Who do you think are the most overrated members of the Irish squad?

**Shedender81** · 10/03/2008, 2:47 PM

McGeady... Would he play for a Top 4 side in England... NO !!

Ashley Young or McGeady who would you rather playing wide for Ireland...

**Seagull-4-life** · 10/03/2008, 2:50 PM

I don't think there are any over-rated players because in all seriousness, the majority of fans think they're all s***e.
Given and Dunne are probably the only players who haven't been abused on this site.

**tetsujin1979** · 10/03/2008, 2:59 PM

Originally Posted by Shedender81

McGeady... Would he play for a Top 4 side in England... NO !!

Ashley Young or McGeady who would you rather playing wide for Ireland...

Current Top 4 in England:
Arsenal: wanted McGeady as a youth, he's a more natural winger than Eboue ever will be, he's a better record in the Champion's League than Rosicky does.
Man United: Noone on Earth would get in ahead of Ronaldo at the moment, Giggs is past his best and McGeady would easily be an understudy to him on the left
Chelsea: don't really play with wingers anyway, but McGeady is more of a wide player than Cole, and would be ahead of Wright-Phillips on the bench on recent form
Liverpool: Are you really trying to tell me Pennant and Kewell are better than McGeady? Babel is a stronger player, but I think he'll end up as a striker anyway

**jmurphyc** · 10/03/2008, 4:07 PM

Originally Posted by Shedender81

McGeady... Would he play for a Top 4 side in England... NO !!

Ashley Young or McGeady who would you rather playing wide for Ireland...

Would Richard Dunne or Shay Given get into one of the top four sides? I would like to think so but the managers of the sides might have different ideas. People need to stop talking about this top four sh*t and harping back to the days when our players played for the very best sides. Football has changed a lot since then; how many foreigners were there in England in those days? FFS look at Barnsley the other night - even they had a variety of nationalities in their team.

**Razors left peg** · 10/03/2008, 4:43 PM

Originally Posted by Shedender81

McGeady... Would he play for a Top 4 side in England... NO !!

Ashley Young or McGeady who would you rather playing wide for Ireland...

McGeady would walk into the current Liverpool team. Arsenal yesterday ended up playing Kolo Toure in second half and they often have Eboue playing there, I think Mcgeady is better option than both. He is a better player in my opinion than Nani, Park,Fletcher and at this stage of his career Giggs(and Im a Man U fan)

**Seagull-4-life** · 10/03/2008, 6:52 PM

Originally Posted by Razors left peg

McGeady would walk into the current Liverpool team. Arsenal yesterday ended up playing Kolo Toure in second half and they often have Eboue playing there, I think Mcgeady is better option than both. He is a better player in my opinion than Nani, Park,Fletcher and at this stage of his career Giggs(and Im a Man U fan)

Spot on