No, Mignolet was a liability at Liverpool, and therefore nowhere near the level that they required. I think most of their fans would agree with this. It doesn't mean he's useless or hasn't had a decent career otherwise, just not good enough for a club of Liverpool's ambitions, ambitions they fulfilled after upgrading. Comparing the player of the year award at Sunderland to Bazunu's potm award might be relevant if I was claiming Bazuna > Mignolet!
Karius never played for Liverpool again after the Champions League disaster, obviously I didn't mean that he vanished off the face of the earth. He clearly wasn't as good as Klopp thought he was, is the point. If he's found 'his level' at Besiktas, good for him, but that's a hell of a drop for a guy in his prime years and one Klopp saw as his number one.
Bookmarks