good explaination.point taking on boardOriginally Posted by jock mib
well you got the answer there in your post, we are given the rules of soccer fifa and are told to inforce our interpretation of those rules we can only inforce what we see and we are one person in a fast game with no use of assistants, we might not get into the best position for a call but are always trying, what a referee sees could be interpreted differently by another it happens in all levels. Look at the referein at the highest level they have all the best training etc and still make mistakes.
As i say to everyone there is a reason i blow the whistle or not if you ask me i will respond to you if you f and blind me i will deal with it a different way. Its up to you's the players and managers you take up that opportunity to communicate with me or not
--------------------------------------------------------------
We played Hyde a couple of weeks ago and we had the young ref(Name anybody??)
The Hyde Forward gave the ref some abuse and the ref just gave it straight back...First bit of common sense by a ref iv seen this season,he realised that things are said in the heat of the moment and didnt over-react!!
"The World Cup is a truly International event." John Motson
Wow, it will be Corbally for the FAI next!!
I think you don't have all the facts or even accurate ones at that (apart from nabs being sent off)
'You should never have a bad game, off the ball.......'
what was he sent off for
And now you said it.Was talking to a few wembley player's and they said paul mccormack got the same as dunphy for a mistimed tackle.They said he caught him alright but it's hardly as bad as throwing punches.call the ref something in the heat of the moment or throw punches,no difference now with these decisions.
should Wembley play a 4-3-3 or a 4-4-2?
I dont know,should they?
There's always one... maybe next yearWow, it will be Corbally for the FAI next!!
I know that, but in all fairness, which offence is worse?well alan you cant really call a ref that
1) Verbally abusing an official in the heat of the moment (which happens a lot), if the refs makes a poor decision
or
2) A violent attack on an apposing player?
I would say the latter, but yet it gets less punishment!!!!!!!
Last edited by abbeyvale; 30/10/2008 at 7:58 AM.
No he turned the page to write the goalscorers!!!!
Well you got the answer there in your post, we are given the rules of soccer Fifa and are told to inforce our interpretation of those rules we can only inforce what we see and we are one person in a fast game with no use of assistants, we might not get into the best position for a call but are always trying, what a referee sees could be interpreted differently by another it happens in all levels. Look at the referein at the highest level they have all the best training etc and still make mistakes.
as i say to everyone there is a reason i blow the whistle or not if you ask me i will respond to you if you F and Blind me i will deal with it a different way. Its up to you's the players and managers you take up that opportunity to communicate with me or not
Yes, but not ALL refs are the same (most wont communicate with players)
Some refs love the power and at times it goes to their heads.
I could name more than a few refs that WILL NOT EXPLAIN a decision (not even to the captain), and would rather threaten the player by telling him to move away or be booked.
For me, a better ref, is one who will take a second or two to explain a decision (whether or not the player agrees), and IMO if all refs done this they would have more respect on a football pitch, from both players and supporters.
Last edited by abbeyvale; 30/10/2008 at 8:01 AM.
I had one who thankfully doesnt ref anymore tell me to "Get the f**k out of my face or ill put you outside the gate".. when i question a decision.. now the fact that i was playing and managing the team did not make any difference. I had to take myself off soon after as i felt i would have done something stupid. The point is, some refs will not take the time to defuse situations and in some cases make it worse...
Big fan Jock keep up the good work
the oldest player that i know turns out for Boro would be dom Fitz..approx 26yrs.the majority would have between 2 and four years expierience playing premier with the club..some a little less..
Hi All,
Just a quick question, who would be the oldest person currently playing in the Premier League?
Gordan Stewart i think...
Ian Sullivan?
it was always going to be a tough season for ye so considering the experienced heads ye lost, when it comes to the matches which are battles a young side will find it tough cos most of them wont be used to it
From Aisling? is he still playing?
as tough a job as referee's have and i do think its a thankless job, most of them dont do themselves any favours. we had the same referee 2 games runnin and in the first game i've never seen a ref take so much abuse but he just laughed it off and didnt book a single player for mouthin, and the followin week he was dishin out yellows for questioning a decision!!I had one who thankfully doesnt ref anymore tell me to "Get the f**k out of my face or ill put you outside the gate".. when i question a decision.. now the fact that i was playing and managing the team did not make any difference. I had to take myself off soon after as i felt i would have done something stupid. The point is, some refs will not take the time to defuse situations and in some cases make it worse...
Big fan Jock keep up the good work
Posting Permissions
Bookmarks