No the furthest the ref could bring it would be the edge of the box. Just like in Rugby I think the furthest the ref can bring it is the 5 metre line otherwise its a try as he will be over the line. If the player does not want the ball brought to the edge of the box because it might be a disadvantage he can ask to leave the free where it is. It happens in rugby all the time and works perfectly. Usually when it happens once in a game you won't see someone complain for the rest of it.
I think this would work better than just booking a player. If you where to book players everytime they open there mouths (like a certain ref does) it can just frustrate players even more. If by mouthing you are giving the team an extra advantage players would shut up fairly fast. Also there is usually a level a player would have to be complaining to before the ref would move it on. A simple disagreement never gets the ball moved forward but shouting and complaining at the ref does.
Last edited by Jofspring; 28/09/2010 at 4:00 PM.
Sunday Oct 10th
Munster Junior Cup Round One
Geraldines v Mungret B, 10.30, A Keogh
Athlunkard v Janesboro, 10.30, O Hayes
Aisling A v Dromore, 10.30, K Gorman
Star Rvs v Charleville, 10.30, R Peiper
Ballynanty v Caledonians, 10.30, J Carey
Cappamore v Polonia Luimni, 10.30, J McNamara
Granville v Abbey Rvs, 10.30, J Curran
Hyde Rgs v Wembley Rvs, 10.30, M Kavanagh
Munster Junior Cup Round Two
Castle Rvs v Prospect Priory, 10.30, K O’Driscoll
Carew Park v Corbally Utd, 10.30, R McCann
Holycross v Lisnagry, 10.30, P O’Brien
Shannon Town A v Pike Rvs, 10.30, PJ Walsh
Fairview Rangers v St Patrick's, 10.30, B Kelly
Knockainey v Kennedy Park, 2.00, T Mazur
Any predictions lads ?????
tough ask for hyde this weekend
athlunkard 2-3 boro aet
carew park 4 corbally 1 steven grant, dermot o shea 2, john boyle.
good performance this morning carew dominated the game from start to finish all the goals coming in the second half.
Shannon Town 1 - 2 Pike Rovers (W O'Donovan, Hartnett)
Hyde 1-2 Wembley
carew played some lovely stuff this morning fully deserved there win could of been more in the end corbally down to 10men with 20 to go second yellow. i have to give a mention on the pitch this morning it was like a carpet fantastic pitch it would rival any field in town
lisnagry beat holycross on penaltys 1-1 after normal time wasn't at it but met 1 of the lisnagry players and he said they went up 1 nil after 2 min from a corner and holycross scored a cracking free kick to bring it back level
Granville Rangers 3 - 1 Abbey Rovers
Gerladines 1 1 Mungret B, Geraldines won 2 1 aet we were blessed by all means
Star Rovers 0 Charleville 2
A game of very few chances. Charleville scored an excellent 1st goal, 1-0 up at half time. Star poured forward second half but Charleville defended well and got a second goal with 25 mins to go. Very honest game of football. Must say Star's pitch is in excellent condition so well done to ye and best of luck for rest of season, ye have a nice side
"It's not about winning, it's taking people apart that counts"
Think Charleville defended very well and deserved the victory in the end, so best of luck to them for the rest of the season.
We were poor and have been playing poor for the last few games including v Charleville, our last good performance was v Carew when we won 3-1................we were lucky to beat Moyross 2-1, lucky to beat Caherconlish 2-1 and our 5-0 victory over Coonagh doesn't tell the whole story.
We need to get a few things sorted and get our full side out asap and get the finger out.
That said it was our fisrt defeat at home in a long time.
Results (Limerick section)
Sunday Oct 10th
Munster Junior Cup Round One
Geraldines 2 Mungret B 1 (aet)
Athlunkard Villa 2 Janesboro 3 (aet)
Aisling A 10 Dromore Celtic 1
Star Rvs 0 Charleville 2
Ballynanty Rvs 7 Caledonians 2
Cappamore 6 Polonia Luimni 5
Granville Rgs 3 Abbey Rvs 1
Hyde Rgs 1 Wembley Rvs 2
Munster Junior Cup Round Two
Castle Rvs 0 Prospect Priory 2
Carew Park 4 Corbally Utd 1
Holycross 1 Lisnagry 1
(Lisnagry won 5-4 on pens aet)
Shannon Town A 1 Pike Rvs 2
Fairview Rangers 7 St Patrick's 0
Knockainey v Kennedy Park
Bookmarks