Forgetting about sporting integrity and morals, heres My two cents:
Early feeling is that the clubs have 'shot their load' too early. Everyone in the game between politicans to broadcasters to fans to football associations are against it. They have no public backing. Seems a very strategic mistake, there is just a wave of negetivity. By the time it starts (which we assume now is next september), the clubs will be in massive legl fights, Government possibly passing legislation against it , and months of propaganda from Sky and BT sports (who dont have the rights) against it.
The competition has no tradition or integrity. Thats a mountain for any new tournament to overcome.
As for going for emerging markets in India and China, having spent time in those countries, I think its fair to say that their sports culture works very differently to ours. I lived in Korea and travelled a bit, it was very rare to see any sports jerseys on kids (esp non local ones from high-schools). Football was always on t.v but was never a topic of conversation. At most, people were concerned with national team. These are super compeitive cultures (esp for children), there isnt much room to following sport teams from another continant for kids. Its not like Asian countires are having a massive baby boom either, and their populations are getting older. I just dont see the massive expansion for Super league clubs from the market. The only option is compete for a 'slice of the pie' of the English, Italian and Spanish leagues.I just dont see any inovation. Everyone has no option but to fight tooth and nail against it.
(Obv, preaching to the choir here.... it also just seems boring..)