(Boro) Guerin(Balla) Heffernan(Kilmallock)

Is Phelan even starting for Pike?

**abbeyvale** · 28/10/2008, 8:29 AM

Originally Posted by oscar

Gilmartin,Sherlock,Goggin,Cummins(AA) McGarry,Hartnett,Purcell,Boyle,Phelan(Pike) Sheehan,Mullins,Russell(Regional) Grant,Harrington(Fairview) Burke(Mungret) D Ryan(Boro) Guerin(Balla) Heffernan(Kilmallock)

1 Keeper?

**the dazzler** · 28/10/2008, 9:14 AM

Originally Posted by abbeyvale

1 Keeper?

2keepers gilmartin+russell

**abbeyvale** · 28/10/2008, 9:38 AM

Originally Posted by the dazzler

2keepers gilmartin+russell

Sorry, didnt know the Regional's keepers name.

A lot of good players not in the squad!!!!!!!

**Football Alien** · 28/10/2008, 1:32 PM

Originally Posted by abbeyvale

Sorry, didnt know the Regional's keepers name.

A lot of good players not in the squad!!!!!!!

is it a case that he's going with the bones of the squad he had from last year, and maybe some players just cant or dont want to commit to it?, theres a lot of quality players not on it!!

**tedd11** · 28/10/2008, 3:04 PM

you will always have the argument that there is not alot of quality players in it.everybody has there own opinion like every year about who should and should not be in the squad.afterall they only lost the final by a penalty shootout lastyear.you could put out 2 squads from limerick that would be as good as each other.last years squad performed better than the last few years before so i dont think its much of a suprise that he picked most of the same players.

**oscar** · 28/10/2008, 9:13 PM

Originally Posted by abbeyvale

Is Phelan even starting for Pike?

is McGarry?

**Football MaD** · 28/10/2008, 10:17 PM

Heffernan isnt having a great start to the season with kilmallock, maybe he will come into his own sooner or later.

**Fairkop** · 28/10/2008, 11:40 PM

Originally Posted by oscar

is McGarry?

is d.ryan.:

**abbeyvale** · 29/10/2008, 7:40 AM

Originally Posted by Fairkop

is d.ryan.:

Interesting to see that Leo Wong was playing football in Div 1A last season and was getting in the OT TEAM, but yet this season he is playing regular Premier football and doesnt even make the SQUAD!!!!!

**dared** · 29/10/2008, 7:54 AM

Originally Posted by abbeyvale

Interesting to see that Leo Wong was playing football in Div 1A last season and was getting in the OT TEAM, but yet this season he is playing regular Premier football and doesnt even make the SQUAD!!!!!

Leo's a nice guy but you cant tell me he's OT quality...

**abbeyvale** · 29/10/2008, 8:02 AM

Originally Posted by dared

Leo's a nice guy but you cant tell me he's OT quality...

There are better players than him around, but it just seems strange that he didnt make the squad this season when he played so well for them last season!!!!

**dared** · 29/10/2008, 8:06 AM

Originally Posted by abbeyvale

There are better players than him around, but it just seems strange that he didnt make the squad this season when he played so well for them last season!!!!

Its strange alright.

**Football Alien** · 29/10/2008, 8:40 AM

Originally Posted by abbeyvale

There are better players than him around, but it just seems strange that he didnt make the squad this season when he played so well for them last season!!!!

saw him play a couple of times this yr, dunno is he prem standard to be honest, seemed to struggle when ive seen him

**Goals4fun** · 29/10/2008, 8:46 AM

Originally Posted by striker 9

a few of us didnt want to play this year its a waste of time

it is a pity to call it that. Whatever players may think it is, it is a chance to represent your league.
The team was unlucky last year, it was well run, so it could hardly be called a waste of time.....

**Abbey Road** · 29/10/2008, 9:54 AM

Originally Posted by Goals4fun

it is a pity to call it that. Whatever players may think it is, it is a chance to represent your league.
The team was unlucky last year, it was well run, so it could hardly be called a waste of time.....

Can't understand anyone that would think it is a waste of time.Everyone has their own opinion but at the end of the day it is a chance to represent your city so i think you should take the oppurtunity when it arises and be proud of the fact that you have got picked.

**Football Alien** · 29/10/2008, 10:01 AM

Originally Posted by Goals4fun

it is a pity to call it that. Whatever players may think it is, it is a chance to represent your league.
The team was unlucky last year, it was well run, so it could hardly be called a waste of time.....

to be fair it was prob the only thing that was run well by the ldmc last year!, i know they have a tough job to do to keep everyone happy but at the end of the day its just not good enough!

**widow** · 29/10/2008, 10:23 AM

To be fair in years gone by it has been a joke but speaking to a few of the players in it last year they thought that it was well run. So if thats the case then it's definately not a waste of time. It's still a shop window which the irish junior manager uses to see players. Good luck to the team again this year, hopefully we'll go one better than last year. This is the squad for the first game we'll see changes to the squad for each game. Every player in town should be looking to get into the squad as its recognition for how well your doing for your club.

**HuRya** · 29/10/2008, 1:30 PM

Originally Posted by oscar

Gilmartin,Sherlock,Goggin,Cummins(AA) McGarry,Hartnett,Purcell,Boyle,Phelan(Pike) Sheehan,Mullins,Russell(Regional) Grant,Harrington(Fairview) Burke(Mungret) D Ryan(Boro) Guerin(Balla) Heffernan(Kilmallock)

only 12 of these players are playing regularly week in week out for their clubs...