Are you sure about that? I thought it was you automatically missed your next competitive game, no matter what competition... I can't find the FAI J C rules on the web. But the Munster Junior cup states:Originally Posted by hacker
Any player sent off in a match in these competitions automatically incurs a suspension from the next competitive club match. A player sent from the field of play shall serve an automatic suspension at the same level of club football. (i.e. a player sent from the field of play in a 1st team fixture may not serve an automatic suspension in a reserve team fixture and vice-verse) Following receipt of the referees report the disciplinary committee may at its discretion extend the duration of the suspension and / or impose fines.
NOTE: There is no appeal against an automatic suspension except in the case of mistaken identity.
”That should be NO problem for the defence – OH NOOOO!!”
George Hamilton...
http://www.innishvilla.com
The rules are DEFINATELY: If a player is sent off in a Munster Junior or FAI Junior Cup game and their team go through to the next round of that competition then they are SUSPENDED for the next round,but if you go out its the next league game
OK... No need to SHOUT...
The bold writing I put up was directly from the Munster Football Association website http://homepage.eircom.net/~munfa/ go to the link click on competitions link and in general cup rules it states the above. I thought it reads like you automatically miss your next competitive match no matter what competition, if I have misunderstood the wording fair enough...
”That should be NO problem for the defence – OH NOOOO!!”
George Hamilton...
http://www.innishvilla.com
wasn't shouting,just making it as clear as i could
[A}[A] above is your interpretation it is not what is written in the rule book
[B]A player sent from the field of play shall serve an automatic suspension at the same level of club football. (i.e. a player sent from the field of play in a 1st team fixture may not serve an automatic suspension in a reserve team fixture and vice-verse
B] above is what is written in the rule book.
[B}above refers to serving a suspension at the same level i.e "ist team" in other words not a "reserve team".It does not mention anything about what competition the suspension is to be served in.
I believe that your interpretation is what is generally accepted as being meant but nevertheless that rule does not say it and therefore is open to other interpretation.
[B} is as far as I know a direct quote from the new FAI rules now inserted in the MFA rules but was adopted by the FAI with Eircom League in mind to avoid guys suspended for their ist teams counting their own clubs reserve teams matches as complying with the 1 match suspension???
Therefore to comply with the letter of the rule the next match means exactly that,a league or any cup match,as long as it is not a reserve match?????
Last edited by shelbourne1904; 08/11/2007 at 2:37 PM.
"You'll not see nothing like the Shelbourne team"
This is from the FAI Junior Cup Rule Book
Rule 16 paragraph 5
"A player who receives a red card in an F.A.I. Junior Cup tie will stand suspended for a minimum for one game in the next round in the competition if his team advances; if his team is eliminated from the competition he stands suspended for a minimum of one game in his next competitive game.
The one game suspension may not be appealed.
A player sent from the field of play in a 1st team match shall not serve an automatic suspension in a reserve team match. Following receipt of the Referees report the relevant disciplinary body may at their discretion extend the duration of the suspension and/or impose a fine."
Smile........ it confuses people
so after all the rambling summervilleman to answer question, the two people sent off are suspended for the next game in that competetion.
so if they were sent off in the league then there are suspended from the next league game or more depending on severity of punishment recieved and are eligable to play in a cup games.
if its was a cup game they are suspended from the next round of that cup or more depending on severity but are eligable to play in league games and other cups.
but if you lost the last cup game then its the first competitive game after that the player serves the suspension....
hopefully this is correct but knowing this forum someone will differ
4th rd drw
Aisling v athlunkard
herbertstown v Carew Pk
regional v Ballynanty
Star v killmallock
Pike v sville
Thats not the draw because Pike are definitley at home to Summerville
sorry meant to say Pike are at home to Carew Park
UMBRO FAI JUNIOR CUP FOURTH ROUND DRAW
(TO BE PLAYED WEEKEND 24th/25th NOVEMBER
Galway Area
Mervue United V Corrib Rangers
St Patricks V Salthill Devon
Dynamo Blues V West United
Mayo Area
Swinford F.C V Westport United
Moyvilla F.C V Castlebar Celtic
Manulla F.C. V Charlestown Athletic
Ballina Town V Urlaur United
Sligo-Leitrm/Roscommon Area
Boyle Celtic V Strand Celtic
Ballinasloe Town V Castlerea Cel or Manorhamilton Rngs
Abbey United V Lisnamult Celtic
Never play leapfrog with a unicorn!!
Where are ye getting the FOURTH ROUND DRAW from ??
Any1 Know the Tipperary draw ??
All I know is that Clonmel Town are away to Peake Villa
CORK AREA:
Springfield v Everton “B”
Castleview F.C. v Richmond F.C.
Avondale Utd v Leeds F.C.
St.Mary’s or Kinsale v Village Utd. “A”
Ballincollig v Douglas Hall M.S.L.
Park Utd. v Grattan Utd or Wilton Utd.
Carrigaline or Marlboro Trust v Ballyphehane Clt.
LIMERICK AREA:
Star Rovers v Herbertstown
Summerville F.C. v Ballynanty Rovers
Aisling Annacotty v Regional Utd.
Kilmallock v Athlunkard Villa
Pike Rovers v Carew Park
TIPPERARY-W.W.E.C.:
Cahir Park v Thurles Town
Cloughjordan v Bansha or St.Michaels
Peakvilla v Clonmel Town
Arra Rovers v Clonmel Celtic
DESMOND-CLARE-KERRY:
Tralee Dynamoes v Listowel Clt.
Newtown v Abbeyfeale Utd.
Lisselton Rovers v Newcastle WEST
Rathkeale Utd. v Killarney Clt.
Inter Kenmare v Bunratty F.C.
WATERFORD:
Dungarvan Utd. v Southend
Carrick Utd. v Waterford Crystal
Last edited by Bossman; 08/11/2007 at 10:51 PM.
One of the easier drws IMO,Clonmel got a very tough game..
I'd still expect Clonmel Town to come through the game.
one of the easier draws - against a carew team that beat us farily comprehensively at the start of the year
They will be missing a few players for what ever reasons.. you have added some quality players since that defeat...home banker for pike imo
fair play to you leather .... a bit like the sun newspaper .... build us up and then go straight for the troat when the inevitable happens
to be compared to that piece of S**t that pretends to be a newspaper, is a bit below the belt..
you have to be favourites.....just look at the form since they beat you early doors in the season...
Posting Permissions
Bookmarks