I feel oddly nervous about this decision. There's part of me that is delighted to see Mick given another shot, given the way he was forced out, and particularly as it comes at Keane's expense. But I feel a little subdued about it, and I think it has to do with the timing - if Mick had been in the job since the start of this year I'd probably have felt much better about it as he would have had time to settle back into the role at the same time as building the team up. First time round in 1996 he started with a record of five defeats and two draws in friendlies and the 1998 campaign was so-so at best. This time he will be going straight into competitive action.
Also, I know a lot of people have complained about Ireland's performances under O'Neill recently, but I noted months ago that this was a transitional phase with new players coming in, some key players out injured, and O'Neill trying out a new formation and said that the results and performances could well be below par. I know he got ridiculed for playing Cyrus Christie in central midfield, but what are you supposed to do when half your available Premier League players are right-backs? Our lack of goals and chances is certainly a big worry but our defence tightened up after the Wales debacle, and we only conceded twice in our five games since then, keeping our Danish tormentors scoreless over 180 minutes and picking up a couple of points which could yet prove valuable in getting a place in the play-offs - and our team was still largely made up of players with fewer than a dozen caps.
On the other hand, I didn't have the misfortune of sitting through the games and perhaps I would have a harsher view of O'Neill if I had - was there really little or no improvement over the last eight months or so? Plus hearing of the rudimentary nature of training sessions, with little or no focus on setpieces, and seeing the possession stats does make me think that it might have been time for MONKEANO to go. Fans complained that Trap didn't believe enough in his players but MON's philosophy seemed much worse than Trap's. And one of the great things about the team when Mick was in charge was the belief that, while they acknowledged defeat was possible, they believed that victory was always possible and often likely and thus knew that there was no reason to be afraid and played that way.
So, maybe the draw will be kind and give us a couple of easier games to start the qualifiers with so that Mick can get settled. And hopefully we'll see a couple of youngsters break through between now and then and some of the players MON brought in over the last few months will step up a gear and that, at the very least, we'll be competitive when the play-offs roll around in March 2020, assuming we make it. And of course Mick always led us to second place in qualifiers, which will be enough this time around
Bookmarks