Printable View
First half I thought Celtic played some decent enough stuff to be honest. 2nd half was a completely different story where Rangers tightened the grip on midfield and Celtic did nothing of note.
Aiden was quiet as you rightly say but he got a few decent balls in.
Lets face it, its not unusual for a game between the top sides in any league to be a dull affair, look at 'grandslam sunday' for example;)
McGeady's been giving the Motherwell fullback "a roasting" so far according to radio commentary.
Vennegoor hit the bar from a McGeady cross.
Maybe i am alone but i really really dont see him matching his potential at Celtic.
I sincerely hope that he moves during the summer. IMO Celtic have had their golden years over the past 5 or so years and will now be back in the shaddow o Rangers for the next few years. Only my opinion though
i'd like to see him go on the continent, ideally Spain or Italy. He'll probably play it safe and go to Liverpool or somewhere though.
He would really suit Spain. Even a good exciting team like Villareal or Getafe would do. In Spain he would plenty the time and space to show what he can do.Quote:
Originally Posted by boovidge
But i agree he will probably end up in England, but i have my doubts it will be a top 4. Think the best he can hope for is Spurs, Everton or Newcastle
Quote:
Originally Posted by eirebhoy
McGeady as expected has made the shortlist of 4 for the PFA SPL
Player of the Year
'PFA Scotland chief executive Fraser Wishart said: 'This is the top award for players. There is no greater honour in football than to be voted the best player in your country by your fellow professionals.' :)
"your country" refers to the country the players play in ;)
How is our wee legend getting on? We should not forget about him.
I wouldn't call him a legend, yet. At the moment he's somewhere in between a leg-end and a legend.Quote:
Originally Posted by BigmanCas
Watched the Motherwell game instead of the boring Liverpool vs Blackburn game. McGeady was the usual curate's egg: good in parts but does run up blind alleys a lot and loses possession frequently. Admittedly the pitch didn't suit him but he's not the real deal YET.
That was the McGeady of this time last season. Poor performance and the full back definitely had the better of him. Terrible pitch though and Strachan certainly wouldn't have started him on that pitch last season.
And arguably the last 6-8 weeks or so.................Quote:
Originally Posted by eirebhoy
Aye he hasn't been great the past couple of months. Still setting up plenty of chances though.
Do you now speak like a Scotsman as well, och aye?Quote:
Originally Posted by eirebhoy
McGeady got the young player of the year award there this morning. Willo Flood got the goal of the season award as well.
Flood goal here, not great quality thoughQuote:
Originally Posted by Fr. Murphy
Flood's finish isn't spectacular, but the build up is impressive
It's the perfect finish Tets.
What else can Flood do but strike it beautifully with a nice bend on it and hit the back of the net..
Helped a bit by the only defender jumping out of the way:)
think I meant the finish wasn't great in comparison to the build up, if you just saw the finish you wouldn't think it would win goal of the seasonQuote:
Originally Posted by geysir
remember Kinkladze's goal for City against Southampton ages ago when he beat half the team and ended up with a tap in? Same thing, if you just saw the finish, you wouldn't think it was a great goal
A couple of months ago McGeady was hot favourite to win the main award but Celtic's dip in form has cost him as they fell behind Rangers in the title race.Quote:
Originally Posted by Fr. Murphy
I would say a large reason behind Celtic's dip was because of Aiden's dip.Quote:
Originally Posted by Maroon 7
As Aiden as gone, so has Celtic this year.
Ffs it says a lot about the (lack of) quality in the SPL if that was the best goal they could find in the entire season. I've seen better goals scored in Sunday league.Quote:
Originally Posted by tetsujin1979
That must be some sunday league team!!!Quote:
Originally Posted by youngirish
Poor performance last night by McGeady. He should have been rested earlier in the season.
Yes but as per usual they doubled up on him all the time. In the first half particularly Whittaker came to Broadfoot's aid all the time. His final ball was poor though when he did get an opportunity to get it in. He beat Novo with ease at times in the second half but have to agree he's looking jaded.
Strachan got away with his gamble last night in taking Robson off but the boo's said it all. Robson was probably Celtics best player. The front 2 were a joke. Cuellar had Hesselink in his pocket. When Strachan goes the new managers first task should be removing Hesselinks £28k a week wages from the wage bill.
Actually I suppose that post should be in the SPL discussion thread.
Was very disappointed with McGeady last night. After reading here that he's finally delivering decent crosses, I was unpleasantly surprised to see him hit the first defender time after time with his crosses. Although he did put in one great cross for Samaras. But out of so many attempts, thats a poor return.
He doesn't seem to have much football intelligence. He picked the wrong option again and again last night. He passed to Wilson when he should have crossed, he ran at the defenders when he had no support and got dispossessed, he shot when there wasn't a hope he'd score. Very poor indeed
Just take into account that that was McGeady off form. The McGeady of August - February is the one for the future. Last season he was in form only up until October so it's a big improvement.
Watched my second ever SPL game last night. The football was a vast improvement on the game a week or so ago and (worryingly :D) I must say I enjoyed it.Quote:
Originally Posted by lionelhutz
I was hoping to see McGeady playing well after the last disappointing performance against Rangers but I thought he was actually worse last night even though he did track back to cover a few times.
I agree 100% with the above assessment from lionelhutz. He may be jaded as suggested above but Rangers certainly had sussed out his limitations. Intelligent players can vary their game when the situation demands but last night, particularly in the second half when in the space of about 5 minutes he lost the ball three times by running directly at and into the defender losing the ball each time, you have to query if he can do it at the top level.
Rangers are not world beaters but are a fairly well organised team and if McGeady can be found out playing them he will certainly be found out at international level. It might also help if he beefed up a bit, just too easily knocked off the ball.
I hope I am wrong and when he plays for us that he rams this back down my throat but I cannot see what all the fuss is about with him, he is average at best.
A friend of mine watched the Old Firm game and talked to me about it (he's a Spurs fan), and told me that he hoped Ramos would go after McGeady.
He said he was very impressed with his play despite being double marked.
Although I love watching McGeady play, I don't think I've ever mentioned him to him, so he pointed this out to me without any prompting.
For a guy who doesn't watch the SPL that often to point him out as a player he'd like for his team say a lot to me. This guy knows his football too.
I know some of us can get on McGeady's back a bit, because we expect so much, but he was identified by Rangers as Celtic's main danger, and was marked by two athletic right backs that gave him very little space.....he still made some good runs with the ball and acted as an excellent outlet for Celtic at times.
Not the finished article just yet, but far from the dire player advertised by many on this forum.
is this to do with the pace of the game, as in the SPL would be a slower pace than international and therefore when under pressure in a game like that against rangers where the pace would be greater he wouldn't be up to it i.e. he needs more time to think?Quote:
Originally Posted by lionelhutz
Wheres BMC to give his objectivity?
Watched the match and didn't have any real problems with McGeady's performance. Rangers doubled marked him; if he was playing in the Spurs team for example, opposing side would find it very difficult to allocate two men to him as Spurs have other quick attacking wingers, such as Lennon who would be provided with too much space. Celtic seemed over reliant on him at times and perhaps used him as an outlet with too much regularity. I fully believe he will go on to play at a higher level than the SPL and contrary to popular belief this may be when we see the very best out of him, playing and training with better players on better surfaces.
What do you mean by pace exactly? I'd say international football would be a breath of fresh air for McGeady after being closed down so quickly by 2 players every week. He'll be coming up against much better players with Ireland but he'll get more time and space on the ball. The SPL is 100 mile an hour at the best of times.Quote:
Originally Posted by paul_oshea
Will be interesting to see if he holds out in Scotland for another year or makes the move in the summer.
Out of general interest.Quote:
Originally Posted by eirebhoy
Do the statistics prove that they cover more ground in an SPL game than in other games - internationals or EPL games?
Or, are we talking about the wrong type of running? :)
Premiership is one of the fastest leagues in the world, if not the fastest. I'd say you'd need to be fitter playing in Britain than anywhere else. Someone like Donati has been a success at most Serie A clubs he's been with, playing as a deep lying playmaker. In Scotland he gets closed down so quickly and just can't get used to that.Quote:
Originally Posted by geysir
Agreed with all that. He's being double marked all the time now and while it's affecting some of his performances it should be making room elsewhere on the pitch but Celtic aren't using that at the moment.Quote:
Originally Posted by livehead1
Still don't think he was that bad the other night either. Had a bad spell when it went 1-1 but overall he was fine, just not great. Funnily enough most of the Scottish papers seemed to give him 8 out of 10 and had him as Celtic's best player. Didn't see it like that myself but he certainly wasn't awful.
McGeady won the PFA Player of the Year and the PFA Young Player of the Year awards tonight.
I think he needs to move away from the SPL, only if he can get European football though. Being double marked the whole time is not doing him any good and he would be better off in a stronger side where the opposition won't have this luxury.Quote:
Originally Posted by Wolfie