The key question is, how much notice must be given by the fixture secretary that a team must fulfil a fixture?
If Kilmallock were allowed to take this to a court of law, any judge would rule that 90mins is unacceptable, irrespective of the situation.
However, Kilmallock (along with every other club in the country) are precluded in taking legal action against LDMC, FAI etc, so an appeal would be farcical. Imagine LDMC hearing an appeal against themselves, then the FAI hearing an appeal against one of their competitions and arbitration would take too long.
serves you right faces praying all week for the game to be off, keep your mouth shut in future and dont be brinnging attention your way....1 other thing if yer pitch was as bad as you say(like concrete) why were ye out warming up, why was this not called off at 10 or 11 o clock...simple reason ye knew if ye called it off early ye would have to travel in.Originally Posted by faces
[QUOTE=Fr Damo;1295808]think peters were on the beer,, fr,damo the day before to be honest!!!!!!!]
As a bystander, my club were due to play a CCFL cup match on a Tuesday evening last may. St Peters FC Athlone v Mullingar Ath. Kick off was to be 7pm if I remember correctly.
During the day it became apparent our pitch might not be playable due to a waterlogged pitch. At about 3.30 we informed our league and opposition that our pitch was unplayable. By about 4.30 the game was rescheduled for Mullingar (about 40 miles away) and needless to say we weren't happy about it. We quickly phoned around and were met with one or two issues from the players, one was a bar man due to work that evening and then we had two garda lads, who were due to start their shift at 6 the next morning, in Tullamore and Tuam. We told the league we would not be travelling becuase we felt that although the standard cup rule states the game is switched to the opposition venue in the event of the home ground being un playable, to ask a team to make a one hour car journey, at such short notice was very unfair on players, families etc. The game was awarded to Mullingar, appealed to the LFA and duley dismissed. Sorry Kilmallock but rules are rules and although I think asking a team to switch venues is fine if within 20 miles of the orginal venue, anything above that is unreasonable and fixture should be played another day.
[QUOTE=thomas72;1295718]the ref said it was a walk over but i take it there will be an objection so it will be a few weeks before its sorted
............. egg shells.............
[QUOTE=alidiei;1296119]A ref cannot give a walkover, thats for the league/FAI to decide.
what have the boro done wrong could you tell me as for the regional situation the rules were broke and they rightly went threw
............. egg shells.............
The only question that has to be answered is
Were in the updated LDMC rule hand book (that was updated at the start of the season)does it say that a team has to travel to the oppostions field only hours after the match has been called off????
That rule wouldn't be in the LDMC rulebook as it's an FAI competition, it would be in the FAI rulebook Topper.
EVERYTHING is black and white
Thats just textbook................
listen to this fella,it wasn't too long ago ye were down in the garryowen green with yer measuring tapes,and here you are waffling on about old times,spare me
2-1 up with 10 mins left(and time to be added on) and we had been awarded a penalty,this has nothing to do with the FAI cup so stop dragging this thread off topic
Viewman76 are you for real or what. Clubs fight their own corners and rightly so, each and every club have signiicant expenses every season so why would they not put up a fight to stay in the FAI or any other competition. To say Janesboro and Regional are wrong is just absurd, Janesboro travelled a long distance on sunday and are aggrieved at what happened, Regional had every right to object to an illegal player, so i don't understand how you say either of these issues are ruining Limericks reputation. They are two very well run clubs and contribute alot to local soccer on a junior and schoolboy fronts. I get to see alot of junior games this time of year and looking at the limerick premier league compared to any other league its a close and very interesting league to be involved in. Its people like you who try to drag down soccers reputation making ridiculous statements and i don't even know if you really are a Fairview man but your club and every other club no matter if they are premier league or not would stand up and voice their opinions if a decision affected them. I also believe Kilmallock have every right to fight their corner on this, i hope the game goes ahead in the Boro now and may the best team win
this is a very bad situation and it again highlights the poor administration in leagues around the country! It seems to be happening in every league and is becoming increasingly frustrating for teams that try and promote their leagues in a professional manner. It doesnt help when small minded people put up comments about teams being out drinking just to try and take away from rival teams! It really shows up the immiturity of peoples comments. It just sums up that Irish organisations really dont have a clue.
lol
But i do agree with a small bit. Again it is the ldmc incompetence to have something done properly. All clubs playing FAI should have been told (formually during the week) that if the home pitches were unplayable by 11.30 and the away pitch was playable, that the game would revert to the away pitch in the afternoon for a 2pm kick off. But no, they (ldmc) got a call to say it was off, crapped themselves in case the fai gave out about not have the ties complete, and made an on the spot decision to reverse the fixture. IMO that is too late and not right. Apart from the travel, players have eaten/planned for a match at 12, plus junior players should not be on call as it is only junior football.
IMO the Boro have done nothing wrong (maybe they told the ldmc their pitch was playable in hope of the reverse fixture against an understrength Killmallock side), Killmallock have taken a stance on not travelling for whatever reason. I think that match should be played sunday the 27th dec or else Sunday 3rd Jan.....
PS: I never hear on any of the other threads on foot , of players continusouly slagging of the league, highlighting the down falls, as much as people do about the LDMC. To me this is either a crap set up ior else the ldmc like the limelight.....
Last edited by Goals4fun; 22/12/2009 at 7:21 AM.
'You should never have a bad game, off the ball.......'
spot on lad well said.
1.yes we did look for match to be rearranged WHICH WAS DENIED.2.it was up to referee to call off match.
3.we did not know anything about traveling in.
4.its imaterial what any one thinks or says on this matter because its going to be up to fai to handle.
5.i wont shut my mouth when ive nothing to hide or deny.
6.end of and wait for fai descision.
Last edited by faces; 22/12/2009 at 8:06 AM.
you must have amnesia...Refusing to play a lawson cup match because you were still in the fai,(gave a walk over) Trying too humilate a Fine club like geraldine(who have supplied you with most of your players for 20 years) by refusing to play on the garryowen green even though your own fairgreen resembeled a ski jump for 30 years..... i can go on about a lot more instances if you want.. i doubt very much if you have any association with fairview
sick of narcissists.....
Wouldn't go that far but some people think they know the rule book, implementation of those rules is how you judge someones worth.
If it's true that the game was only arranged after boro claimed their pitch was playable it seems al a bit underhanded. Don't know the history of the two teams here so going to keep out of it now!
Why is there so much chaos over this Kilmallock Boro incident? There is alot of mudslinging going on, for absolutley no reason. Neither club have done anything wrong. From what I can make out the facts are as follows:
1. Kilmallock's pitch was unplayable, and the game was quite rightly called off
2. A suggestion was made that the game be played in the Boro. This is not an official obligation and Kilmallock are well within their rights to refuse to travel. I'd say deep down that the Boro were happy to avoid a potentially sticky tie, and now get ome advantage.
This tie should now be settled in the Boro, and not in front of some committee. Lets get to the football lads
This fella most certainly is not a Fairview man, and well spotted
I think it was because there was suggestions that Kilmallock watered the pitch to assist in it being frozen, to get the match off as they had hurlers.
Then the chaos of the ldmc got involved and word seems to be that Boro were handed a walk over......
maybe it is going to be postponed and played at Pearce stadium in the coming weeks, which i hope hapens for the sense of junior football
'You should never have a bad game, off the ball.......'
Posting Permissions
Bookmarks