Given to United or Arsenal

[Pablo]

Shay is a fine goal keeper. It should be no suprise to anyone that the big boys are chasing him.
he's top notch

[Fergie's Son]

I don't agree. I think Given is an excellent keeper but I think he is too small. He is a great shot stopped but he doesn't command his box well and he isn't great on crosses.

United are still looking for the next Peter Schmiechal so I don't think a move there would suit Given.

Arsenal need a keeper who can handle crosses given their relative weakness in the air.

Personally, I have always rated Kiely above Given but that's just a personal preference. I rather tough, physical keepers so I am biased. That said, I don't see Given going to either Arsenal or United.

[Dublin12]

lol United are still looking for the next Schmiechal

[Fergie's Son]

Aren't they? He is arguably one of the best keepers ever and definitely the best ever in the Premiership. He commanded his box, marshalled the defense and was a great shotstopper. United have never had a goalie come close to that since then.

[Terry]

well if he does want to move on, and one of the top clubs want him, they will have to pay for him as Souness has a price tag of 11 million pounds on his head!!!! Thats a lot of money for a keeper

[Dublin12]

I agree he was a fantastic keeper and a one off but is it not time to stop comparing every keeper to Schmiechal,it's a bit annoying thats all.What would you think if England fan's were still looking for the next Gordon Banks!

[Dublin12]

According to the latest from Sky sports he's going nowhere and is a bit confused himself as to where the rumours started

[Superhoops]

well if he does want to move on, and one of the top clubs want him, they will have to pay for him as Souness has a price tag of 11 million pounds on his head!!!! Thats a lot of money for a keeper

Can see United getting him as part of a deal involving O'Shea to Newcastle and about £6/£7m.

[Dublin12]

I suppose your confidence would be dented playing behind Titus Shambles week in week out