What flag if any was used....

[Tipp Townie]

Without wanting to hijack SligoBhoy's thread, a quick flag-related question for Ealing Green and any other NI fans-

I noticed a while back in a photo from the famous win over Spain in '82 that the team name ("Irland de Nord" or summat like that) was represented on the big scoreboard on a background of the tricolour! Sorry i havent got any pics to hand. (And with relevance to the thread, i'm not sure if the tricolour was 'flown' anywhere around the ground.)

Could well have been a wind up by the hosts, rather than stupidity/laziness. I guess given the basic graphics on the scoreboard it would have been very difficult to replicate the NI flag itself, but still!

I just wondered if this was noticed by the NI fans at the time, and if so, whether it caused any controversy. Probably not given that yous were probably too busy celebrating at the time!

Sorry, i warned you that it was a geeky post..

[Da Real Rover]

ealing green what's you take on creating an all ireland team now is there steadfast opposition to it in the protestant community ?

Id hazard a guess at yes.
Maybe im way off the mark but I always interpreted that Domestic Football in Ireland as a whole is a different animal to the likes of Rugby or GAA in its supporter base which leads us to understand how Football has not overcome partitionist splits like the GAA or Rugby.

That being where the GAA predominantly comes from a history of rural support primarily being of the Nationalist variety because of its much documented history of being entangled with cultural nationalism at the turn of the century. So therefore those who support GAA North and South of the border are largely cut from the same cloth and therefore an All Ireland League and championship has little or no resistance.

Then with Rugby which historically has its roots in the upper class of the Island (bar Limerick of course), both protestant and catholic has much the same situation as the GAA. Most of the wars, skirmishes and disputes in this Island have historically been waged through the working class of both the Catholic and Protestant communities (with some obvious noteable exceptions) so thus there would not be the same emnity between the respective creeds in the upper class, obviously there will be an element but not to such an extent to make an All Ireland Rugby League unworkable.

Then we come to Domestic Football which historically in Ireland has its roots in the urban working class of Ireland. Both Protestant and Catholic. As the majority of wars and disputes have been waged through the working class, even the previous 30 years of troubles its understandable where there will be an emnity between both sides of the divide who participate in Football. When most people in the south hear of The Bogside, The Falls, Short Strand etc they think Republican areas or the like, when in reality they are working class areas. Just as when people down here hear of the Shankill, Mount Vernon or the Fountain they think Loyalist when in reality they are the working class areas of the other side of the divide. Thus it only makes sense that there will continue to be a partitionist league and partitionist National Team in Ireland with the historical backdrop of Irish Domestic Football supporters.

There are of course exceptions to the rule and this is far from 100% accurate, merely dealing with generalisations of course, but it certainly helps me understand the partitionist divide in football in Ireland.

[gspain]

I think it has less to do with class rather than the fact that football split into 2 associations at the time of independence for what is now the Republic of Ireland.

Football has strong middle class roots anyway on this island with gentleman amateur teams such as Bohemians and Cliftonville.

Peter Byrne's official history of the FAI 1996 (updated edition due shortly - hopefully) is generally accepted as being accurate on this. There are extracts posted on this site if you care to search.

The IFA and other "home" associations did everything to stop the FAI as they considered the IFA as the governing body for football on this island even post independence. In 1950 FIFA finally forced the IFA to stop picking southern born players. FIFA had to intervene again in 1954 to decide on the term "Ireland".

NI fans are very proud of their team and certainly don't want to lose it which in reality is what would happen. They see us as their main rivals and hence a merger to them is the equivalent of us merging with England.

[Gather round]

what's you take on creating an all ireland team now

Totally opposed. Not interested in merging with other teams. See threads passim.

is there steadfast opposition to it in the protestant community ?

There's steadfast opposition within the Northern Ireland fans community.

[Da Real Rover]

Football has strong middle class roots anyway on this island with gentleman amateur teams such as Bohemians and Cliftonville.

Indeed many clubs were formed along those lines.
But as those clubs grew you can trace the majority of their support base and where they priamrily hailed from.
With Cliftonville historically they pulled support from the North Belfast/Ardoyne Nationalist community which as im sure you are well aware is predominantly working class. Now of course its different as they pull alot of support from West Belfast also, the collapse of Belfast Celtic has alot to do with that.
As with the likes of Bohs which grew out of the Phibsborough area and the North Dublin Area which is also predominantly working class.
In fact you will find the vast majority of Domestic Football Grounds are actually located in working class areas as this is where they garnered the overwhelming amount of their support.

[Gather round]

With Cliftonville historically they pulled support from the North Belfast/Ardoyne Nationalist community which as im sure you are well aware is predominantly working class. Now of course its different as they pull alot of support from West Belfast also, the collapse of Belfast Celtic has alot to do with that

When I started watching Irish League football (about 1970) they had a lot of unionist support. Much of which was middle class as GSpain suggests. I went to Cliftonville primary school (next door to the ground). The area was more mixed then than now.

[Predator]

Totally opposed. Not interested in merging with other teams. See threads passim.



There's steadfast opposition within the Northern Ireland fans community.

OT but...
Why is that? If it can be done with no problems in the rugby, why is there such opposition with the soccer teams?

[Gather round]

OT but...
Why is that? If it can be done with no problems in the rugby, why is there such opposition with the soccer teams?

GSpain has already answered your question. We (NI fans) support NI- we're not interested in merging with anyone else any more than you are in fielding a joint team with England. It is international sport, after all. As for Britain having four international teams, I'll admit it's an oddity but one that works. And less anachronistic in recent years as other large European countries have broken into smaller units.

You'll have to ask someone else about rugby union- I've no real interest in or knowledge of it.

I talk to fans from the South when watching the Irish cricket team. Everyone largely gets on fine, but I'll be honest I'd prefer it was a NI side. Incidentally only three of the 15 man Irish squad in this year's cricket World Cup grew up in the South.

[EalingGreen]

(To answer Tony Soprano's earlier query) It's nearly 40 years since I was first taken to watch NI. I was too young to know or care about religion or politics etc.
I became a fan then and have been a fan since, during which time they have been sometimes sh1te, frequently mediocre and just occasionally sublime.
I have no desire to see my team disappear into some merged entity, whether that be a United Ireland team, a United Kingdom team or a United-any-other-feckin-combination team.
It's my team, I welcome anyone else who wants to join me in supporting them, but am not bothered by people who choose to follow another team, or none, since that is their loss (imo).
And whilst I have at least a passing interest in other sports, such as rugby and cricket, neither those or any other can ever get me anything like as excited as Our Wee Country's team.
Others may nor understand or agree with me on this - fine, that's their prerogative, just as it is mine to feel as I do.

That's it, really.

P.S. Re Tony S's reference to the views of "the Protestant community" on such matters, I couldn't give a fig about that "community" or any other which identifies itself around the tribal divisions of NI. When it comes to football, the only "tribe" I'm interested in is the "Green and White Army" and I've yet to meet one other member whose opinions vary significantly from my own on this topic.

[Gather round]

See you in Katowice for a swift half before the game EG (our party decided to stay in Krakow so we're bussing in, late afternoon).

[EalingGreen]

Without wanting to hijack SligoBhoy's thread, a quick flag-related question for Ealing Green and any other NI fans-

I noticed a while back in a photo from the famous win over Spain in '82 that the team name ("Irland de Nord" or summat like that) was represented on the big scoreboard on a background of the tricolour! Sorry i havent got any pics to hand. (And with relevance to the thread, i'm not sure if the tricolour was 'flown' anywhere around the ground.)

Could well have been a wind up by the hosts, rather than stupidity/laziness. I guess given the basic graphics on the scoreboard it would have been very difficult to replicate the NI flag itself, but still!

I just wondered if this was noticed by the NI fans at the time, and if so, whether it caused any controversy. Probably not given that yous were probably too busy celebrating at the time!

Sorry, i warned you that it was a geeky post..

Yep, you're right, the scoreboard did display a Tricolour for at least part of that game. I doubt very much that it was a wind-up, more likely just an oversight by some dopey Scoreboard operator.
And no, no-one I've ever met has ever got the slightest bit bothered by it. As for myself, quite frankly the Scoreboard Operator could have been knocking off my missus at the time and I wouldn't have cared.

[EalingGreen]

See you in Katowice for a swift half before the game EG (our party decided to stay in Krakow so we're bussing in, late afternoon).

Look forward to it.

Apparently there will be a "Fans Zone" organised in Katowice before the game with bars etc, from where we will all be bussed directly to the stadium. We will be held back for an hour after the game, when buses will run us back to the fans' zone (or possibly also our hotels in the centre of Katowice). Jim Reilly and the Amalgamation of NISC's are "on-the-ball" over this, in conjunction with the two FA's and the local police.

The IFA have requested up to 1,500 tickets, though are only expecting a bit over a thousand to travel. (I suspect the trouble around the Belfast game has deterred quite a few fans, especially the older/female/kids etc.)

[Predator]

The IFA have requested up to 1,500 tickets, though are only expecting a bit over a thousand to travel. (I suspect the trouble around the Belfast game has deterred quite a few fans, especially the older/female/kids etc.)

You guys would need to be careful. Have you seen the Ross Kemp episode on Polish football hooliganism?!

Here.

I remember watching it last year. The first sentence and the accompanying footage are unsettling!

[Tipp Townie]

As for myself, quite frankly the Scoreboard Operator could have been knocking off my missus at the time and I wouldn't have cared.

Hahaha, made me laugh.

Thanks for the response EG.

[Bluebeard]

Yep, you're right, the scoreboard did display a Tricolour for at least part of that game. I doubt very much that it was a wind-up, more likely just an oversight by some dopey Scoreboard operator.
And no, no-one I've ever met has ever got the slightest bit bothered by it. As for myself, quite frankly the Scoreboard Operator could have been knocking off my missus at the time and I wouldn't have cared.

This for me most epitomises why there is opposition to the idea of a single football team subsuming both and calling itself Ireland. As the name seems to mean the South for most people, I suppose one could liken it to how the Southerners among us would feel if all five island teams were lumped into the one and called "The British Isles".

[third policeman]

GSpain has already answered your question. We (NI fans) support NI- we're not interested in merging with anyone else any more than you are in fielding a joint team with England..

I am seriously not trying to revive a futile discussion about the merits of a united football team, but your suggested parallels avoid one significant and differentiating fact. A very large section of the NI population dont identify with the NI football team rightly or wrongly, they support RoI and we all meet them on a regular basis at RoI games. This worries me, because contrary to your and EG's blinkered and unsustainable platitudes about the non-sectarian ambience at NI games, football on this Ireland has become polarised in an increasingly ugly way. (This includes RoI fans abusing Rangers players and hard-line Republicans in the North wearing RoI shirts as some sort of alternative fashion accessory to black berets). Perhaps a united team is not the answer but niether is Panglossian complacency.

[Gather round]

perhaps a united team is not the answer but niether is Panglossian complacency

TP, equally I don't really want to revive a sneering match, but spare us the patronising literary criticism. It's pretentious and irrelevant to the discussion.

My attitude is neither blinkered not unsustainable. I've no problem with NI based football fans supporting the South, as I've said on here and elsewhere repeatedly. Similarly I know the ambience at NI games from going to them, clearly it has improved hugely in recent years. But I'm not complacent at all, again as repeated regularly here.

Stop stirring, eh?

PS on a slightly lighter note (I hope), we were entertained in the stadium by two Polish fans with Celtic jerseys and a tricolor. And by a local steward in a Rangers jersey

[ifk101]

You need to understand Gather round that third policeman is a "supporter" of both teams. Third policeman can identify with both teams and assumes that deep-down everyone else can. What he fails to understand is that no genuine football would wish the disbandment of their team.

[third policeman]

You need to understand Gather round that third policeman is a "supporter" of both teams. Third policeman can identify with both teams and assumes that deep-down everyone else can. What he fails to understand is that no genuine football would wish the disbandment of their team.

You are right I was brought up to support both teams and its hard to give up on that instinct. So well done to NI. Great performance against Poland ands the prospect of two Irish teams in South Africa is absolutely fantastic.

However you are wrong that I have ever suggested disbanding the NI team. I did once suggest that an All-Ireland team might participate in the proposed Celtic cup competition as a way of allowing football fans in the North to actually cheer for the same team for once. This was and continues to be motivated not by a desire to see the end of the NI team, but see an end to the alarming and hostile polarization of footballing loyalties on a sectarian basis.

It might be a stupid and niaive idea but it that's the case it should be countered without misrepresentation or simplifaction.

[ifk101]

This was and continues to be motivated not by a desire to see the end of the NI team, but see an end to the alarming and hostile polarization of footballing loyalties on a sectarian basis.

It might be a stupid and niaive idea but it that's the case it should be countered without misrepresentation or simplifaction.

Yes it is a stupid and naive idea because the issue you speak of is not induced by football but has found expression through football. Ultimately this is a social issue and beyond the premise of a football forum.