I was at the Athlone Monaghan match Saturday and thought the programme was v.poor.I think Galway have the best of what i have seen.Whats your opinion?
Printable View
I was at the Athlone Monaghan match Saturday and thought the programme was v.poor.I think Galway have the best of what i have seen.Whats your opinion?
Galway's had very little content, as I recall.
Dundalk`s programme this year has been getting very good reviews, its a magazine style, a lot of colour and some excellent features, best I`ve ever seen from the club and def in the top 5 that has been produced of late through the league,
drogs had a good programme 2 years ago, not sure if they have same format now.
I've seen every programme in the Premier this season (bar Cork) but none of them come close to Dundalk- by far the best in the league.
Drogs apparently have a ten man programme committee, although I don't know what they do, because there was nothing in their programme.
For what it's worth this season, in my opinion -
Bohs - don't remember
Bray - not a huge amount in it
Cork - wasn't down there
Derry - good, although I always get the feeling that it's largely a cut and paste job from the internet
Drogheda - little enough in it
Dundalk - very good publication; not too keen on the awkward size, but if that's all I can complain about...!
Galway - not much in it, as I recall.
Rovers - very good as per usual
Sligo - don't remember it
Pat's - one of the better ones I think
Waterford - very little in it
UCD - biased obviously 'cos I write for it, but it's got more content than most others, so it's a case really as to whether you feel glossy pages are a necessity.
In general though, don't think programmes in the league are particularly good quality, to be honest.
Cork have the best programme.
No other Club really comes close to it tbh,maybe Rovers.
Best of the rest would be...Rovers,UTD,Bohs and Derry IMO.
I think our programme is a good read. Better than most ive read this season. Monaghans must be the worst Ive seen in a long time. Athlones was poor enough too.
Dundalks is a good programme, similar to our own imo.
Cant remember a whole lot about the rest ive seen this season.
I don't buy away programmes any more due to vast majority being rubbish. Broke that habit in the last couple of years at Drogs only to see they using threads from the internet as filler. I hope it has improved since then. :o
The Galway programme is colourful, very slick and well put together but a little short on articles IMO.
First Division
Finn Harps - Probably only pipped by Dundalk's. Has always been of good quality in terms of production and content since I started going to Finn Park. Along with Dundalk, one Club that actually goes looking for articles from the opposing club.
Cobh Ramblers - Has the basics covered, but nothing extra special about it. Not a bad use of photos in it though. Layout is like their website, a bit all over the place.
Dundalk FC - Definitely the best. Nice design, articles on the opposition, good stuff on their history, interviews with players, good stats and good use of photos. Only thing it is lacking is colour.
Limerick 37/FC - Always found it poor enough in recent seasons, including our first visit this season. Don't have a copy from our second visit so it may have improved.
Shelbourne - Again only have one sample from Shels. Not too bad with some interviews, articles and home and away pen-pics. Anything lacking in the content is covered up the good production of it.
Kildare County - Never really been impressed with Kildare's. Kind of like Cobh's, covers the basics but very little special about it.
Monaghan United - Lot of little snippets of club news, like how the Under-12's got on last week and stuff like that, but have never seen any good articles with players etc in it.
Athlone Town - The less said about it the better.
Wexford Youths - The most expensive in the League at 4? Full A4 size and in full colour. Did improve from our first visit to our second visit this season. Should improve more with time.
Kilkenny City - See Athlone Town.
These are just my own feelings as a former programme editor on what I believe makes a good programme.
The drogs programme has improved a very small bit since last season (well it couldnt get any worse) but still miles behind the one from a couple of years ago!Quote:
Originally Posted by robbiesdrogs
Dundalk have a very good one this season - have seen very few others this season tbh, as ive been too tight to buy them - even the drogs home ones :o
You've not seen Kilkenny's then?Quote:
Originally Posted by Sam_Heggy
I think Salthill charged E2 for eight pages, including four ads, for our Cup game.
Quote:
Originally Posted by longfordjames
Yes but you didnt have to pay for it as there was a problem with the print run and count yourself lucky it is usually full of ads with no content.
Fair comments atfconline, but must say this season I have not been asked for anything by Dundalk and alot of the stuff in their programmes for us seems to enjoy taking petty swipes and they have come close on the liable laws in one programme of theirs I saw. It is still prob the best in the 1st division tho.
Wexford Youths is an excellent product too and especailly when you consider this is their first season.
Sam, Kilkenny's is the worst by a mile. €3 for a team sheet and a few ads and they even had the wrong team down for us (they had listed Wexford Youths players!).
I was shocked at how bad the Athlone one was on Saturday having always had the pleasure of enjoying atfconline's efforts. From one of the best programmes in the league to one of the worst in the same season is kinda shocking.
Quote:
Originally Posted by oriel
Promote that club!Quote:
Originally Posted by DmanDmythDledge
Looks like Maxi was right all along :(Quote:
Originally Posted by pineapple stu
Bray had a double programme(Cork game the previous Friday) for our recent trip to the Carlisle Ground. And the balls to charge 3 euro for it. Sad state of affairs. Rising costs mentioned as a reason.
I don't usually buy away programmes but I have seen Longford's one and I think it's terrible. Mostly adverts. Without sounding biased but our one is very good and has improved in the last few seasons. Lots of interesting articles along with the regular columns.
:DQuote:
Originally Posted by Magicme
You should have seen what they were going to print from a Philly Hughes interview!
Cork City's is far and away the best.
Rovers Second
Dundalk's is the best in the first division for me closely followed by Harps. Nobody else is close with Cobh or maybe Shels probably best of the rest. I don't like the size of the Dundalk issue though.
Hard to comment on the premier division as I see very few league games and can only judge on Setanta and European programmes.
Rovers is by far the best, although at €4 its not great value for money.
Cork's isn't a patch on preious years.
Some rubbish efforts out there. Can't comment on any frst division...
What's great value???Quote:
Originally Posted by Dodge
Is €2 for 8 pages of ads great value?
Is €1 for a messy photo-copy great value?
Good quality printing ain't cheap.
Cork has a great programme
Shels Dont seem to talk about anything outside Dublin
Dundalk another great programme
Kilkenny lets all start laughing
Can only really speak for the First Division as I've only seen one Premier Division programme this season.
Dundalk the best by a mile. Harps a clear second. Shels was okay and easily finish third, as the other seven would really be better off not even bothering.
agree with sligoman on that. gas thing is up to two years ago we had a excellent match program. but this is what happens when there is cutbacks im afraid!Quote:
Originally Posted by sligoman
Unfortunately its part of the club licensing.:oQuote:
Originally Posted by The Lilywhites
Best in the First Division I've seen to date has been the Finn Harps and Wexford youths programmes. Hopefully going to Dundalk next week so will see what thats like.
I always thought Corks programme in the Premier was a good read but haven't been down there this season. Have Shamrock rovers, bohs, Bray and St. Pats programmes for this season and all have nice articles and useful bits of info. Premier programmes that I've got this season are a lot better than what I have for the first division.
Fantastic souvenier alright, but overall the drogs programme has been s*** this season!! As i said earlier, as much as it kills me to say it the craptown programme could well be the best programme in the premier and first divisionQuote:
Originally Posted by robbiesdrogs
This is very true. I've often seen UCD's programme criticised for produced on normal printing paper. There's a trade-off here - glossy or cheap.Quote:
Originally Posted by khoop
What do people prefer? Would you happily pay €4 for a glossy programme, or would you sooner the same content on non-glossy paper for €2?
From what I have seen, Rovers have a good programme, as have Cork, and reckon they are the top 2
corks was good enough i think.
never get programmes really though. but corks was best that i got this year, of about 2 or 3 only