Potential New EL Teams

[jorge]

Wayside Celtic would survive very well footballwise but unfortunately havent the facilities.

[crc]

I got a list of town and city populations from the CSO website. The population figures are for urban areas, not for administrative boundaries. They are a rough guide of the potential ability to support a club, but Longford, Cobh and Monaghan prove you can run a club on quite small populations. Ballybofey-Stranorlar is a bit different as Harps attract fans from all over Donegal (pop. 131,393) and even Strabane (going by the banner at last week's Cork City-Harps game)!

Towns which have an eL club are listed in Bold. The Derry figure is the population of the Derry City Council Local Govt. District.

Greater Dublin - 965,244
Cork - 179,007
Derry - 105,066
Limerick - 83,290
Galway - 63,822
Waterford - 44,669
Dundalk - 30,715
Drogheda - 29,260
Bray - 29,260
Swords - 25,842
Tralee - 20,965
Ennis - 20,904
Kilkenny - 19,831
Sligo - 18,998
An Uaimh - 18,212
Carlow - 17,492
Naas - 17,209
Wexford - 16,386
Clonmel - 16,202
Droichead Nua - 15,826
Athlone - 15,242
Celbridge - 15,127
Mullingar - 14,719
Letterkenny - 14,429
Leixlip - 14,375
Malahide - 13,316
Killarney - 12,732
Portlaoise - 11,374
Greystones - 11,436
Castlebar - 10,775
Carrigaline - 10,435
Tullamore - 10,591
Balbriggan - 9,731
Maynooth - 9,618
Arklow - 9,495
Cobh - 9,332
Ballina - 9,185
Wicklow - 8,861
Skerries - 8,676
Enniscorthy - 8,504
Mallow - 8,519
Shannon - 8,118
Portmarnock - 8,197
Tramore - 7,858
Midleton - 7,529
Longford - 7,128
Dungarvan - 7,095
Thurles - 7,088
Rush - 6,363
Youghal - 6,332
New Ross - 6,226
Nenagh - 6,169
----------[5 towns]------------
Monaghan - 5,693
----------[27 towns]-----------
Ballybofey-Stranorlar - 3,423

[sligoman]

Leitrim have great potential for a team in the EL

[centre mid]

Looking at those CSO stats, you would think that Carlow would have an EL side, maybe its to close to Kilkenny or something, but big student population and all that

[KR's Post]

They could get a new team and Call themselves ''Dublin Home Farm Everton Fingal City United''.......... Oh wait!!!!!!

[KR's Post]

Looking at those CSO stats, you would think that Carlow would have an EL side, maybe its to close to Kilkenny or something, but big student population and all that

Big student populaton in U.C.D. and they have only a fair few fans!!!

[centre mid]

Yeah but a lot of those students in carlow would probably spend the weekend there, there are a lot more choices in dublin if you want to go and watch EL football, if Carlow had an EL team chances are you would probably get a decent smattering of them

[Speranza]

Despite small attendances at Harps matchs their crowd do tend to come from the entire county and the arsehole of the world Strabane. It would be sensible for Harps to move to Leterkenny imo. Harps fans feel free to correct me but I've heard that Its a town/city which is supposedly the fastest growing in western europe?

New teams representing a whole county would be the best option, if marketed in the right way it should be a sucess.

[superfrank]

Wayside Celtic would survive very well footballwise but unfortunately havent the facilities.

They could ground-share with us, just an idea.

Droichead Nua 15,826

Despite small attendances at Harps matchs their crowd do tend to come from the entire county and the arsehole of the world Strabane. It would be sensible for Harps to move to Leterkenny imo. Harps fans feel free to correct me but I've heard that Its a town/city which is supposedly the fastest growing in western europe?

New teams representing a whole county would be the best option, if marketed in the right way it should be a sucess.

Kildare County are similar to Harps in that respect. And I'm sure many other teams are too. For instance I know people from Greystones, Shankill, Kilpedder and other parts of North Wicklow that go to Bray games.

[centre mid]

They could ground-share with us, just an idea.

As far as I Know Wayside may be looking to do just that - there own pitch ( the golden ball ) has been sold i think for housing, while i agree that in footballing terms Wayside would hold there own in the 1st Div, i am not sure what support they can draw on tough, the stepaside area is growing and not that far from cabinteely etc, but they are in between Bray and UCD

[Gerrit]

I'd count Swords, Malahide and Bray in as Greater Dublin, as they're in the direct agglomeration.



Just a maybe weird idea but you don't only have to look at numbers of people, also to the groups of people. Dublin may have 6 Eircom League teams already but they all fight for the attention of the average Dubliner and therefor fish in the same pond. With the huge Asian community in Dublin and the growing Islamic community I'm sure an ethnical Asian or Turkish teams would attract good crowds if run decently - they could survive in Dublin without the 6 other teams and the immigrants team having to fish in the same pond.

Take Berlin. They already have Hertha, TeBe Berlin, Dynamo Berlin and Union Berlin as the 'authentic Berliner' clubs. Still Turkiyemspor (currently in 4th division) attract good crowds without speaking of yet another club in a city with already 4 teams.

I'm sure if you'd get Turkiyemspor Dublin it would get good crowds, it would fill in a gap in the marketspace even as I never noticed the immigrant population showing interest in the EL. In a multicultural growing city as Dublin, there's potential I'd say.

[KR's Post]

I'd count Swords, Malahide and Bray in as Greater Dublin, as they're in the direct agglomeration.

Please don't... We are Wicklow and always will be.

Yeah but a lot of those students in carlow would probably spend the weekend there, there are a lot more choices in dublin if you want to go and watch EL football, if Carlow had an EL team chances are you would probably get a decent smattering of them

Thats true....

[dcfcsteve]

I'd count Swords, Malahide and Bray in as Greater Dublin, as they're in the direct agglomeration.



Just a maybe weird idea but you don't only have to look at numbers of people, also to the groups of people. Dublin may have 6 Eircom League teams already but they all fight for the attention of the average Dubliner and therefor fish in the same pond. With the huge Asian community in Dublin and the growing Islamic community I'm sure an ethnical Asian or Turkish teams would attract good crowds if run decently - they could survive in Dublin without the 6 other teams and the immigrants team having to fish in the same pond.

Take Berlin. They already have Hertha, TeBe Berlin, Dynamo Berlin and Union Berlin as the 'authentic Berliner' clubs. Still Turkiyemspor (currently in 4th division) attract good crowds without speaking of yet another club in a city with already 4 teams.

I'm sure if you'd get Turkiyemspor Dublin it would get good crowds, it would fill in a gap in the marketspace even as I never noticed the immigrant population showing interest in the EL. In a multicultural growing city as Dublin, there's potential I'd say.

Interesting example - but with the possible exception of Sweden, football teams based upon immigrant support tend to be in countries with very very large numbers of immigrants from those groups concerned. Germany has a 9% 'Auslander' (immigrant) population, of which 2 million are Turkish - and that doesn't measure 2nd and 3rd generations ethnic Turks now treated as nationals (even with the fecked-up passport qualification system the Germans have in-place). Within that, certain cities have a huge immigrant population - 25%+ in Frankfurt, Munich and Stuttgart. There's 0ver 120,000 Turkish-born Turks in Berlin alone, and then they'll have 2nd and 3rd generation families.

Meanwhile, neither Ireland nor Dublin have such large immigrant populations in total, let alone from a single country. I don't know what the actual figures are, but I'd be surprised if there were more than 10-15,000 members from any single non-EU community based in Ireland. (e.g. the 2002 census recorded less than 20,000 Muslims in the whole of the island). I don't believe that represents a sufficient potential supporter base from which to make a senior football team financially viable, without doing a Spurs or an Arsenal - and having certain communities each overwhelmingly supporting a different existing EL team. Also - immigrant groups like the Turks will have primary loyalty towards teams in their homeland (e.g. I live in an area of London with 40,000 Portuguese, and the place went mad the night Benfica won the league last month).

Finally - from a personal point of view I'd prefer it for the purposes of social cohesion if those of non-Irish origin supported local sides, regardless of religion or race. Just look at the venom that exists in Scottish football due to the presence of a team from a large immigrant group.

P.S. Sorry Gerrit - I always seem to be disagreeing with you in my posts ! It's nothing personal !

[jorge]

As far as I Know Wayside may be looking to do just that - there own pitch ( the golden ball ) has been sold i think for housing, while i agree that in footballing terms Wayside would hold there own in the 1st Div, i am not sure what support they can draw on tough, the stepaside area is growing and not that far from cabinteely etc, but they are in between Bray and UCD

The area is growing and i would say they would easly get 300-500 people to matches.

[Poor Student]

Meanwhile, neither Ireland nor Dublin have such large immigrant populations in total, let alone from a single country. I don't know what the actual figures are, but I'd be surprised if there were more than 10-15,000 members from any single non-EU community based in Ireland. (e.g. the 2002 census recorded less than 20,000 Muslims in the whole of the island).

I think from the statistics I have read there are 50,000 Polish here.

[4tothefloor]

Harps fans feel free to correct me but I've heard that Its a town/city which is supposedly the fastest growing in western europe?

As far as I know, Newcastle West in Co. Limerick is the new holder of that title. I remember reading an article about it around 3 months ago. Land is being gobbled up by housing estates and the likes of Tesco and Dunnes at a frightening rate. Newcastle West used to have a LoI team in the eighties of course, but I can safely say that they won't be having one again in the future.

I think one team per county is enough. None of the Dublin clubs have a huge support when they should have. Cobh struggle because Cork are the main club down there. I think the FAI should look at the feasibility of starting up teams in Kerry, Tipperary, Clare, Mayo, Offaly, Wexford and Carlow. If there are any other clubs out there, such as Wayside Celtic, that fancy playing at senior level then they could be looked at too. A third division could be run on its own for a year or two, and if successful promotion\relegation between Division 1 could be introduced. You would think that if this was realised, and with an eventual amalgamation with the IL, you would have a very ecxiting league with at least 4 Divisions and huge media coverage.......we can only dream

[Poor Student]

A third division could be run on its own for a year or two, and if successful promotion\relegation between Division 1 could be introduced.

That would definately have to be regionalised. There's no way 10 clubs would sign up to a 3rd tier spread over the country. Given the lowly level and the distances crowds and travel expenses would not make it viable.

[4tothefloor]

That would definately have to be regionalised. There's no way 10 clubs would sign up to a 3rd tier spread over the country. Given the lowly level and the distances crowds and travel expenses would not make it viable.

Teams from Kerry, Tipperary, Clare, Mayo, Offaly, Wexford and Carlow, as I mentioned. Most of those are within 2\2.5 hrs of each other. Regionalised divisions wouldn't work because there is no appeal in them. Playing the same, small few teams over and over again doesn't appeal to me, don't know about you! In the long run, travel expenses are part of life in football, so if a side in this third division was to progress, they'd have to live with the expenses. Or just stay in the third division for ever, which defeats the purpose of creating it in the first place. If small parish GAA clubs can afford to play in the All-Ireland club championships, surely a county soccer team can afford to travel a couple of hours every two weeks? Of course it's viable, if the clubs were run properly.

[thecorner]

Wayside Celtic would survive very well footballwise but unfortunately havent the facilities.

looks like ur right..knocked cobh out of the cup tonight

[jorge]

I think they will go far just like Rockmount.Ian Callaghan scored AGAIN the chap should be playing in the EL.