
Originally Posted by
fruice
It’s hard to beat the sheer numbers that clubs like Corinthians, Douglas Hall, Avondale and Carrigaline have to work with. When you’re competing with that level of player base, it naturally creates a gap. Yes, they run into a different issue where their very top talent inevitably moves on to bigger and better things, which brings its own challenges, but even with that, a club with a decent structure simply can’t compete with those setups consistently.
Maybe the expansion of steps in the LOI pyramid will help balance things out over time, but at the moment the disparity is very real.
As for the AUL, I do think a lot of clubs—especially those on the junior side—made the wrong call moving across. One or two of them would absolutely have been better off staying put. I’d agree that the freefall seems to have stopped, but the league structures are still totally off. To be fair, they have started putting steps in place to address this, but it’s a long road back.
The biggest issue for me is that the top division just isn’t competitive. Coachford are miles ahead; they have their house in order from top to bottom. The rest of the Premier looks completely structureless—clubs are scrambling around trying to pick up players from here and there. That’s grand in the short term, but there’s only so many of those available, and if you’re not producing your own, you will always hit a ceiling with that approach.
Even if a club manages to piece together a decent team and gets a bit of success, it’s usually short-lived. If the lads were willing to jump ship at the start, they’ll jump ship again the second something better comes along. To catch Coachford, you need a club with real structure coming up through the ranks. Watergrasshill made a good effort and still reached their limit. Mallow Town might be one to watch if they stick at it—they’ve huge numbers underage, so the potential is there.
Social media could be better, but realistically, doing it right is a full-time job. You’d need someone actively around the grounds, and given the geographic spread of the league, that becomes an expensive venture very quickly.
The Astro project will be a massive boost once it’s finished. But if the plan is to use it mainly as a home for the homeless clubs, then yes, numbers will go up—but will the quality of the league actually rise? That’s the real question.
Bookmarks