FAI Junior Cup 2009/10

**Poolman** · 23/03/2010, 10:06 AM

Originally Posted by Monster

Pike are 50/50 to be thrown out and will hear Wednesday but giving St Micheals clout abnove in the FAI they are not optimistic.

Fairview think they are ok with there objection but then again Pike did as well until that meeting last night.

According to star pike will know their fate this morning hopefully common sense will prevail.I'm sure they didn't do anything wrong knowingly.

**carrick hoops** · 23/03/2010, 10:10 AM

"
"heard" from who ??
we all hear things !!!!

**Poolman** · 23/03/2010, 10:17 AM

Originally Posted by thomas72

just heard pike are safe

Where u hear that tomas I'm working with someone from pike here whose on committee and he heard nothing yet.as far as he knows they will find out tomorrow.

**faces** · 23/03/2010, 10:39 AM

Originally Posted by thomas72

just heard pike are safe

are you god because pike dont know the outcome yet.my god what a load of bull****.

**faces** · 23/03/2010, 11:04 AM

Originally Posted by thomas72

just heard pike are safe

sorry lad your spot on.REPLAY

**serpico** · 23/03/2010, 11:10 AM

Originally Posted by faces

sorry lad your spot on.REPLAY

Replay 100% don't think the tipp boys and tommy lewis will be too happy.

**serpico** · 23/03/2010, 11:14 AM

Originally Posted by faces

sorry lad your spot on.REPLAY

The same outcome might come of yeres as well.

**Longshanks** · 23/03/2010, 11:20 AM

Originally Posted by faces

sorry lad your spot on.REPLAY

Why Replay the game?? If illegal players were played(intentionally or unintentionally) the game should be forfieted, if there was no breach of the rules the result should stand. Black and White. Seems like a 'fudge' of the issue if you ask me.

**hooper74** · 23/03/2010, 11:31 AM

Originally Posted by Longshanks

Why Replay the game?? If illegal players were played(intentionally or unintentionally) the game should be forfieted, if there was no breach of the rules the result should stand. Black and White. Seems like a 'fudge' of the issue if you ask me.

can Pike play the illegal players in the replay??

**hooper74** · 23/03/2010, 11:52 AM

Originally Posted by redcardrory

carroll was the only person and ldmc took the rap for it cos he was only short a day for amatuer status so all players are available against st.micheals i wouldn't like to be their goal keeper in the replay cos all of their panel are available including barry

replay is a long way off,saints are going to the senior council with an appeal,there is no precedent for a replay,you either break the rules or you dont,there is no inbetween

**Tipp Top** · 23/03/2010, 12:01 PM

Originally Posted by redcardrory

thats where the problem lies cos the fai rules that they brought in last year from senior council was not clear enough for league secs to under stand and i can see this been thrown out by senior council so st.micheals are better off doing the replay,fai don't need a black eye cos of their own rules (rule44)

Clonmel Town didnt get a replay when Pike had them thrown out???

**thomas72** · 23/03/2010, 12:20 PM

replay it is so has micheals agreed to play it??
out of the six objections gone in will all those players be able to play??
will micheals keep home advantage??

which team will be happest with this result micheals will prob say pike broke the rules they should be thrown out and might turn down the replay and take it further.

pike will be fuming having to start all over again but what they have in there favour is there 3 best players will be back for them alan barry, keith hartnett, and i think wanye colbert

**leather** · 23/03/2010, 12:22 PM

you might aswell be short 1 year as one day....if players are illegal team should be out..... if players are legal team progress...it all black and white...
and it is the players and the clubs responsibilty to have thier eligibilty correct... pike were not aware that C.Carroll had played for Limk..Thought cork were his previous LOI club....
So ldmc took the rap for an illegal player....and people are on here saying that st micks have clout....???

**Poolman** · 23/03/2010, 12:51 PM

Originally Posted by leather

you might aswell be short 1 year as one day....if players are illegal team should be out..... if players are legal team progress...it all black and white...
and it is the players and the clubs responsibilty to have thier eligibilty correct... pike were not aware that C.Carroll had played for Limk..Thought cork were his previous LOI club....
So ldmc took the rap for an illegal player....and people are on here saying that st micks have clout....???

What a riduclous post from you of course pike were aware of Carroll playing for Limerick, and he wasn't a day out so get you're facts right he who knows all????

**serpico** · 23/03/2010, 12:55 PM

Originally Posted by leather

you might aswell be short 1 year as one day....if players are illegal team should be out..... if players are legal team progress...it all black and white...
and it is the players and the clubs responsibilty to have thier eligibilty correct... pike were not aware that C.Carroll had played for Limk..Thought cork were his previous LOI club....
So ldmc took the rap for an illegal player....and people are on here saying that st micks have clout....???

I'm surprised with you leather of course pike knew Colm played with Limerick.

**leather** · 23/03/2010, 1:04 PM

Blind faith in anything is a very dangerous path to go down...

**Bonovox** · 23/03/2010, 1:08 PM

It will be interesting to see if there is any fallout from LDMC in terms of accountability - if they messed up then heads should roll.

**leather** · 23/03/2010, 1:12 PM

Originally Posted by Bonovox

It will be interesting to see if there is any fallout from LDMC in terms of accountability - if they messed up then heads should roll.

Best joke of the year so far......excluding anything involving the FAI...

**serpico** · 23/03/2010, 1:14 PM

Originally Posted by redcardrory

why can't we all from limerick on this fai post just back the limerick teams wheather we like them or not the best of luck to fairview with their hearing

What about kilmallock Rory are they not from limerick.