What manager would you NOT want to see arrive at your club?

[Big Chief]

I've seen Scully's name on here a few times.

I thought he had done pretty well with the clubs he has managed, at least in terms of their league positions.

What is it that makes him a less than desirable manager?

Speaking from a personal opinion I have never been particularly excited by the brand of football his teams play. It was probably no coincidence that Stuart Malcolm had arguably his two best games for Finn Harps against Scully's Shamrock Rovers team and Paul Doolin's Drogheda side. Given that Malcolm was hopeless on the deck but would have headed a meteorite it appears both managers' focus on the long ball played into Malcolm's hands!

I appreciate that the players in the League of Ireland may not share the technique of their Brazilian counterparts but I still think managers should encourage a game plan based on passing and off the ball movement rather than aimless hoofing.

[CarrickFan]

Michael O'Neill x 100

[Acornvilla]

vinny perth

[dfx-]

Not sure Pep could handle the pressure of a big club like Bohs alright. It's alright winning a few tin pot trophies with those Spanish minnows but when the pressure is on and you're only drawing 1-1 with Sligo and the baying hordes in the Jodi are on his back..well that's a whole different ball game.

If it they can get to Gareth Farrelly and Mahon, there's few who can handle it.

Fenlon, Keely, Connor, Doolin, Matthews, Scully, Roderick...no surprises really

[dfx-]

I've seen Scully's name on here a few times.

I thought he had done pretty well with the clubs he has managed, at least in terms of their league positions.

What is it that makes him a less than desirable manager?

He works by making young players or journeymen afraid of him. Cannot handle first-team stalwart players who stand up to him.

[bluewhitearmy]

He works by making young players or journeymen afraid of him. Cannot handle first-team stalwart players who stand up to him.

Well i say let him make them afraid if he gets the results.

[Paddyfield]

He works by making young players or journeymen afraid of him. Cannot handle first-team stalwart players who stand up to him.

Same as Don O'Riordan so

[Leeside Swagger]

Billy Morgan. Remember that rumour last year?Christ that would have been almost as bad as having Roddy as manager.

[Bluebeard]

I heard that if you look in a mirror and chant "Roddy Collins" five times, he comes out through the TV screen when you're dreaming.

[John83]

David Brent.

[WoodquayBoy]

He's not the Messiah he's a very naughty boy!

Gerroff, that's my signature . . .