Monaghan (Home)

**bluewhitearmy** · 23/07/2011, 12:31 AM

Originally Posted by abbeyvale

Lads was that McCarthy wearing no.13 tonight?
He was beaten in the air by a bloke roughly a foot smaller than him at the edge of Mons box from a Lim free, which Mons then went up the other end to score (the less said about Lim defending in the corner the better, how in gods name did the Mons player get passed 3 Lim players to get his cross in.................schoolboy defending)

Thats McCarthy ya what did people make of his constant hoofing?

Anyone agree with em that Paudie Quinn adds nothing i keep being told that he is very good but i cant see it at all.

Agree 100%b with Monster about yellow apparently his excuse was yellow wasnt fit but he started last weeks match and if hes not fit then why is he on the bench.

**fieldofmarkets** · 23/07/2011, 3:49 AM

Abroad at the moment and so missed the match (thank god). Didn't need to be there though as you knew how it would go as soon as extratime put up the teamsheet. O'connor on, kelly not starting etc. Fullback into center midfield for o'leary. Last throw of the dice while loosing to the team that may keep us down ... Straight swap right full for a right full with midfielders and forwards on the bench. Not only do we loose these games but they are such a shambles we have players driven to foolishness and now another red card. Manager is costing us points, players, attendances and a premier spot for the markets field next season.

**Jofspring** · 23/07/2011, 9:20 AM

Every person I talked to before the game where disgusted that O Connor was starting and knew it was down hill from there. Scully can't use injuries as excuse as he had enough quality around to replace the injured players. If Yellow was fit enough to play the last few games he was fit enough tonight. Yellow has also been excellent doing the job that was required when O'Leary came off but a left full goes into that position. Crazy stuff. I really think Scully has lost his marbles and I think Shiels and Farmer have most likely also. Scully made it very easy for Mons in the end last night.

**Targetman** · 23/07/2011, 10:37 AM

To be fair to some of the players that played last night, we were by far the better team. In patches we knocked the ball about very well, it seems we were just missing that bit of creativity to carve an opening or someone like steve-o to finish off a half chance. Monaghan were woeful in my opinion, just hoofing balls into spaces where there were clearly no players anywhere near. Its crazy that they are up towards the top of the table.

Now why we lost the game instead of drew:

When O' Leary went off injured, Skully changed the system from a 4-4-2 which was working, to a 4-1-2-1-2 kind of formation, with all our midfield bunched in the centre. Most of the time, when we were in possession we were ok, and could pass and retain it if we wanted to, without creating too much. But when Monaghan had the ball, they could counter quickly, by simply passing the ball out to the wing. There would then be no one within 10/15 yards of their winger and they had time to pick a pass, or take on the fullbacks, if they were even there. That’s how the first goal came about.
Another shocking decision was with 15/10 mins to go, just throwing Paddy Purcell up front. This isn’t Under 12's, he should have subbed McCarthy for an att midfielder or striker if he wanted more up front.

I agree with nearly everything else:

O'Connor was shocking, didn’t even know he was playing until he was taken off.

Although Corey Tracey played ok, he looked unfit at times. Kelly played well when he game on, and should start the next game.

Behan, although a stone or two overweight, played decent and you can see flashes of what he can do.

Gamble started very well, but didn’t see enough of him in the second half. Sending off was deserved and stupid.

Not blaming the result on him, but the ref was absolutely shocking. Missing blatant fouls right in front of him and then just the inconsistency in giving out cards and fouls.

To be honest I can’t see Scully being sacked before the end of the season. Although his home record is shocking against the good teams, I still think it’s possible that we could achieve a top 2/3 finish. If we don’t, he should be out the door and then there should be a decent budget available to hire a new manager when quality ones are there to hire.

**inmoscow** · 23/07/2011, 11:39 AM

Steve Henderson come on in.

**bluewhitearmy** · 23/07/2011, 11:50 AM

Originally Posted by inmoscow

Steve Henderson come on in.

Exactly what i was thinking would love to see him come in til the end of the season at least. No hope will Scully actually be sacked though it will be at the end of the season when we are stuck in this league for another year.

**nosebleds** · 23/07/2011, 12:23 PM

i no u are probally sick of hearing this,but in fairness there are a few guys on the athlone team who would have played way better than half the guys in jackman last night.Scullys stubbourness and dislike to certain players could be costly come end of season .If a player is good enough he should be signed end of story,please dont start slating me as its only my OPINION.

**bluewhitearmy** · 23/07/2011, 12:26 PM

Originally Posted by nosebleds

i no u are probally sick of hearing this,but in fairness there are a few guys on the athlone team who would have played way better than half the guys in jackman last night.Scullys stubbourness and dislike to certain players could be costly come end of season .If a player is good enough he should be signed end of story,please dont start slating me as its only my OPINION.

Jason Hughes caused us more problems in Athlone then Sean O Connor or Paudie Quinn have causes anyone all season and Wayne Colbert or Connor Kavanagh would have been 100 times better then Bhandarkhar in midfield so you are spot on really.

**thomas72** · 23/07/2011, 1:05 PM

It's was on radio this morning that we are looking to bring in another striker question is do you trust scully to sign the right one. We need an out and out striker a fox in the box if you like. We don't need another target man pacey striker I reckon.

**bluewhitearmy** · 23/07/2011, 1:12 PM

Originally Posted by thomas72

It's was on radio this morning that we are looking to bring in another striker question is do you trust scully to sign the right one. We need an out and out striker a fox in the box if you like. We don't need another target man pacey striker I reckon.

Being honest i think Pat O S should keep his money and not give a cent more to Scully.
Bring in another striker and what then he gets dropped while hes in good scoring form like Brosnan.

**Jofspring** · 23/07/2011, 3:49 PM

No I don't think we need another striker. We have players that can score goals but the way we are playing isn't setting up any decent chances and we are resorting to snatching at the ball from far out. Don't think Sava had to make any decent save last night.

Going by Hendersons recent record with Waterford I wouldn't like him anywhere near the Limerick team. He has done a worse job than Scully this year, he signed bad players, played players out of position and couldn't motivate the team at all. Would almost be replacing a like for like. We need a no nonsense manager that plays the team to players strengths. Scully seems to want players to adapt to his tactics and fit into the way he wants them to play instead of the other way around.

**ped_ped** · 23/07/2011, 4:43 PM

Originally Posted by Jofspring

No I don't think we need another striker. We have players that can score goals but the way we are playing isn't setting up any decent chances and we are resorting to snatching at the ball from far out. Don't think Sava had to make any decent save last night.

Going by Hendersons recent record with Waterford I wouldn't like him anywhere near the Limerick team. He has done a worse job than Scully this year, he signed bad players, played players out of position and couldn't motivate the team at all. Would almost be replacing a like for like. We need a no nonsense manager that plays the team to players strengths. Scully seems to want players to adapt to his tactics and fit into the way he wants them to play instead of the other way around.

Who would you suggest yourself?

**kingpin4** · 23/07/2011, 5:32 PM

Originally Posted by Jofspring

No I don't think we need another striker. We have players that can score goals but the way we are playing isn't setting up any decent chances and we are resorting to snatching at the ball from far out. Don't think Sava had to make any decent save last night.

Going by Hendersons recent record with Waterford I wouldn't like him anywhere near the Limerick team. He has done a worse job than Scully this year, he signed bad players, played players out of position and couldn't motivate the team at all. Would almost be replacing a like for like. We need a no nonsense manager that plays the team to players strengths. Scully seems to want players to adapt to his tactics and fit into the way he wants them to play instead of the other way around.

That surely means the players aren't intelligent enough or good enough to play that system...? The only thing I'd say is, none of us see what they do at training or how they plan on playing, but surely once the whistle goes it has to be on the players to perform. I know people have said about players playing out of position and all that, but they have to be able to carry out whatever job you give them, it's not like asking a dentist to perform open heart surgery... A left back surely can perform in left wing or the middle. Just my opinion though, but I'd definitely put a fair share of the blame on the players too.

Also, gamble is going to get booked in every game because of his name. Predicting a red card against cork already.

**harpin** · 23/07/2011, 7:11 PM

Originally Posted by Targetman

To be fair to some of the players that played last night, we were by far the better team. In patches we knocked the ball about very well, it seems we were just missing that bit of creativity to carve an opening or someone like steve-o to finish off a half chance. Monaghan were woeful in my opinion, just hoofing balls into spaces where there were clearly no players anywhere near. Its crazy that they are up towards the top of the table.

Now why we lost the game instead of drew:

When O' Leary went off injured, Skully changed the system from a 4-4-2 which was working, to a 4-1-2-1-2 kind of formation, with all our midfield bunched in the centre. Most of the time, when we were in possession we were ok, and could pass and retain it if we wanted to, without creating too much. But when Monaghan had the ball, they could counter quickly, by simply passing the ball out to the wing. There would then be no one within 10/15 yards of their winger and they had time to pick a pass, or take on the fullbacks, if they were even there. That�s how the first goal came about.
Another shocking decision was with 15/10 mins to go, just throwing Paddy Purcell up front. This isn�t Under 12's, he should have subbed McCarthy for an att midfielder or striker if he wanted more up front.

I agree with nearly everything else:

O'Connor was shocking, didn�t even know he was playing until he was taken off.

Although Corey Tracey played ok, he looked unfit at times. Kelly played well when he game on, and should start the next game.

Behan, although a stone or two overweight, played decent and you can see flashes of what he can do.

Gamble started very well, but didn�t see enough of him in the second half. Sending off was deserved and stupid.

Not blaming the result on him, but the ref was absolutely shocking. Missing blatant fouls right in front of him and then just the inconsistency in giving out cards and fouls.

To be honest I can�t see Scully being sacked before the end of the season. Although his home record is shocking against the good teams, I still think it�s possible that we could achieve a top 2/3 finish. If we don�t, he should be out the door and then there should be a decent budget available to hire a new manager when quality ones are there to hire.

No 4-4-2 Bardanker went to the left of the midfield 3 and Jeffrey came across to play where O'Leary was. We have no width because of this system it's meant to come from the fullbacks....if they're forward then our midfield I presume is meant to cover them. Our first goal Behan had no options, Tracey tore up the line to give him an out, the pass never made it to him, he couldn't get back in time and Purcell gave out to him....wasn't his fault but his head dropped after that

Anyway O'Connor....what the f*** was that about
Brosnan...ditto
Yellow...ditto
Bardanker...ditto
Gamble was always going to get sent off
No support for Behan...I feel sorry for Hynes always tried and caused problems

Scully....what does he do in the dressing room?

**Jofspring** · 23/07/2011, 8:01 PM

Originally Posted by ped_ped

Who would you suggest yourself?

Dunno to be honest. Somebody with experience that will come in and hit the ground running. Not a guy that will come in and want to get used to the players and experiment. Damien Richardson till the end of the season maybe and see from there. He talks a lot if crap but he does know his stuff. I'm sure he would be interested for a few months anyway if Scully was to go.

Can't see POS getting rid of Scully though. He does come across as a loyal guy and he will probably stick by Scully.

**Jofspring** · 23/07/2011, 8:52 PM

Forgot to ask is Gamble only one more yellow away from another suspension? Is it 4 or 5 yellows? He now has 3 yellows in two games.

**da bishop** · 24/07/2011, 12:22 AM

well cant say i,m fond of the guy but hats off to roddy because lets face it he is getting the very best of a very ordinary mons team and he certainly prepared his troops for this one.when they got the chance they tried to play and his subs etc were spot on.our first 20 mins were ok ,after that it was a chore plenty possession no end product ,by the end it was shambolic not helped by some bizzare decisions by the bench most notably sending purcell up front and once that happened the 2nd goal was always on.having previously said that we cant wait for new signings ...to get fit.....this game only cemented my view,plus i would think player morale has already dropped as a result of recent events..i.e signing a veteran centre half with a record of injury,playing him straight away ,then he coming off injured minutes into his first game.also the negative system at home,the selection of o conner and theres plenty more,however there is light at the end of the tunnel ,heres hoping things improve so we can get there.

**bluewhitearmy** · 24/07/2011, 12:45 AM

I might be being harsh but i dont think Paddy talks enough for a captain he is supposed to lead but its Frost that does all the talking and Gamble since he came.

Told by one of the players that Sean O Connor was meant to be playing left wing but kept moving out of position and refusing to get back in position.
John Frost asking Scully to take him off at start of 2nd half says it all.