So how can the Irish Times and Extratime get an agreed figure of 650 for Drogs V Fingal then ? Is one feeding the other, or are both from the same source ? And on the estimates of two fans here the figure is increased by 250.
Once again it would make things so much easier if clubs reported crowds in their website match reports, DFC have finally started giving esitmated figs in our website, but even this has changed from official figures given previously in the season.
Last edited by oriel; 10/05/2010 at 7:51 PM.
#DundalkFC - First Irish club to win an away game in Europe (1963), only Irish club to win a game / points in Europa League Group Stage (2016).
I dont think its beyond the realms of reality to think that the Irish Times looked up Extratime and just took that to be the attendance. Extratime have it as an estimate, which is what we are doing.
I also believe that a Drogheda fan would have a better idea of what crowd was in their ground (as long as they are being honest of course) than somebody who doesnt go to the ground that often (me and extratime). When extraime try to judge attendances they tend to be off by quite a bit.
As for clubs giving out attedances. I totally agree. I dont understand why its not done.
Last edited by Lamper.sffc; 10/05/2010 at 8:26 PM.
Plenty of journos ask each other for details but there's no way the IT are looking up extratime for the attendance.
Would they be better of just ringing the club for the official figure ?
Maybe they care as much about the numbers as I do
we can all see what the crowd is. The actual figures mean nothing
The guys writing the two reports were most likely sitting beside each other in the press box and either came up with a guess between them or got the figure from someone. I know that the press are given the official figure by a club official in Belfield soon after half time.
We're not arrogant, we're just better.
I use fans' guesstimates. I'll tend to use the lower or lowest reasonable guesstimate (so if someone says there were 2000 at a match, and someone else says it was more like 1700, I'll go with 1700) because history has shown that people generally overestimate.
I generaly ignore newspaper figures after seeing how laughably inaccurate the likes of the Star were. However, as schumi noted, I know the press get the official figure in Belfield these days, and they've been appearing in the Irish Times all season. I've taken to assuming they do that at all other grounds, and so any irregular figure (like the 3417 at Tallaght) I assume is official unless anyone wants to contradict it.
Well that 3417 figure was actually estimate at 2,200 on extratime...
54,321 sold - wws will never die - ***
---
New blog if anyone's interested - http://loihistory.wordpress.com/
LOI section on balls.ie - http://balls.ie/league-of-ireland/
Doh!
That's in the alternate reality where Joe Hanrahan scored late on in Goodison instead of hitting the bar...
Yeah, it was the following day, I think. Certainly the same week. The Bohs and UCD keepers were brothers too. Howard Kendall mentioned it in the programme notes for the away leg to point out that Irish clubs aren't walkovers at all.
1348 at rovers-ucd tonight. . Looked like there was about 800 rovers
Ahhh
Bookmarks