Quote:
Originally Posted by
elatedscum
1. Bazunu/Kelleher
2. Doherty
3. O’Shea
4. Egan
5. Collins
6. McClean
7. Cullen
8. Molumby
9. Knight/Smallbone/Sykes/McGrath
10. Ferguson
11. Obafemi/Parrott
I think I’d be confident in knowing for sure 8 of my starting 11 against France, probably even 9.
I was texting mates the other day and suggested 8 are certs.
I'm wondering something vs France. If we take that they'll have some variation of Mbappé, Griezemann, Thuram and Coman, possibly all 4, but unlikely...would Andy Omabamidele be the best bet to 'mark' Mbappé in terms of a foot-race? OShea is no slouch, but Nathan Collins absolutely has a weakness on the turn - I'd see it as possibly his only serious weakness - and that Doherty in front of him takes the edge away from Doc's play, which is in that inside right channel in the defensive half and the outside right channel in the offensive half.
I'm not suggesting we drop Collins, Egan probably won't because he's captain and a very good threat in the opposition box, but perhaps we might see Omabamidele, Collins, Egan as the three (in that order)?
Quote:
X??Doherty
O’Shea
Egan
Collins
McClean
?Cullen
Molumby
X??Ferguson ?X
Against Latvia, I’d plan to play two different formations. I’d play the first half in a 5-3-2 and the second half in a 4-3-3. What we’ve found is that against weaker sides - once we score, 5-3-2 is successful but when teams sit deep, and we don’t score early, we can struggle to break them down. So I think going forward, being able to play both systems would help avoid most of those calamity results or near misses.
Totally agree.
Quote:
GK: I’d start with Kelleher in goal for the Latvia game. I’d very likely start Bazunu for the France game but I’d make that call after the Latvia game was over. If for some reason, Kelleher managed to perform so well that it changed my opinion. Don’t see it as being likely but no harm in having the info
I don't see a huge amount of difference between either keeper in a pure defensive capacity - I think that i'm more nervous with Gav under crosses, but that may not have any basis in fact. But I absolutely believe that Caoimhin is the better footballing goalkeeper. What might sound like illogical ways of picking a side, while I'd fully accept the jersey is Gav's to lose, I'd pick Kelleher vs Latvia, and if showed that he's not rusty, I'd nearly pick him vs France. (but that's biased as I do like him).
RWB: Doherty - he probably needs minutes against Latvia, but not too many. He struggles with fitness when playing 2 games in a short space of time, no point on burning him out. So I’d play him and switch him for Coleman after 55 mins. I don’t fancy Mbappe taking on Coleman and the pace differential, so I think Doc is the only option. I’d play 5 at the back and try have your wing back and your right sided centre half (O’Shea) double up on Mbappe. Same on the other side with Coman or Kolo Muani or whoever will be playing right wing. Then just hope that the space that their fullbacks get at a result doesn’t cost us too much. But generally the real danger France have comes from the 3 behind Giroud - the two wingers and Griezmann.
Quote:
RCB - O’Shea - I’d start Omobamidele against Latvia to give him minutes and to see how he looks after the injury but I think O’Shea is the starter for the France game. Coleman is playing really well of late and is an option but I do think he’s a better right back than a right wing back or right centre half.
CB - Egan - will probably captain the side. I’d start him against Latvia and take him off after 45 and bring on a winger and move to a back 4. He doesn’t need the minutes particularly.
LCB - Collins - get him 90 mins against Latvia and again against France.
I think we're wasting time putting Nathan anywhere else but the stopper/central cog of the three. Egan is quite comfortable as the lcb and given that we're weak at lwb, his organistion and reading would be preferable there. I've been as big a supporter of John Egan if not more than anyone here for a very long time, but I think the sooner we get the three kids bedded in together the better. Not suggesting that vs France, but I'd like to see it become the staple by the end of the campaign, fitness willing.
Quote:
LWB - McClean. I haven’t seen a huge amount of O’Dowda at LWB but I’d trust McClean a bit more defensively and that he’d be a bit more fight about him which we’ll probably need against the french. I’d start O’Dowda against the Latvians and bring on McClean at the same time as Coleman, in part because McClean is probably better at left back.
I don't like him and I don't trust him. If we had a willing replacement at RWB, I'd pick Doc here. We don't so I'd pick ODowda, purely because he's not McClean.
Quote:
RCM - Molumby would start for me against France. It’s between him and Hendrick and I’d value the extra bite, energy and athleticism he provides. Hendrick probably to come on when Molumby is at risk of getting a second yellow.
??CM - Cullen. I’d wrap him in cotton wool for the Latvia game given his current workload and his lack of a viable replacement. I’d start Smallbone along with Hendrick in the Latvia game.
I actually don't think this is a decision anymore, I think Jayson and Josh are the two recognised starting midfielders for this campaign, regardless of the circumstances. I've a hard-on for Molumby, I don't hide it.
Quote:
LCM - the more attacking midfielder - i’d most likely start Knight for the france game - and probably Sykes for the Latvia game - but i’m undecided. All of Knight, Smallbone, Sykes, McGrath and Browne offer different qualities. Browne would be the most conservative (aeriel ability, aggression and goal threat) and probably the only one I’d be against. McGrath has been widely slated here but his performances for Ireland have been good. And he has qualities as a composed carrier of the ball, linking midfield and attack, with more vision than any of the other midfielders (a low bar).
Was thinking about McGrath. Club career in the ****ter, but hasn't been poor for ireland and was very good when we were good in portugal. I'd pick Knight here though. And I like Alan Browne. He has a f*ck up in him, but he gets into good positions and like it or not, he's our only scoring midfielder who arguably should have had more.
But it has to be Knight. He's just too...everything! to not start him - when our likely success will be from placing them under serious pressure on and off the ball - would be a mistake.
Quote:
ST - Ferguson starts for me. I’d give him 70 minutes against Latvia (before being replaced by Obafemi) and I’d start him again against France. Hard to know who is his best partner. I liked the Obafemi-Parrott pairing, I felt they had great understanding - but you can’t ignore Evan. Only problem is that you’ve got to create a partnership on the fly. ??ST - I’d start Parrott against Latvia and give him 45 minutes before bringing on Ogbene for the 4-3-3 switch. So basically game begins with a Ferguson-Parrott pair, before turning into a Ogbene-Ferguson-Johnston front 3 with Obafemi replacing Ferguson for the last 20. Obafemi needs minutes but I’d be more afraid of him picking up a knock against Latvia. He has a terrible knack of getting injured on the first game of an international window. I kinda fear Kenny might see Keane as the ideal partner for Ferguson. I hope not - but I can imagine Keane sitting deeper is something that might appeal to Kenny, the number 10 to Ferguson’s no. 9. Anyway, i’d make a call between Parrott and Obafemi after the Latvia game, seeing how they both looked.
Ferguson absolutely. And the partnership is a vital point that cannot be dismissed. I was stunned by how isolated Ev was for the 21s the couple of times I saw him, to the point where I'd nearly consider him playing slightly withdrawn and leave the partner as the runner. He needs ball into feet, and while I think this would be Troy's best position, I don't think Parrot can start as much as I like him, and with Idah out, it's a straight choice between Cheodzie or Obafemi. I'd be inclined to go with Obafemi, but wouldn't be disappointed with Ogbene either. I think with Ogbene on one side and Knight on the other, it probably keeps france a bit more honest.
Quote:
So it’d end up with:
- Latvia First half:
Kelleher
Doherty
Omobamidele
Egan
Collins
O’Dowda
Hendrick
Smallbone
Sykes or McGrath
Parrott
Ferguson
Latvia Second half:
Kelleher
Coleman (after 55)
Omobamidele
Collins
McClean (after 55)
Same midfield with Knight coming in after 70
Ogbene
Ferguson (replaced by Obafemi after 70
Johnston
France:
Bazunu/Kelleher
Doherty
O’Shea
Egan
Collins
McClean
Cullen
Molumby
Knight/Sykes/McGrath
Parrott/Obafemi
Ferguson
Thanks be to god some good posts to consider, thanks ES.