Printable View
Why did we sign him? Only now have I recovered enough from the depression he induced on friday night to post about it. Candidate for the worst ever performance in a city jersey? He couldn't pass, he couldn't run, he couldn't tackle. The only thing he looked capable of doing was heading the ball IF it came straight at him. He ballsed up for both goals BRING BACK BENNO!
Eanna.
I dunno if you can blame Coughlan for both goals. It seeemed to me that both Coughlan and Murray were equally to blame. It was Murrays worst game for City IMO. The communication between Murray, Coughlan and Devine seemed non existent. Having said all that Coughlan was in terrible as he always is against nippy fast forwards. Coughlans always at his best against a big man with planty of aerial combat.
To my mind Coughlans performance just showed how much we need Bennett back in next to Murray. They had an understanding all through the season. I know Bennett made mistakes. There weren't that many but unluckily for him and more importantly for City they were punished.
Next Sunday at UCD Bennett for Coughlan and George for Behan !
Sure didn't Bennett come on and in my opinion was equally as bd a Dan or Derek, couldn't even control the ball.Quote:
Originally posted by Éanna
BRING BACK BENNO!
:confused:
I have to say I agree with Eanna. We could have used the money to get another striker, for instance. Derek is ok, but he is not an improvement on what we had already, so why sign him?
Maybe he will improve some bit, but he will never be able to run at any kind of speed. Needless signing.
[SIZE=1]I really hope he proves me completely wrong[/SIZE]
I didn't get out to see the game, so I'm relying on the tv coverage, but it looked to me that Dan was at fault for the first goal.
Coughlan hasn't been that bad up to now. I thought he was great in the rovers game and been solid since then.
Derek isn't match fit yet and should improve.
How was Derek at fault for the first goal??
Murray and Devine should have been talking to each other.
Murray and Coughlan had a shocking game but so did a number of others.
City are a stronger team and squad because of Derek's presence.
of all the back 4 i thought derek possibly had the best individual game. he won everything in the air (as you would expect) and made some decent covering tackles. the real problem i thought was the lack of communication, sparked by the fact that dan and derek didn't look comfortable playing next to each other at all. both the fullbacks were exposed by the lack of organisation from the center halves.
dan is captain, and while benno was playing would have organised the defence. now suddenly dels back and nobody seemed to know who was in charge. if the 2 lads can sort it out, they could be a very good combo, better than dan and bennet imo. but based on fridays game, they've a lot of work to do. dan is captain and should take charge, but being a non citizen and relatively new to the club, you can understand why he'd be reluctant to tread on dereks toes (plus the size of coughlan i wouldn't like to be risking annoying him like!). its up to the 2 lads and dolan to sort out, but it does need to be addressed.
They were good together for the Rovers match. I don't what went of for the Pats match.
Murray was totally at fault for the first goal.
Derek had a tendency to go AWOL up the pitch later in the game as he was dragged out by the forward he marking.
That combo can only get better. :eek:
Yeah, Dan was at fault for the first primarily, but Derek was badly positioned for it IMO. My attitude is- if it ain't broke, don't fix it, and Benno and Murray were getting better all the time. The money could have been better spent. Agree with patsh though- hope he proves me wrong.Quote:
Originally posted by niamh
How was Derek at fault for the first goal??
Murray and Devine should have been talking to each other.
Murray and Coughlan had a shocking game but so did a number of others.
City are a stronger team and squad because of Derek's presence.
I think Derek has unsettled Dan a bit.He was playing brilliant stuff until coughlans return.Quote:
Originally posted by yiddo
Eanna.
I dunno if you can blame Coughlan for both goals. It seeemed to me that both Coughlan and Murray were equally to blame. It was Murrays worst game for City IMO. The communication between Murray, Coughlan and Devine seemed non existent. Having said all that Coughlan was in terrible as he always is against nippy fast forwards. Coughlans always at his best against a big man with planty of aerial combat.
To my mind Coughlans performance just showed how much we need Bennett back in next to Murray. They had an understanding all through the season. I know Bennett made mistakes. There weren't that many but unluckily for him and more importantly for City they were punished.
Next Sunday at UCD Bennett for Coughlan and George for Behan !
you could be right. Dan and Benno were foring a good partnership that was getting better by the game. I think Dan and Derek are too similar, with Derek being the poorer of the two by quite a distance.Quote:
Originally posted by Cityace
I think Derek has unsettled Dan a bit.He was playing brilliant stuff until coughlans return.
Derek's biggest fault is that he cant run for his life but then again Murray's is if gets the ball(which he does alot) its always hoofed up to the left and most teams have copped on to this.
sit down and shut ur face,granted benno is better this season thatn last.last season he was awful and wats better than awful?...badQuote:
Originally posted by Éanna
BRING BACK BENNO!
correctQuote:
Originally posted by razor
Sure didn't Bennett come on and in my opinion was equally as bd a Dan or Derek, couldn't even control the ball.
:confused:
this is a forum for discussion, no need to bite my face off. P.s. I am sitting down :)Quote:
Originally posted by ccfcman
sit down and shut ur face,granted benno is better this season thatn last.last season he was awful and wats better than awful?...bad
Benno is a much better player than derek coughlan can ever hope to be
yes i am the anti-bennet
your parents must be so proud of you :rolleyes: get behind the team will yaQuote:
Originally posted by ccfcman
yes i am the anti-bennet
You're obviously either not very good at judging the performances of a footballer or you haven't seen Benno play much this season?Quote:
Originally posted by ccfcman
sit down and shut ur face,granted benno is better this season thatn last.last season he was awful and wats better than awful?...bad
Or he is full of poo..........Quote:
Originally posted by Colm
You're obviously either not very good at judging the performances of a footballer or you haven't seen Benno play much this season?
Bennett and Murray had combined as a very effective central defensive pairing. i don't see any reason why that should hjave been broken up on the arrival of coughlan, i had assumed he was being brought in as cover. i'd have bennett in there first anyway
bennett is rubbish give me a break,just cuz dolan luvs him doesnt mean i will.ffs his"good"performances r so few,hes a big donkey and when he turns its akin to a small oil tanker
:ball: :ball: :ball:
I've seen Bennet all season at the x except against Shels and Derry and HEs been Clumsy and not evry good. I've heard aginst Shels he was ay fault for 1 of the goals in the cup. He was lucky against UCD for his rugby tackle and he deserved his sending off against RoversQuote:
Originally posted by Colm
You're obviously either not very good at judging the performances of a footballer or you haven't seen Benno play much this season?
Hmmmm, lets see now. did benno, or did Benno not get player of the month for City recently? Was he or was he not involved in one of the meanest defences in the eL?
Do u feel confidant in Dereks ability to track back, make the clean tackle and play a good ball out of defence?
Benno IN!
i'VE HEARD k mURRAY HIS STABLE AT DEFENCE LATELY
ccfcman wrote about Bennett
[FONT=arial]"he's a big donkey and when he turns hes akin to a small oil tanker"[/FONT]
This I assume is as opposed to Coughlan who turns like a big oil tanker:D :D :D
congratulations. if I knew who you were I'd shake your hand. Your last post has just confirmed you are a total moron. :rolleyes:Quote:
Originally posted by ccfcman
bennett is rubbish give me a break,just cuz dolan luvs him doesnt mean i will.ffs his"good"performances r so few,hes a big donkey and when he turns its akin to a small oil tanker
:ball: :ball: :ball:
Thats not nice calling him a moron.You should at least call him something he could understand.
ccfcman-you are a big stupid head.:rolleyes: