Clare District League 2016/17

**Cruyff** · 03/11/2016, 1:28 PM

Sorry I was told 300, 6 points is very hefty, I'm struggling to think of any precedent to go by. Usually just 3 points

**Side Cutter** · 03/11/2016, 2:25 PM

Originally Posted by old git

Sidecutter, common sense i think everybody would agree 3 point deduction and fine would be enough would be very intrested to know how many other clubs were deducted 6 points for same offence by league? As for league rules three rules currently being broken and ignored by clare league.

Three rules being broken?

**old git** · 03/11/2016, 9:35 PM

Originally Posted by Side Cutter

Three rules being broken?

Rule 41 no two teams from the same club can play in the same division/ rule 47 teams not fulfillin fixture to be fined 125 euro and deducted 6 points burren utd gave walkover recently in 2nd division dont see any punishement on league website / rule 97b all suspenions to be posted weekly on website check last date/ rule 100 all club team managers must have coaching qualifications so very suprised league can quote rules to clubs when handin out punishment

**old git** · 03/11/2016, 9:48 PM

Apologies suspensions have been updated on league website recently but numerous players already served bans before it was even updated???

**Second** · 03/11/2016, 10:00 PM

Originally Posted by old git

Rule 41 no two teams from the same club can play in the same division/ rule 47 teams not fulfillin fixture to be fined 125 euro and deducted 6 points burren utd gave walkover recently in 2nd division dont see any punishement on league website / rule 97b all suspenions to be posted weekly on website check last date/ rule 100 all club team managers must have coaching qualifications so very suprised league can quote rules to clubs when handin out punishment

Burren United have been thrown out of the league as per league rules. 2 walkover and your out. Kilkishen celtic played with 9 men last Sunday so as to not get kicked out of league too . It's a sad state of affairs when lads sign a form and then won't turn up for their club.

**Second** · 03/11/2016, 10:03 PM

Originally Posted by old git

Rule 41 no two teams from the same club can play in the same division/ rule 47 teams not fulfillin fixture to be fined 125 euro and deducted 6 points burren utd gave walkover recently in 2nd division dont see any punishement on league website / rule 97b all suspenions to be posted weekly on website check last date/ rule 100 all club team managers must have coaching qualifications so very suprised league can quote rules to clubs when handin out punishment

Your do realise that committee members are voluntary and might not be able to update things every week even when eagle eyes like you are watching over them .
As for rule 100 do you know.of certain coaches with no qualifications ??

**Second** · 03/11/2016, 10:05 PM

Originally Posted by old git

Apologies suspensions have been updated on league website recently but numerous players already served bans before it was even updated???

Committee probably don't get match cards until late in the week. Therefore if they don't meet until following week to discuss possible suspensions then how can they be updated weekly. You should probably put yourself forward for the committee. They could obviously do with someone like you helping out 😉😉

**old git** · 03/11/2016, 10:49 PM

Originally Posted by Second

Your do realise that committee members are voluntary and might not be able to update things every week even when eagle eyes like you are watching over them .
As for rule 100 do you know.of certain coaches with no qualifications ??

Voluntary or not they made the rule all suspenions would be up on website weekly dont make rules if you cant honour them?? In fairness puttin suspended players up on website probally helps stamp out clubs trying to play the same players while suspended. As for teams with managers with no qualifactions plenty of them out there and should be easy enough for league to identify them.

**old git** · 03/11/2016, 11:15 PM

Originally Posted by Second

Burren United have been thrown out of the league as per league rules. 2 walkover and your out. Kilkishen celtic played with 9 men last Sunday so as to not get kicked out of league too . It's a sad state of affairs when lads sign a form and then won't turn up for their club.

Fair enough if burren thrown out but nothing on clare league website sayin this so you must have inside information from committe ;-) sad state of affairs from players not turning up and alot of good people involved in running clubs now punished

**Second** · 03/11/2016, 11:23 PM

Originally Posted by old git

Fair enough if burren thrown out but nothing on clare league website sayin this so you must have inside information from committe ;-) sad state of affairs from players not turning up and alot of good people involved in running clubs now punished

Agreed not fair on the people who are trying to keep clubs running. As for the inside information it was common knowledge in Ennis on Wednesday night. Very sad as a great facility out there.

What's your opinion on hibs situation with the fine and 6 point deduction.

**Side Cutter** · 04/11/2016, 7:09 AM

Originally Posted by Second

Your do realise that committee members are voluntary and might not be able to update things every week even when eagle eyes like you are watching over them .
As for rule 100 do you know.of certain coaches with no qualifications ??

The suspensions is updated now but before yesterday it was last updated mid september

**Side Cutter** · 04/11/2016, 7:11 AM

Was there any punishment for moher b for failing to fulfill any fixture in the shield?

**Second** · 04/11/2016, 7:26 AM

Originally Posted by Side Cutter

Was there any punishment for moher b for failing to fulfill any fixture in the shield?

As far as I know shield is optional to enter . The therefore the could have pulled out before 1st game. Not sure though.

**old git** · 04/11/2016, 8:01 AM

Originally Posted by Second

Agreed not fair on the people who are trying to keep clubs running. As for the inside information it was common knowledge in Ennis on Wednesday night. Very sad as a great facility out there.

What's your opinion on hibs situation with the fine and 6 point deduction.

I think it is extremly harsh. I know rule in place but league should look at every protest and judge on all the evidance presented. but they have set the Law now and amy other clubs will have to get same punishement. Fine and 3 point deduction would have been enough what do u think yourself

**Second** · 04/11/2016, 10:41 AM

Originally Posted by old git

I think it is extremly harsh. I know rule in place but league should look at every protest and judge on all the evidance presented. but they have set the Law now and amy other clubs will have to get same punishement. Fine and 3 point deduction would have been enough what do u think yourself

I think it was harsh . But at the same time if a player gets a straight red it very rarely results in just a 1 game ban. Maybe someone should have made a call to league as I'm sure they could have done without Jamie for Olympic game. Which the score suggests. I'd prefer to be missing him for that game than a tougher team. No disrespect to Olympic b.

**old git** · 04/11/2016, 5:19 PM

Originally Posted by Second

I think it was harsh . But at the same time if a player gets a straight red it very rarely results in just a 1 game ban. Maybe someone should have made a call to league as I'm sure they could have done without Jamie for Olympic game. Which the score suggests. I'd prefer to be missing him for that game than a tougher team. No disrespect to Olympic b.

I think Hibs at fault for not contactin league a quick phone call would have had it sorted, they probally thought it was like limerick league were they send out letter to club to confirm suspenions, they only brought jamie on at half time as well when 2-1 up. Very costly mistake :'(

**Side Cutter** · 08/11/2016, 12:52 PM

Originally Posted by Second

As far as I know shield is optional to enter . The therefore the could have pulled out before 1st game. Not sure though.

Never heard of the shield being optional. In a lot of the rules they talk about the season. The shield is part of the season so same rules should apply. The shield is played at the start of the season to accommodate certain teams who are missing players to GAA. Moher b took no part but weren't fined or deducted points?

**Second** · 08/11/2016, 11:18 PM

Originally Posted by Side Cutter

Never heard of the shield being optional. In a lot of the rules they talk about the season. The shield is part of the season so same rules should apply. The shield is played at the start of the season to accommodate certain teams who are missing players to GAA. Moher b took no part but weren't fined or deducted points?

Your will have to go to the agm and find out why.

**Side Cutter** · 09/11/2016, 8:11 AM

Originally Posted by Second

Your will have to go to the agm and find out why.

Not on till june. Season over then

**old git** · 09/11/2016, 4:45 PM

Originally Posted by Side Cutter

Never heard of the shield being optional. In a lot of the rules they talk about the season. The shield is part of the season so same rules should apply. The shield is played at the start of the season to accommodate certain teams who are missing players to GAA. Moher b took no part but weren't fined or deducted points?

If optional i would have thought moher would have opted out before fixtures. Were made?