Quotebooster is a summerville man!Originally Posted by the only 1
dont worry there was none for balla
booster is a summerville man!
they defo didnt ask anyone from S'ville
There was actually but they turned them down!
i take it davy ryan was 1 and if they had any sense Dunphy was asked
These Junior folks just don't quit do they
do you not think he'd be good enough for EL?
He's been there done that and worn the substitutes bib
Don't get me wrong, he would do as a squad player if you were badly, badly stuck for players (Which we could well be) but you will NEVER EVER win anything at Eircom League level with players of his quality in your team
his a better player then tommy barrett and his gone to rovers
If you genuinely think he's a better player than Tommy Barrett maybe football isn't your game
Dunphys isn't fit to lace Tommys boots
I've seen them both play LOI
Tommy excelled, Dunphy was excrement
all tommy is,is fit.thats what made him stand out in junior a very high level of fitness his football is very limited
So just to clarify once and for all for when all the Limerick lads come on for a good laugh...
You actually think David Dunphy is a better player than Tommy Barrett??
ya theres more football in dunphy then barrett,its crystal mate!
Hang on a minute above he was a better player, now there's more football in him?? Backpeddling at a rate of knots my junior friend??
Sorry Sees it.
I played with and against Tommy for over 10 years, and have played against and watched Dunphy for a while as well, and I would say that IMO Tommy is the better all round player.
allab? Whats your view on this, you'll probably go with DD as hes your team mate but try and be honest with your answer.
68, 99, 08
been honest its hard to compare players that play diff positions, dunphy would be a better winger/full back than tommy where tommy would be a better goal scorer than dunphy so u cant really compare the the 2 of them.
Ah but who would you have in midfield. Thats where dunphy started out and thats where Tommy played the majority of his games for limerick.
Personally id take Tommy. Dunphy does too much jumping into the air and screaming when he hasnt even been touched. Oh and Tommy is a better player also imho.
thats a bad point wit dunphy but tommy cant pass the ball,
boith good players but again having played with both and against both i think tommy slightly shades it.
i think tommy played in a better limerick team than dunphy.
also i think DD did not fully apply himself
'You should never have a bad game, off the ball.......'
i thought it was a very interesting discussion anyway.Hang on a minute above he was a better player, now there's more football in him?? Backpeddling at a rate of knots my junior friend??
not backpeddling at all just think dunphy is better.i think dunphy would do alot better if he was playing EL now he was young when he was up there,tommy didnt start until he was 26
Posting Permissions
Bookmarks