Confederations Cup

[thejollyrodger]

i think its only right that we have an english supporter on the panel since the amount of people here who support the english PL.

[Plastic Paddy]

Leave Trevor alone. I met him at a function in Dublin last year and chatted with him for ages. A really nice, genuine guy. He gave me his e-mail address and we exchange e-mails now on various football matters. He is an agent for Steven MacLean, the Wednesday striker.

Isn't it better sometimes to have a neutral non-Irish view on things ? And why do you need an Irish slant on a game between Brazil and Japan etc ? He's usually only used when the Muppet and Giles are on holidays and would know a lot more than the Muppet about foreign players.

Nice to hear someone talking up Berwick's finest. Despite being an ex-Rankers man TS is a great bloke (I've met him on a few occasions too) and one I'm happy to second as an all-round-nice-guy. Would that football had a few more like him.

PP

[Sheridan]

Leave Trevor alone. I met him at a function in Dublin last year and chatted with him for ages. A really nice, genuine guy.

So's my uncle Johnny, but that fact alone doesn't make him qualified to analyse football matches on national television (although his trial with West Ham might, in the eyes of certain servile toads who probably constitute a majority of the TV audience )

He gave me his e-mail address and we exchange e-mails now on various football matters. He is an agent for Steven MacLean, the Wednesday striker.

Tell him to lose the hideous pastel-coloured shirts. Never heard of his client, btw.

Isn't it better sometimes to have a neutral non-Irish view on things?

Balls, Steven belongs the precisely the same British footballing tradition as Giles and Dunphy, insular, narrowminded and rooted in the attitudes and terminology of the 1950s (not, admittedly, to quite the same extent as Giles and Dunphy.) Dolan, alone among the RTÉ anaylsts, displays some modicum of acquaintance with the world game. Incidentally, Dolan dropped into Richmond Park during the DC vs. Limerick game, fresh from the studio (still wearing his make-up in fact. I hope....) He thought it an hilarious jape to respond "Germany won 4-0" my query concerning the final score of Germany-Brazil.

[razor]

Argies scrape home 6-5 in a shootout, after it was 0-0 after 90mins and 1-1 after ET.
Collicini the Argie centre half made one of the most sickening challenges i've seen in a long time. nearly took the mexican guys head off and he stayed on the pitch. Got booed for the rest of the game.
Damn RTE for delayed coverage, I was doing fine til I flicked on Aertel for the League Cup result.

[tetsujin1979]

Collicini was off balance from the slide tackle just before he collided with the Mexican, I think this is why he stayed on, it was accidental more than deliberate .It looked at lot worse than it was, especially with the head wound.

[OwlsFan]

So's my uncle Johnny, but that fact alone doesn't make him qualified to analyse football matches on national television (although his trial with West Ham might, in the eyes of certain servile toads who probably constitute a majority of the TV audience ) .

But has your Uncle Johnny won numerous league medals both sides of the border in GB, played for his country 36 times, including in the World Cup, and also play in France ? I think Trevor is well qualified to comment and more so than Dolan I suspect, although I do enjoy his punditry.

Tell him to lose the hideous pastel-coloured shirts. Never heard of his client, btw. .

Will do and you will..........

[razor]

Collicini was off balance from the slide tackle just before he collided with the Mexican, I think this is why he stayed on, it was accidental more than deliberate .It looked at lot worse than it was, especially with the head wound.

Not sure about the accidental piece, he led with his elbow, should have walked IMO.

[superfrank]

Watched the matches tonight. Ronaldinho and Sorin should've been off. Hanke deserved his.

But onto the football.......Adriano is world class. By far the best player in this tournament. His first tonight was brilliant.

Ronaldinho and Kaka were both good too. As was Robinho. As for Argentina, I can't stand that fcuker Collocini. He's a real dirty player. Good goal by all involved though.

Overall I'd say Mexico were the best team but that's the way it goes....

[Schlooooomp]

If Chelsea want to be as good as they think they are they should get Abramovich to part with as much as it takes to sign Adriano, he is everything they thought they were getting with Drogba, strong, powerful, able to run with the ball, an awesome shot (last night's first goal), an excellent header of the ball...Brazil deserved to win last night, they are a scary prospect, though I am sure at this stage all other times will be looking at how they might stifle them in the world cup

[razor]

Delighted to see good win over evil last night, and there was me wondering where the term Dirty Argies came from ? They really can't take a beating.
For all Brazils prowess up front they still look dodgy at the back. That Roque Junior wouldn't inspire confidence in anyone. Lucio needs a new partner.
Collicini was filthy again last night and should have walked.
Big Adrian was superb and Kaka's goal was peachy. as always the Brazilians are a joy to watch.

[ken foree]

borgetti must be one of the best headers of a ball in football at present.

[superfrank]

borgetti must be one of the best headers of a ball in football at present.

John Terry? Wes Charles?

[Frank Blue]

I was at the game Wednesday night. Argentina were nothing short of bloody awful. They were in complete disarray. The first 2 goals for Brasil were class and I got a good view being sat in the 7th row behind the goal. Adriano does nothing for ages and then all of a sudden comes to life, like in the Greece game too. Kaka's goal was also class. Argentina offered nothing until Pekerman made substitutions - good goal by Aimar.
As for the stadium itself, apart from the leak in the folding roof that was shown on TV (i believe), the permanent roof also leaks and many fans, including me, got wet too. So much for german engineering.
As for Robinho, i can't comprehend the hype, nor the fact he played the entire game. Too much, too young, too soon.

[superfrank]

Granted he didn't do to well the other night but he's definitely a good player.

[Stuttgart88]

I only saw bits & pieces of the tournament but I thought Riquelme was outstanding. He looks a better player than Deco to me. Did Barca sell the wrong guy?

For all their attacking brilliance I still think a direct European team could cause Brazil trouble, especially if they persist with Roque Jr.

[Frank Blue]

I only saw bits & pieces of the tournament but I thought Riquelme was outstanding. He looks a better player than Deco to me. Did Barca sell the wrong guy?

For all their attacking brilliance I still think a direct European team could cause Brazil trouble, especially if they persist with Roque Jr.

I watched all the Brasil games and was less than impressed with their defence. They also seem to think that they can dance through opposition defences. However, the opposition IMO seemed to not offer the best opposing defences, so didn't exactly test them at times, even though Japan gave them a bit of a scare.
Robihno may be good, but seeing as so many 'experts' are calling him the 'new' pele , especially as he plays at Santos, I think is pushing the boat out a bit. He struggled at times and should have been substituted in many games. Or was it just to advertise him and raise the bidding price with viewing European clubs?

[superfrank]

Advertising, hit the nail on the head there. Mexico stood up to them defensively.