BBC's Top Keepers (No Given)

[L37Ultra]

Why did Given vote? I thought it was only the managers and captains?

Ya they even named Given as the Ireland captain on Sky Sports News. Maybe its based on the last International game and wasn't Given captain against Poland?

[Drumcondra 69er]

I think Given's very good but he's not the best in the Premiership.

Reina, Friedel and James have all been better this season. Cech is not as good as he used to be but he's still a very good keeper. Jaaskelainen and Green are also two very good keepers. VDS is over-rated though.

He's definitely nowhere near the top four in the world.

Nonsense, James has been at his most error prone for years this season , Freidal is a very solid keeper but I''d rate Given above him and Reina. Cech has undoubtedly not been the same since his injury, had a shocking European Championships and has also been inconsistent for Chelsea this season. Jaaskelainen is an excellent keeper alright but Green has yet to show the level of consistency you'd get from Given.