I appreciate what Innishvilla and Hooper are saying and do not wish to argue. I still say all games in the Munster Junior Cup go to penalties up to and including the final. Could I suggest one of you contact the Secretary of the Munster Football Association.Originally Posted by hooper74
As if that would bring clarity. Can we leave this redundant argument as Town won the game in the second period of extra time. In the unlikely event that the second semi is played, I'm sure this argument could be ressurected then.
Sorry - just trying to be helpful. Let me have the final word - I am 100% correct when I say there are no replays in the Munster Junior Cup. There are no replays in the Munster Youths Cup including the final on Saturday night. There are no replays in the F.A.I. Junior Cup including semi-finals and finals.
incorrect again,fairview beat st michaels in a replayed fai final in 2002, anyway its a pointless argument the Clonmel and Villa players would not have been taking penalties,maybe the referee was wrong and it would have caused more appeals, anyway lets all move on
True, but an awful lot of rules regarding the F.A.I. Junior Cup have changed in eight years, wouldn't you agree? No replays is one of them.
Fair point,i think the problem is nobody seems to know the rules and thats why we find ourselves in the mess that we are in now
Typical FAI re inconsistency between rules and competitions. Leinster Senior Cup final, for example, goes to extra time and then replay. No pens in first game. Always has been that way.
I have followed up and yes it is as was thought no replays - it seems they forgot to delete the clause about replays in rule 5 of the Munster Junior cup rules when the no replay rule was implemented a few years ago...
”That should be NO problem for the defence – OH NOOOO!!”
George Hamilton...
http://www.innishvilla.com
Well, they will have to do it at first time of asking this year.
You are 100% correct
pike are back in mun jun
PIKE ROVERS V CARRICK UTD is on sat 29th may jackman pack limerick,cant figure out why there not gone from mjc aswell????
great news for pike,but surely we are heading for more delays now,one presumes this decision can be challenged and what does this say about the fai decisions assuming the player concerned played in mjc.
Is this true !!!, strange happenings how can they been deemed out of order in two competiations and legal in the MJC. Seems a very odd occurance. Munster committee sitting on the fence like the FAI Jnr council waiting for others to do the nasty work. Surely more objections to follow.
It was Limerick95fm this morning that the Munster Junior Council were happy that the player in question did not play in any rounds of the MJC.
I could have swore he played against Fairview in the fairgreen
Will Carrick United lodge an objection?
Just quoting what was on the radio..Im sure Carrick could ask for the match cards from previous rounds and it will be easy to check if he played or not.
Actually according to the match report on the Limerick website http://www.limericksoccer.com/limerickleaderreports.htm he did play against Fairveiw
Last edited by gaidin; 18/05/2010 at 10:31 AM.
where areyou getting youre 2 competitions from.is it the senior cup youre on about.
on what grounds could carrick logde an objection they didnt play pike yet?
Posting Permissions
Bookmarks