did someone drop something??
Originally Posted by vidic-class
Did ye get a bye into the 5th Round Planners?I thought we were only at the 3rd Round Stage at the weekend, ye're pulling some amount of strings out in Rineanna this season
Typo on that - Sorry- in any case still in the 4th round waiting to see who'll join us from the CDSL -
CDSL Cup Champions 2008 / 2009 / 2011 / 2013 / 2014 - CDSL League Champions 2010/11 - - - - - - 2011 /12
members - TBC
I would disagree. I definately think that at a certain date some of those lads will not be turning up for them...Would you not agree that they see Rineanna as an easy option?harsh to say them gaa lads are using rineanna to stay fit, they dont show up if they are playing championship but other than that they will give the commitment. think they could go along way in fai with that squad especially if they have home draws. would love to see one of the big guns having to play rineanna at home.
why easy??
Well because they maybe think that they will get their game and more so because it is accepted that when they sign there is an understanding that they will not be committing for the season...this is just an opinion and i am aware that it happens in every club...the point im trying to make is that things may be good out there at the moment but it may soon fade...and it has been the way in Rineanna that they start better in the league than they finish. They could have won a few leagues had this been rectified. I would like Planners to join in the discussion as i would like to hear his views...
By all accounts they dont show up for the championship eitherharsh to say them gaa lads are using rineanna to stay fit, they dont show up if they are playing championship but other than that they will give the commitment. think they could go along way in fai with that squad especially if they have home draws. would love to see one of the big guns having to play rineanna at home.
ya neil dropped a contact lens
did someone drop something??
Last edited by dahamsta; 17/11/2009 at 11:49 AM.
touche!By all accounts they dont show up for the championship either
No First, as you can see Planners was given the coveted No.6 jersey and was in the dressing room for the half-time team talk yesterday so he wasn't involved in the half-time showboating that has become the highlight of many a Rineanna game over the last season or two.
Good win for the Rovers, that's them with a guaranteed place in the FAI Area Cup Final this season
In my opinion the start we have had is on the same lines as the 2006 / 2007 season - we didn't have too many hurlers then - when you look at it we have played 2 games in the MJ - 4 in the FAI and 5 in the league - the league started Aug - at this stage NOF had blind intentions of winning the Cannon cup- these players hadn't signed / played for us in the first 4 league games - then the FAI and MJ kicked off , its a good way of giving other players a run out - lads , at the end of the day these hurlers are training away with us and do deserve a chance to break in as much as anyone else -
In relation to your opinion on the understanding of not commiting - any manager would play week to week and would expect an honest commitment , the majority of managers pick a team on ability and training attendance , getting a nice mix would be perfect but this isn't always the case - the same can been seen at your club -
To say there is an understanding is a bit off the wall and I'm not going to rise to it -
You'll be back soon so I'd keep my powder dry if I were you
CDSL Cup Champions 2008 / 2009 / 2011 / 2013 / 2014 - CDSL League Champions 2010/11 - - - - - - 2011 /12
members - TBC
So you dont think that there is an understanding that when some of those players sign that both the manager, the player and the team know that this is a short-term commitment. It would be ideal for a manahger to have a squad full of just soccer players but in reality these type of players are needed. In Rineanna it is your most important players that will not be available when the hurling starts up whereas in other clubs this does not appear to be the case. Would you not agree?In my opinion the start we have had is on the same lines as the 2006 / 2007 season - we didn't have too many hurlers then - when you look at it we have played 2 games in the MJ - 4 in the FAI and 5 in the league - the league started Aug - at this stage NOF had blind intentions of winning the Cannon cup
In relation to your opinion on the understanding of not commiting - any manager would play week to week and would expect an honest commitment , the majority of managers pick a team on ability and training attendance , getting a nice mix would be perfect but this isn't always the case - the same can been seen at your club -
To say there is an understanding is a bit off the wall and I'm not going to rise to it -
You'll be back soon so I'd keep my powder dry if I were you
And I am not trying to rise you, merely sparking a conversation about a topic...
LL - lets be realistic here , every club knows what they are getting when the GAA lads sign - and you have basically said the same in your post in that it would be ideal to have a full squad of soccer players , I disagree with your statement of them being the most important - we have a fairly large squad with only 5 GAA players - this leaves 17 + lads that are more than capable
Take a look at your own club - there are 4 GAA players , all quiet capable of making the starting 11 , when they FO will that be the down fall given the stregth of ye're current squad ? IMO i don;t think so by the way , allowances are made when you take on GAA players - is it wrong ?? - - in some ways but given the distance that the NOF hurlers got I don't think they'll be in a rush to get back training in Feb for a Chanpionship match in Aug
Last edited by dahamsta; 16/11/2009 at 3:27 PM.
CDSL Cup Champions 2008 / 2009 / 2011 / 2013 / 2014 - CDSL League Champions 2010/11 - - - - - - 2011 /12
members - TBC
[QUOTE=Planners;1274196]Can you name the 4 i know devitt and you cant count in lazylegs because at the moment he is a free agent.So you dont think that there is an understanding that when some of those players sign that both the manager, the player and the team know that this is a short-term commitment. It would be ideal for a manahger to have a squad full of just soccer players but in reality these type of players are needed. In Rineanna it is your most important players that will not be available when the hurling starts up whereas in other clubs this does not appear to be the case. Would you not agree?
And I am not trying to rise you, merely sparking a conversation about a topic...[/QUOT
LL - lets be realistic here , every club knows what they are getting when the GAA lads sign - and you have basically said the same in your post in that it would be ideal to have a full squad of soccer players , I disagree with your statement of them being the most important - we have a fairly large squad with only 5 GAA players - this leaves 17 + lads that are more than capable
Take a look at your own club - there are 4 GAA players , all quiet capable of making the starting 11 , when they FO will that be the down fall given the stregth of ye're current squad ? IMO i don;t think so by the way , allowances are made when you take on GAA players - is it wrong ?? - - in some ways but given the distance that the NOF hurlers got I don't think they'll be in a rush to get back training in Feb for a Chanpionship match in Aug
LL - lets be realistic here , every club knows what they are getting when the GAA lads sign - and you have basically said the same in your post in that it would be ideal to have a full squad of soccer players , I disagree with your statement of them being the most important - we have a fairly large squad with only 5 GAA players - this leaves 17 + lads that are more than capable
Take a look at your own club - there are 4 GAA players , all quiet capable of making the starting 11 , when they FO will that be the down fall given the stregth of ye're current squad ? IMO i don;t think so by the way , allowances are made when you take on GAA players - is it wrong ?? - - in some ways but given the distance that the NOF hurlers got I don't think they'll be in a rush to get back training in Feb for a Chanpionship match in Aug
Is there any chance you coud post up the starting team including the subs that came on?
Spotted this in the Desmond thread pictures
Is there any chance you coud post up the starting team including the subs that came on?[/QUOTE]
. j CASEY
NEIL RYAN P FAHY J EARL
H KELLY P KEYES
COLIN RYAN S KELLY - K KEANE J HAMANN
J ACOURU
C SWEENEY FOR H KELLY
P BUTLER FOR C RYAN
D NASH FOR J ACOURU
- THE LISBON LEADER WILL HAVE ALL THE DETAILS
CDSL Cup Champions 2008 / 2009 / 2011 / 2013 / 2014 - CDSL League Champions 2010/11 - - - - - - 2011 /12
members - TBC
Is this cause for an objection. Note that there is no team name for Rineanna RoversSpotted this in the Desmond thread pictures
[QUOTE=YNWA;1274204]1 - Eoin O Brien
2 - Darren Cullinan
3 - Kieran Devitt
4 - Mike Devitt
5 - Eoin Hayes - has to be mentioned - will be back
6 - Seamus Lawlor - GAA handball
Can you elobrate - I'm on an NC and cannot access these photosIs this cause for an objection. Note that there is no team name for Rineanna Rovers
Last edited by dahamsta; 17/11/2009 at 11:49 AM.
CDSL Cup Champions 2008 / 2009 / 2011 / 2013 / 2014 - CDSL League Champions 2010/11 - - - - - - 2011 /12
members - TBC
[QUOTE=Planners;1274237]mike will be thrilled to be considered a gaa head
How come Tulla Utd A and Rhine Rovers are yet to play a league match this season? I take it the tables on the website are up to date
Tables are up to date yeah. We have had our lg game with Rhine called off on 2 occasions because of weather.
Posting Permissions
Bookmarks