Originally Posted by
GavinZac
No it isn't. "Extremists" (arguably, people who follow scripture, but for that post, see above) are committing their acts FOR religion. Her point, and now mine, is that Hitler and Pol Pot did not commit mass murder FOR vegetarianism.
You're being silly. I think its the guys writing Freakonomics who coined the phrased "correlation is not causality". However, nobody said it did in this case. Unless their vegetarianism justified them killing people (it'd be a strange type of vegetarianism, eh?) it would have no bearing on whether he turned out to be a war lord or a fiddle player.
My own view isn't that religion is the cause of all the problems in the world; human nature is. For one, we wouldn't so readily subscribe to such tripe as Jesus walking on water or quetzalcoatl leading an immortal army of white men into tenochtitlan if it wasn't for the facet of human nature related to craving acceptance in a group. Does that mean that religion is an inevitable byproduct of this? No, its not. Religion came about as an answer to the gaps in our knowledge - where did we come from, where did this bountiful world come from, what happens when we die? Because at the time, the only creators we knew about were ourselves, we personified the answers to these questions - some mighty powerful being must have created all this, and i bet he's waiting for us when we die, because after making all this he's not going to let us rot in the ground, right?
Those gaps are now relatively minuscule. We know where we came from, we know where this world came from, and we have a damn good idea as to what happens when we die. Yet irrationalists still abuse those ever shrinking gaps, squeezing the last drop of power out of selling a utopian ideal of everyone who ever lived, save for the bad guys, flouncing about "in the presence of God". Because that's all that remains, for anyone exposed to the outside world - the fear of dying and of our loved ones dying being allayed by this hope, sold to us for a euro a week and our sanity.
Ignoring the outright idiots like the people who think we should ignore global warming because we're all being carted off to heaven within 50 years anyway (these happen to be elected idiots in the USA) or the ones who think thinking really hard about saving your loved one is better than giving them a blood transfusion, removing religion would give us one less thing to kill each other for. I'd be glad of this even if it didn't solve all our problems.
Congrats on the reducto ad hitlerum, though.
Bookmarks