Originally Posted by
pineapple stu
Well that's fair enough - at least you're trying to argue facts, which I can respect. There can obviously be a decent element of opinion, and exposure bias, involved in deciding who's a better keeper.
I would point out that Corbet is playing in the Premier, not the First (which was my original point!) He's with Waterford now.
I don't agree with your point -
Aside from the fact that he's not with UCD any more, players can often stay at UCD longer than they would at other clubs. Corbet stayed just long enough to complete his Master's - just like Benson and McMillan, for example. So I don't think your point above is relevant, as it also argues that Benson/McMillan (and others) aren't top players.
It's a shame in one way that Waterford signed Vigoroux so soon after signing Corbet, as Swindon's first choice keeper from 2015-17 is clearly going to be better than UCD's first choice for the same period. But with Vigoroux going back to Swindon in July (apparently?), I guess Corbet has to take the chance to learn from his experience and try make the spot his own come then.
Bookmarks