I can't comment on your first choice but going on past recent schools finals they are always excellent fare. On your second choice, I think there were better matches this year, biased as I may be the Kerry Armagh game was of a higher quality.
The fact that Tom Humphries is a Dublin GAA fan and everything he says is gospel disguises the fact that for excitement the Mayo Dublin game was right up there but skill wise it was a poor game.Still everyone has there own opinion.
Bookmarks