Munster Junior Cup 2006/07

Printable View

Show 40 post(s) from this thread on one page

29/03/2007, 10:49 AM
Tipp Man 2

Quote:

Originally Posted by backodanet

is it the centre half ken kiely did he sign for limerick from cobh?? his profile in the CTFC website says he won the munster senior in 06

http://www.clonmeltownfc.com/profiles/kkiely.html

I was speaking to a pike man and aparently the protest is two fold, first as outlined above kenneth kiely played in munster senior cup and also FAI senior cup for limerick(against drogheda) and secondly Alan Coady( striker) was sent off against st Michaels 2 weeks ago and clonmel never had a game in between michaels and pike game therefore he never served the automatic one match ban which is mandatoty... they had a game scheduled but they got a walk over from st nicolas but seeminly the TS&DL committee never met in between to officially give a walkover(points haven't been awarded on website yet)..

If both are true clonmel are in trouble.. you have to question how the h*ll their committeee and secretary made this mistake !!! its a pity to see this but rules are rules and are there for everyone...
29/03/2007, 11:27 AM
Noddy

when will the objection be heard?
29/03/2007, 11:32 AM
see's it

mick noonan is chairman of the ldmc a week and pike have an objection gone in already its a funny old world.a team gets knocked out of a cup these days and the first thing they do is appeal it,junior football is becoming a fiasco
29/03/2007, 11:34 AM
backodanet

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tipp Man 2

how the h*ll their committeee and secretary made this mistake !!!

Unbelievable

as regards the rule about ex LOI players i don't think its anything to do with what competitions a player played in its about when the players were "regraded" as junior players they had to recieve permision from the FAI, Local League and the munster concil to play in their respective competitions
the Munster concil did not give that permission so that is why the likes of Derek McCarthy, Davy Ryan and Shane Guerin cannot play
29/03/2007, 12:19 PM
gaidin

Quote:

Originally Posted by see's it

mick noonan is chairman of the ldmc a week and pike have an objection gone in already its a funny old world.

Whats that got to do with anything. If what is being said is true than Pike have every right to object.

Clonmel broke the rules so why not object.
29/03/2007, 12:24 PM
leather

If both alegations are proven too be true, the best of luck to pike...
29/03/2007, 12:51 PM
see's it

are ye not sick of hearing about appeals?
29/03/2007, 1:02 PM
young boy

people may be sick of appeals but if clubs are breaking the rules they should be punished. if thats the case pike should have played McCarthy and balla should play there 2 lads.

clonmel should get thrown out and pike back in.
29/03/2007, 1:12 PM
silvercircle

Quote:

Originally Posted by see's it

are ye not sick of hearing about appeals?

People are sick of appeals, however would you expect pike to let it go...if illegal players were fielded, then the rules were broken, tell me a club that would not appeal on these grounds..(and I dont mean the length of the pitch)
29/03/2007, 1:16 PM
leather

Low blow S/Circle... Pitch dim's are part of the rules too.....
29/03/2007, 1:44 PM
see's it

something has to be done about EL players playing junior the rule is obviously not clear its popped up afew times recently maybe the new LDMC might sort it,we live in hope.......
im sick of objections there was a big 1 in 3B recently
29/03/2007, 1:58 PM
young boy

its not the ldmc. it is the munster council who has this rule. if a player plays more than 5 senior games in the eircom league they cannot play munster junior.

this rule is a bit stupid as u can still play fai no matter how many games you play in the eircom league.
29/03/2007, 3:35 PM
Town Fan

Objection

Kenneth Kiely was ok to play as he is an U-21 player. The rule only appliers if you are over 21. In relation to Alan Coady, it is a tricky one. Town got a walkover so they can argue that this counts as a game as it wasn't postponed.
Just have to wait and see
29/03/2007, 5:24 PM
MitreSize5

thats very thin ice they're walking on there
30/03/2007, 7:18 AM
Tipp Man 2

Quote:

Originally Posted by Town Fan

Kenneth Kiely was ok to play as he is an U-21 player. The rule only appliers if you are over 21. In relation to Alan Coady, it is a tricky one. Town got a walkover so they can argue that this counts as a game as it wasn't postponed.
Just have to wait and see

they got a walk over but was it "officially ratified " by the TS& DL..points and games still have NOT been applied on website http://www.tsdl.ie/league.asp.. its a tricky one !!!
30/03/2007, 7:25 AM
backodanet

Quote:

Originally Posted by Town Fan

Kenneth Kiely was ok to play as he is an U-21 player. The rule only appliers if you are over 21.

so is davy ryan from Balla and he is not allowed to play ???
30/03/2007, 8:17 AM
Hoops 1967

In my opion if you played league of Ireland in 2006 you should not be allowed to play junior football until the 2007/2008 season, the fact that you can go from playing LOI in november and then go and play in the FAI junior cup in december is a joke.
30/03/2007, 8:18 AM
leather

Kenneth Kiely was ok to play as he is an U-21 player. The rule only appliers if you are over 21.

If You play 5 or more senior games it does not matter what age you are...
30/03/2007, 8:21 AM
young boy

i think the rule is if you are under 21 it still does not make a difference. if clonmel get away with this and kiely is left play then surely balla can play there guy no.
30/03/2007, 8:32 AM
gaidin

Quote:

Originally Posted by leather

Kenneth Kiely was ok to play as he is an U-21 player. The rule only appliers if you are over 21.

If You play 5 or more senior games it does not matter what age you are...

I think Ken Kiely did play more than 5 games for the senior team though.

So he would have been illegal.

Show 40 post(s) from this thread on one page