I can tell you that game for game McShane since August has had a better over all season than Murphy.. McShane gave some stirling performances at the start of the season. He's only 21. He was a victim of Sunderlands lack of deth as he should have been taken out of the firing line (yes this's a nice way of saying dropped) long before he was. Any mishaps he's had (his fault or not) have generally been in the middle of some solid enough performances.
Wonder strike aside, Murphy played alright yesterday.. At one time he showed a level of pace I didn't think he had to get in ahead of two wigan defender from deep, but fluffed the shot, as he did on another occasion. Keane has said that he sees him as a centre forward though and the goal is to get him back in there (presumably as back up to Jones). He's playing well now over the last few games and long may it continue. He's showing a level of urgency he didn't before. I like him but he needs to use his physique more (like he did for the bolton goal)... And he needs to learn how to jump.
Bookmarks