Exactly, you can't, just as you can't judge an incident solely on the other photo, they are obviously taken form the same incident, just pointing out how two photos from same incident can appear to show two different things, that's all.
From what I've read (either here or in poapers, not sure which), Keane held his head after incident which is when the red was shown, so neither photo is evidence of what led to the sending off!
"Billy Corgan, Smashing Pumpkins."
"Homer Simpson, smiling politely."
Original question answered. I'll hold my hands up, I didnt think Cooke would play as strong a side as he did after I read the original news feed yesterday morning, so all credit to him for that.
In Rod We Trust.
(not really!)
Hardly a stupid question given the similar circumstances from last years title run-in,also the original report linked mentioned sligo resting players.And as the OP mentioned Cooke has form in this regard-Hardly "womens intuition"(I didn't even realize GGAJD was a woman-You learn something new every day!)
Surley if it was as stupid as you claim no-one would have answered?
theres no such thing as a stupid question. Just stupid posters.
in fairness, it should have waited until at least the team was announced and not on the back of some press release... Osam was doubtful for 20 years.
Model Club, honestly is the only reason you come on this forum is to have a dig at every possible oppurtunity.
Manager: Fergal, have you your boots with ya?
Fergal: Ya, I have them here.
Manager: Ah good stuff, well give them to this man so, he forgot his!
What can I say?I'm pro-active and re-active
I can understand that a lot of my posts wouldn't suit a lot of other posters but at least my contribution doesn't consist simply of a "thanks" or the self-paradoxial
gem such as "dongs" on a previous page of this thread.
Nor are they wind ups in any way.
If you or others have an issue just report any posts that don't fall under the rules and I'll fall on my sword.
I love the way Shams are still harping on about the team we played in Dalymount last season.
Here's the team we played in Tolka against Shams last season - only 4 of that team started the cup final (Brush would have started only for injury).
Sligo Rovers: 1 Richard Brush; 2 Jason Noctor, 3 Shaun Holmes, 4 Alan Keane, 5 Ger Rafter; 6 Christopher Kelly, 7 Brian Cash, 8 Romauld Boco, 9 Matthew Blinkhorn, 10 Rob Turner, 11 Dean Marshall. Substitutes not used: 12 Rafael Cretaro, 13 Gavin Peers, 14 Danny Keohane, 17 Ciaran Kelly.
And here's the team we played in Dalymount - 6 of that team started in the Cup Final.
SLIGO ROVERS : Schlingermann; Boco, Camano, Keane, Kendrick; Marshall, O’Grady, Meenan, Ryan (Cash, half-time), Doyle; Turner.
Final score in both games. 3-1
The old saying about these things evening themselves out over the course of the season comes to mind
The only one harping on about that fixture is you.The difference in the 2 fixtures is that for the game in Tolka,Sligo were weakened through injuries/suspensions iirc,rather than simply resting players. the
Again I have no problem with Cooke dropping players for the long term good of his club-Its just unfortunate for us that he chose to do it when he did and because of the almost identical circumstances(title race,upcoming cup game) and this along with the linked article in the original post led to a legitimate question being asked.Trust me if you were in our position you'd be asking the same questions as us.
I've moved on now-A good result for us but only if capitalized on by us tomorrow.
The term "model club" was,to the best of my knowledge given to SRFC by other clubs fans because when we got our house in order very few,least of al, any of the title contenders since our take over.The harping by the fans of SRFC may not have been what you/they wanted to hear but recent history surely has proven them/us right!
You suggest that we as a group "conveniently forget about bankruptcy and the non-payment of creditors".I dont know where you picked up such a presumption but I can assure you that that period is far from being forgotten about and is what will make any future success feel so much better.
Why this period is not a shameful one for me is because when we seen just how deep the idiots who were in charge of the club at the time had us buried we decided to do something about it.This not only involved taking over the running of the club but in doing so effectively relegating ourselves by coming clean with the books.
No Hoop can dismiss the debacle that went on before our take over but then no supporter of any club can seriously fail to admire what has gone on since.
The model we have adopted is the ONLY one that can really work in this league where very few people care about their local team but those who do care more than they really should.Of course bohs although being probably the pioneers of the members model in this country have managed to make a balls of it but this shouldn't deter others from following such a course.
IMO all clubs should have a members club independant of the current owners for 2 reasons.
(1)The help out the club if they are in need of financial support,or
(2)To act as a warchest to take over their club should the suppport base become unhappy with their current owners.
As for conveniently forgetting important times in history-Just how much did bohs give the FAI for the home of Irish football in the 80's-Dont hear much about that one any more!!
One last point-Something tells me bohs current creditors will be doing well to recieve 4% over the coming close season so maybe that'll be one less broken record for you to churn out when Rovers occasionally are given the credit they deserve
No offence to you btid1, but you've been handed your ar$e there.
Shamrock Rovers- Where trophies are won and envy is scarce
Bookmarks