Coldplay Record

**Colie** · 03/06/2005, 4:51 PM

Just goddit. Class. 3 amazing records in a row. Not easy to do. Can't wait for that gig.

**jofyisgod** · 03/06/2005, 5:29 PM

I recieved an advance copy too last week. It's unreal.

It sounds like U2 in their prime in the late 80s, and blows Oasis' new record out of the water. Songs like' Fix You' and 'What If' are laden with church-like music, building to epic sections of a song. The actual song 'X&Y' is Beatles-esque with the strings at the end.

Martin's voice is better than ever, and lyrically, it says alot about how he views his own marriage, and life in general, at the moment. For the first time as well, Coldplay are an actual band-not just Chris Martin and his piano.

There's a secret gig being shown on MTV on Sunday at 9, and the album 'X&Y' is out on general release from Monday 9th June.

**hamish** · 03/06/2005, 9:19 PM

Fond of Coldplay but doesn't new single sound a little U2 ish?
No crime in that.
In fact, there was a U2 video on one of the music channels last night and the background etc (eg lights) looked amazingly just like the Coldplay video. A coincidence I suppose.

Great live band Coldplay.

They're on Johnathon Woss on BBC 1 tonight.

**jofyisgod** · 04/06/2005, 5:35 PM

They have drawn inspiration from U2's earlier work, and also from the Beatles and Radiohead most notably for this album. That crazy frog thing Chris Martin did was very good

**Gareth** · 04/06/2005, 11:37 PM

Never really warmed to Coldplay. I enjoyed some of their tunes but never wanted to buy an album. Oasis just completely uninterest me. The single was weak in my opinion, but I have not heard the entire album so I can't judge. In fairness to Coldplay three albums that please a majority is a hard thing to pull off. Esp in a row. I didn't find them that great to watch live when at Witnness. Got bored and headed off to a different stage.

Whats your favorite Coldplay song?

**hamish** · 05/06/2005, 12:38 AM

I'm feeling a little pi$$ed at the minute so I'll go for "In my place" - suits the mood.

**hamish** · 05/06/2005, 1:27 AM

Originally Posted by jofyisgod

They have drawn inspiration from U2's earlier work, and also from the Beatles and Radiohead most notably for this album. That crazy frog thing Chris Martin did was very good

I think there's a little Procul Harum in there too - Martin's voice sometimes sound like that group's vocalist - Gary somethingorother - and the organ sound and sort of melancholic ballads also remind me of PH.

I think PH's singer/keyboard is Gary Broker.

**jofyisgod** · 05/06/2005, 9:08 AM

Originally Posted by Gareth

Whats your favorite Coldplay song?

God Put a Smile Upon your Face, or off X&Y, What If

**gustavo** · 06/06/2005, 12:05 AM

favrourite coldplay song?

definetly politik
great opening song for an album - good lyrics - great drrums - excellent outro

**Wolfhound** · 06/06/2005, 11:40 AM

Favourite song - has to be Yellow.
Cant wait for X&Y, hope to get it today.
Any one going to see them in Marlay Park? I am, got my tickets on friday.

Looking forward yo seeing Interpol aswell, they're fantastic!

**jofyisgod** · 06/06/2005, 1:25 PM

Got another copy this morning. It's amazing. I've listened to it 3 times now, just gets better and better. The second song (X2) is unreal, as is Talk. Sounds class with the Kraftwerk riff. What a band...

**Rovers1** · 06/06/2005, 10:10 PM

excellent album from an excellent band,got it last week,cant wait till Marley Park!!!! (and Croker!!)

**Wolfhound** · 07/06/2005, 11:44 AM

Got X&Y yesterday, it's unbelievable! Have been playing it on repeat for yhe last 4 hours - It's gonna be the cause of me doing crap in my leaving tomorrow!

**Pauro 76** · 07/06/2005, 6:58 PM

favourite Coldplay songs? The Scientist, Politik, Shiver and Clocks... looking forward to hearing the new album, Talk is an instant classic even after one listen...

**SaucyJack** · 07/06/2005, 8:14 PM

Jon Pareles of the NY Times pretty much sums up my feelings

**Frank Blue** · 08/06/2005, 7:44 AM

A classic? A great album?
A lot of folks on a music rating site happen to disagree

http://rateyourmusic.com/view_album_...m_id_is_283841

3.5/5 stars is fairly average.

I am waiting for a CDRcopy before deciding whether to buy the original or not.

**tetsujin1979** · 08/06/2005, 9:38 AM

I have the album, it's pretty much what you'd expect from Coldplay, guitars, pianos, drums, the problem with it is that there's nothing particularly wrong with it, Chris Martin does seem to follow the same formula (as does Dido IMO) and it works and it sells, I just keep waiting for them to do something remotely controversial musically, something to start a conversation on, not the same old thing. Maybe it's just me.

**Frank Blue** · 08/06/2005, 9:42 AM

Originally Posted by tetsujin1979

I have the album, it's pretty much what you'd expect from Coldplay, guitars, pianos, drums, the problem with it is that there's nothing particularly wrong with it, Chris Martin does seem to follow the same formula (as does Dido IMO) and it works and it sells, I just keep waiting for them to do something remotely controversial musically, something to start a conversation on, not the same old thing. Maybe it's just me.

how can you mention Dido in the same breath when talking about Coldplay?!!

She's awful.

**Roo69** · 08/06/2005, 9:46 AM

Originally Posted by tetsujin1979

I have the album, it's pretty much what you'd expect from Coldplay, guitars, pianos, drums, the problem with it is that there's nothing particularly wrong with it, Chris Martin does seem to follow the same formula (as does Dido IMO) and it works and it sells, I just keep waiting for them to do something remotely controversial musically, something to start a conversation on, not the same old thing. Maybe it's just me.

Nah i would have to agree with ya, its sounds way to like there previous 2 albums for my liking, but in saying that i still like it - a good album, not a great album, 3 outstanding tracks - the rest are average.

For me, they are trying to sound more and more like U2 but just are'nt up to it, Martin was saying in an interview that the lead Guitarest (cant remember his name) was just as good as the edge !

seriously thou, he was having a laugh right ?

I would'nt even put Coldplay in the same class as Radiohead at the moment, it's only 3 albums at the end of the day which all sound very similar.

Verdict - 6.5/10

**Frank Blue** · 08/06/2005, 9:50 AM

Originally Posted by Roo69

Nah i would have to agree with ya, its sounds way to like there previous 2 albums for my liking, but in saying that i still like it - a good album, not a great album, 3 outstanding tracks - the rest are average.

For me, they are trying to sound more and more like U2 but just are'nt up to it, Martin was saying in an interview that the lead Guitarest (cant remember his name) was just as good as the edge !

seriously thou, he was having a laugh right ?

I would'nt even put Coldplay in the same class as Radiohead at the moment, it's only 3 albums at the end of the day which all sound very similar.

Verdict - 6.5/10

Well be honest, the Edge has had at least 15 years head start. Check out most bands, and their playing gets better over time, as they beocme more serious in their music (musos??). Unfortunately, with a lot of bands, becoming better does not equate in better music, as the 'edge' is lost in their music. Take U2 for example.........