We haven't become a bad team overnight

[paul_oshea]

i dont know why my other thread got deleted, but anyhow, reading this forum the last few days all i can here is negativity from everyone, where has all the optimism gone from before, everyone know beleives over night that we are a ****e team. i hate this from everyone here. i myself said i could see us losing, i never thought we to quote others "a ****e team with no depth", so why has everyone all of a sudden changed their attitudes since losing to france. some have been realistic before that match, and those few are still being realistic, we have a good team, we havent got a solid 90 minute performance from all players yet.

[zinedineontour]

i dont know why my other thread got deleted, but anyhow, reading this forum the last few days all i can here is negativity from everyone, where has all the optimism gone from before, everyone know beleives over night that we are a ****e team. i hate this from everyone here. i myself said i could see us losing, i never thought we to quote others "a ****e team with no depth", so why has everyone all of a sudden changed their attitudes since losing to france. some have been realistic before that match, and those few are still being realistic, we have a good team, we havent got a solid 90 minute performance from all players yet.

Agree totally mate think too many people at the game and who come on here just plain and simple like to give out .. Were France with their array of talent much better if any better than us on wed ?? NO ... we have doherty on the bench they have Cisse .. people have to be realistic about things .. We played well against one of the best teams in the world .. we are not a bad side and if which i think we will win our last two games we at least have a playoff.. cheer up !

[paul_oshea]

well said zinedine. you could well be right, it just seems a lot of those were the first to say we would beat france as well.

as you say 2 wins, lets hope so, it will be tough but we owe the rolls big time.

[wws]

i dont know why my other thread got deleted, but anyhow, reading this forum the last few days all i can here is negativity from everyone, where has all the optimism gone from before, everyone know beleives over night that we are a ****e team. i hate this from everyone here. i myself said i could see us losing, i never thought we to quote others "a ****e team with no depth", so why has everyone all of a sudden changed their attitudes since losing to france. some have been realistic before that match, and those few are still being realistic, we have a good team, we havent got a solid 90 minute performance from all players yet.

well I said that (a ****e team with no depth), and I certainly dont believe we have the sort of team required at this level - we just dont have a 'vintage crop'. I went into the french game hoping an old fashioned "up and at them" or "put em under pressure" approach would paper over the obvious cracks and give us the momentum to beat superior opposition but we simply dont have it in the first eleven let alone in the squad to win when needed.

It is a poor squad and hoping Duff and Keane will raise the games of the others to the class required is a long shot at best. Duff, a genuine gem in the horsecrap, looks lost in the ireland set up.


as for posts blaming kerr, these posters nver specify who would improve the current first XI and those that do venture alternatives, laughably suggest a load of no marks....lets be honest we're not producing enough quality at the minute

[Junior]

We didn't actually play well on Weds nor have we throughout this campaign. We competed with France who weren't much better than us and who scored a magnificent goal.

You are correct we haven't become a bad side over night, I'd say we've been bad throughout this campaign. Luckily for us our poor performances are still in line with the other 3 teams fighting for qualification.

We need the next two performances to be good for the FULL 90 minutes, no lapses in concentration and we need to be lethal in front of goal & take the chances we create.

Though, I feel like Ive been saying that after every game in this group, time is running out for us to get it right.

Im not that hopeful Im afraid.

[Tram_14]

I don't think we have become a bad team overnight. I think robbie needs more football, he was also marked out of the french game. Apart from boomSh!te, I thought the french defense was very strong though. I've watched the game twice now (couldn't go to work yesterday not because I was hungover but because I have lost my voice completey ) sure we didn't create enough clean chances & kilbane showed alot of the bad parts of his game but I thought Andy Reid showed more defensive skills than before, his shot against the bar! another two & half inches & that was in. Keane & Cunningham were fanatastic, Dunne did really well. I think this team has alot of positives. Truthfully we do need more from a couple of players, JOS & Robbie Keane have alot more to give, especially O' Shea he really needs to get his act together & I believe this is a make or break year for him. Carr has lots of talent but I haven't seen it in awhile & my god he's such a moany hole?

I think this team will get a play off place. Swiss have a very big game against the french on the 8th October. I guarantee, that they will pick up cards, It will be a physical game which they will be feeling the effects from when they turn up against us. We will hopefully have Roy, Andy Reid & Morrison back fresh for that game & against cyprus Elliot will have had (hopefully) a good few premiership games by then, hes played the last couple.

These last two games will define the Irish team & Brian Kerr, it is not beyond us to beat the Swiss & when we do we will have deserved a play off place, which means we are good enough to compete at the world cup. Its very possible

I invite ALL to lose their voices once again on 12th October Eh, would this be a good time to inquire has anyone spare ticket for the swiss game

[paul_oshea]

"We need the next two performances to be good for the FULL 90 minutes, no lapses in concentration and we need to be lethal in front of goal & take the chances we create.
"


this is what i am saying I honestly dont think we have played well for a full 90 minutes, nor have every player played well together in one game. for example rob keane and duff were very poor whereas reid and roy keane were brilliant.

6 players do not make a world cup side but if you are strong in the centre those 6 can make up for the rest. That is why I think we do have a good side, we just havent had everyone firing on all cylinders at the same time.

I also dont beleive we played poorly on wednesday, quite the contrary, I thought in the first half bar the last 10 mins we were very good, our passing was good, our defending was very good, allowing france one free kick, france looked lost in the final third and resorted to hit and hopes, that was down to our play. Where we really lacked quality the last day was the final third, our passing in close and tight corners was very good ( bar kilbane ), but this was because duff and keane didnt perform, had they performed or even morrison got one of the chances the outcome of that game could have been completely different. we could have for example caught france on the counter, and if duff and keane had been up to it, then the final third would not have been a problem.

There is one thing i have noticed in all games and i dont remember it under mccarthy, but i beleive this comes down to the coach/manager, we have no ideas in the final third, no quick 1 - 2's or no slick through balls, no run offs by any players, this is something that a manager can work on, a few different ideas but i havent seen this, bar a couple of through balls from oshea and duff up the left wing. When I was watching the ireland - italy game, there was many an occasino in the second half where we could have played through balls to robbie/clint but we didnt and passed the ball backwards, i had been roaring this all day and my mate was agreeing with me, as soon as elliot came on he made decisive runs through the middle and duff placed a few balls through gap, subsequently setting up two very good chances. I dont know whether elliot spotted this himself from sitting on teh bench but it worked, that is the only time i have seen ireland doing this. Had we played smart, quick and low balls through against the french then who knows?

[zinedineontour]

Does everyone think Elliott will start against Cyprus ?? Obviously he should but have a funny bad feeling that Doherty might start which is silly ..Need to get Elliott in and he should have come on against the french as well ..

[Tram_14]

Elliott definately, has so much more to offer than Doherty.

[pineapple stu]

Does everyone think Elliott will start against Cyprus??

He did in the Faroes when Keane was suspended. Presume that's where most people are coming from. It's what I think will happen as well, to be honest.

[zinedineontour]

He did in the Faroes when Keane was suspended. Presume that's where most people are coming from. It's what I think will happen as well, to be honest.

hopefully just after doc coming on against israel and france but i suppose kerr thought hoofing forward was the best option in these cases ...

[geysir]

The defensive performance was excellent on Wed. night, Apart from the goal, the free kick and Vieira's shot I had a relatively relaxed viewing time while the French were applying pressure. Its given me some confidence.
Areas to improve in, is that we can manage to have that defensive performance when we want to close down a game. Other times when we need to, be secure in defense without having to concede an acre of space (with the midfield retreat) by having a front 2 with support from midfield closing down the opposition.
It is a myth that its only teams like NI have to play like that in order to gain a result. Is it a surprise that much of the effective workrate of Milan and Barcelona's front players is devoted to closing down. It is the standard tactic of top class teams.
Too often last night with a bit of pressure on the back 4 and midfield closing down we played the long ball (Roy and Reid excepted) to the forwards, that imo is what Domenech was dismissing as predictable. It wasn't just the Docherty sub.

[paul_oshea]

yes our defensive qualities were good, but not good enough, because it was a needless give away that gifted henry the ball and also dunne holding back, he even turned his body for the goal, i have seen defenders do this many time, why turn away the direction the ball is comign from, bloody face it head on. i honestly do think that goal could have been prevented if dunne had been a yard in front or even just put his body in front when the shot was taken and not turn away from the ball.

[gufct]

has to start along with Elliot & Harte for O'Shea .Would like to see Alan Mahon,David Connolly & Mark Kennedy brought back into the squad to freshen it up a bit.

O'Shea is the weak link in the Irish team at the moment his passing and concentration are woeful and Robbie keane needs to be put under pressure as he is far too smug at the moment.

[Stuttgart88]

I'm not sure everyone responded with such negativity. My view after the match was and still is (I hope a trawl of my posts doesn't disprove this):

(a) The difference between drawing and losing isn't that great if you're realistic about remaining results. Yes, we'd have some possible margin for error if we'd drawn but we still have what I would consider a better than evens chance of getting second. Not winning was the big disappintment.
(b) generally we put in a very good performance. My lasting image of the match was the French kicking long, inaccurate, hopeful punts straight out over the goal line.
(c) Robbie was brutal & short of match fitness. He can be a lot better.
(d) We miss a creative spark in the middle. For all KK's industry he was never going to penetrate Vieira & Makelele. But we'll rarely come up against such good defensive midfielders anywhere in the world.
(e) no Irish or British-style manager would have done anything else. Maybe a real quality coach like Guus Hiddink may have had something else to say but I think Kerr isn't to be faulted for Wednesday at all. Yes, we were predictable as Domenech said, but all Irish & British teams are in Europeans' eyes.

After the two games against Israel I was seething livid for days. After the French match I went to bed perfectly happy that 6 points will do the job.

I'm not for a secong ignoring the missed opportunities but it's an extremely achievable target. If you look on the bright side, a play-off will hopefully give us an interesting & memorable away trip.

[Stuttgart88]

i honestly do think that goal could have been prevented if dunne had been a yard in front or even just put his body in front when the shot was taken and not turn away from the ball.

I think Cunningham allowed the ball to drop instead of attacking it too - often a fatal error. The goal was brilliant but avoidable alright.

[FarBeag]

Lads we can never expect Ireland to be anywhere as good as France ,Spain Italy Chech Rep etc,etc for obvious reasons and to beat any of those teams we would have to virtually play out of our skins, not just four or five players but the whole eleven. This did not happen on Wednesday evening and half of our guys were not just at the races from the word go. This is why we lost.The French although bad compared to their past high standards all played steady enough without been spectacular this is why they won even with a manager they all dislike for that matter.

One thing i notice over the years and am not sure of the reason but Ireland when playing in Friendlies appear to gel together much better as a team thus providing us with nicer football and usually better results. Could this be because there is less pressure on them before the game and it does not really matter if they win or lose, but for the big game that really matters something goes drastically wrong.We can partly blame the manager but only marginally imo as he did not tell the likes of Duff, Robbie,donkey kilbane and a few others to play shi*e the other night, so its the players fault 99 %.It is Kerrs fault of course that he still has not copped on that the Doc is even a bigger donkey than Kilbane.
We all like to think and hope that Ireland are capable of beating anyone and to an extent they are if all the team play well and not just a couple of them.I thought they may nic a result against France on Wed if they played as a team. They have two more chances left to prove us all wrong with the whole 11 players slogging their guts out for their country.

[thejollyrodger]

france have better players than us full stop. We are meant to be better than Israel and the choclate makers. Thats where we fúcked up. Were a good team with a very shallow squad.

[onenilgameover]

I think Cunningham allowed the ball to drop instead of attacking it too - often a fatal error. The goal was brilliant but avoidable alright.

I haven't seen it on TV (and will do my heart some good and try not to) but thats what I felt straight after it happened...

[onenilgameover]

I don't think the squad is that shallow. Sure its was embarassing as hell watching Doherty fall about the place but that was Kerrs choice. Elliot or connolly (not in squad) both Premiership players would have been far better. If we dont get to germany with that set of players and in that group it will be one of Ireland's biggest football Fup up's. I do think we are still in with a chance though. I always thought we would beat the Swiss. I did however also think we wouldn't lose to the French.