I think the reason is as I an see from you posts is that you like a player that can pass the ball (nothing wrong with that). O Shea has the potential to be a good passer but his confidence is shot at the moment. What he does not have and Kilbane and Holland do have,is fight. Holland is limited but on Sat he put his foot in a few times. So did Kilbane. This sort of thing makes them liked by supporters. O shea is going to have a hard time cause he does not dominate his man and for the size of him he is easily pushed off the ball. Anyway I think the basic reason is that Kilbane and HOlland put their foot in and thats the reason they dont get slated for their lack of ability.
Bookmarks