What are your views on the progress of the EL new clubs Wexford Youths and Limerick37?
Printable View
What are your views on the progress of the EL new clubs Wexford Youths and Limerick37?
Personally i think the whole idea of Wexford Youths is a disaster. It's one man's club and when the one man is fed up then it's club over, i just don't agree with that all.
Limerick 37 on the other hand i think have made a very good impression and I like the idea behind them.
I don't really consider L37 a new club though. It's just like a take over of an existing club. Do L37 claim the honours of previous senior clubs from Limerick?
http://www.limerick37fc.ie/history.html
It looks like they do. This article doesn't even refer to L37...
Its a problem that Limerick and Waterford teams have. The current Waterford United are a separate club completely than thegreat waterford side of the 60s but no one in Waterford thinks that, and their list of honours contain all those trophies.Quote:
Originally Posted by holidaysong
There are good arguments for and against claiming the honours of previous clubs though. AFC Wimbledon for example, who would deny them the right to claim the honours of the original crazy gang though they are in reality a seperate club? I don't mind Limerick and Waterford using this right as there was no overlap in clubs from these places existing in the league unlike teams from Cork for example.
You're right we don't see it as a problem Dodge, though I suppose I would say that. :D When Waterford FC changed to Waterford United it was just a name change (for various reasons, but presumably substantially for financial benefit), the behind-the-scenes people and playing staff, and all the trappings of the old club went with the new name. There's no question that it wasn't the same club.
Limerick 37 seem to have made more radical changes, mainly in order to rid themselves of one individual it seems like, but have a good case for carrying forward past honours too IMO, as there wasn't any time between clubs when there was no senior football in the city, and especially as there was a fairly hefty transfer of personnel from one entity to the other, which is the most important thing for me.
At its core a club is really just the people involved after all.
Most of the clubs have folded due to infighting. Look at clubs like Pats or Rovers that have multiple owners, holding companies but the club remained the same.Quote:
Originally Posted by stann
Just think its a bit cheeky for a club to fold, then set up a new one and take the old one's history and acheivements.
Cheeky in a bad way or cheeky in a lovable scamp way? ;) :DQuote:
Originally Posted by Dodge
Depends on my humour, or more specifically whther they've beaten Pats the previous week :)
South East FC aiming for Eircom league spot
In August this year the South East Academy will take another leap forward, as part of their continued development of elite players in the south east region, when their recently formed club ‘South East FC’ will affiliate to the LFA and FAI through the Carlow and District Football League. South East FC will then compete in the FAI Youth Challenge Cup, FAI u17 Challenge Cup, LFA Youths Cup and will contest challenge games regularly with some of the leading teams in the country throughout the season. The club intend to be based at Bunclody FC, which is also the FAI Regional Development Centre. Bunclody FC have recently installed International class facilities, including three International class grass pitches, an indoor 3G Astro Turf pitch and superb clubhouse facilities on its 16 acre site and are presently installing a full-size outdoor 3G Astro Turf pitch with flood lights.
South East FC see the coming season as a stepping stone to League of Ireland football, as they hope to compete in the New Under 20 Division of the Eircom League which is due to start in 2008. John Coughlan, Vice-President of the Leinster Football Association and Secretary of the Carlow and District Football League said ”We are delighted to be working with South East FC. It will provide a great opportunity for elite players in the south east to compete at a high level without having to travel long distances, as has been the case in the past. It will also enable these players to receive coaching to an International standard and afford them a real opportunity to play in the Eircom League in 2008”.
Preparations to take the club forward into the Eircom League are already well under way, with management structures and highly qualified coaching staff in place including Pat Purcell who is head coach with the FAI emerging Talent Programme in Carlow and currently working on his UEFA ‘B’ Coaching Licence. Garry Coady holds a UEFA ‘B’ Licence and is an FAI Tutor and FAI regional squad coach while Dutch native Robbert Wagemans is an FAI emerging talent programme coach who holds a Semi-Pro Coaching Licence from the Dutch Football Federation. Seamus Glover who recently completed his UEFA ‘A’ Licence also holds a UEFA ‘B’ Goalkeeping Licence.
Over the last few years, the South East Academy has built up a network of contacts with professional clubs in the UK and Europe. South East FC will maintain these contacts and continue to travel regularly to these clubs in order to provide an opportunity for players to experience different styles of play and coaching methods. During the coming season they will play up to 30 games and will have over 60 coaching sessions.
Pre-season training is now under way in preparation for one of Europe's premier tournaments, the Foyle Cup, in Derry during July and the prestigious Galway Umbro Cup in August. South East FC are currently assembling an impressive squad of players from Carlow, Kilkenny, Kildare & Wexford, with all having played at representative level while the majority have also played in the DDSL Premier division. They currently have a small numbers of places available and are looking for elite players born in 1990 who are serious about playing soccer. Places are limited so if you are interested or would like further information,
I dont think AFC Wimbeldon is able to claim the honours as the original crazy gang wimbeldon has just changed its name to MK Dons.Quote:
Originally Posted by holidaysong
I dont mind Limerick & Waterford claiming the previous honours tbh. Personally i think clubs like Harps, Derry, Rovers, etc should all be proud of the fact they have kept their clubs afloat from day 1.
I dont think wallace would bale on youths tbh. He seems committed and maybe the idea is t form a joint ownership/committee in the years ahead, that if he did leave the club wouldn suffer.Quote:
Originally Posted by teckno
Hey TopMan, stop posting the same press blurb everytime. Honestly hope you don't get into the league because of you". And yes I am that petty
*and also because there are already clubs in waterford, Wexford and Kilkenny
Quote:
Originally Posted by holidaysong
Ya most of our fans dont see Limerick37 as a new club either!! Same fans, majority of the same players, just different name!! The whole set-up is way more professinal though and is attracting new fans!! Ya they kind of do ya!! Fans still still claim we won the League in 1960... etc...and that was Limerick United as far as i know, was even before Limerick F.C!!
Quote:
Originally Posted by Topman
Yawn........ :mad:
Wexford Youths are an interesting and ambitious addition to the league and seem likely to contribute in the coming years. They will develop good facilities and when they ditch amateurism will probably be a decent D1 club at least. They're getting a harsh baptism this year- but the roots appear to be solid enough.
When I was at Jackman earlier this year I have to say I was impressed by L37. There was an air of progression and ambition around the place that replaced the air of despair that seemed to surround Limerick on previous visits. They're definitely a club going in the right direction and the idea of being closely integrated with local football is a good one if you can make it work and avoid too much infighting.
Havent seen L37 but was really impressed with Wexford Youths both times I have seen them against Shels. On Friday they got the ball down tried to hold possesion and play through us rather then long balls and just depending on strength like some of the other clubs in the league. I think they can only be positive for the league.
Apparently the MK Dons chairman has handed over the FA Cup (replica I assume) & all other non & lower league trpohies that the original Wimbledon won to AFC WimbledonQuote:
Originally Posted by Sam_Heggy
:eek: thats shockin.......Quote:
Originally Posted by endabob1
Anyways back to LOI :p whos next for the chop?
What was done to Wimbledon FC was an absolute disgrace. Some dodgy Norwegians came in and bought a modest club (but with a proud history) on the cheap, in the hope that they could then move it somewhere where they might make more money, regardless of the feelings of the fans.Quote:
Originally Posted by Sam_Heggy
At one stage, they even wanted to move it to, ahem, Dublin - thereby also ****ing off fans of local Dublin clubs, into the bargain.
When that fell through and they began to lose money, they passed control to a "businessman" called Pete Winkelman, who declared that the club wasn't viable in Wimbledon (where it had managed somehow for 100 years) and would have to move.
As "proof" of its unviability, he pointed to the growing losses being incurred, (though Wimbledon fans preferred to point to the blatant asset-stripping which went on as the club was run into the ground).
Eventually, he told the FA/Football League that Wimbledon HAD to move (or go bust), the only conceivable site was Milton Keynes (over 70 miles away) and he said he'd sue the authorities if they dared to enforce their own rules which forbid League membership being transferred out of their natural catchment area and/or into the catchment area of neighbouring clubs (e.g. Luton, Northampton, Peterboro etc).
Of course, it was mere coincidence that Tesco wanted planning permission to build a bloody great Hypermarket on a site outside Milton Keynes. And that the local Council told them they wouldn't get Planning Permission (the town already had an ASDA Hypermarket nearby) UNLESS they could demonstrate they could bring some additional amenity to the town. At which point, Tesco proposed building a big sports stadium on the site. To which the Council said "OK, but only if you've got a professional sports team as Tenant".
Which entirely coincidentally caused Winkleman to raise his hand, crying "Look at me, look at me - I've got a football team you can have..."
Anyhow, anyone's who's interested can read more about it here:
http://wimbledon.rivals.net/default....2&stid=8271036
PS - As EndaBob correctly pointed out, the Franchise were finally required to hand back the trophies they had "acquired" - not that they ever cared anything for the history behind them, or the people who won them. :mad:
Wexford Youths are a great addition in my opinion. There's something very exciting and pure about taking a bunch of mostly inexperienced players from one county and taking on the established clubs. We haven't lost 45% of the games - 8 out of 18 - and will soon be a force to be reckoned with when 1 goal defeats turn into draws or wins. Our 21s have 1 win and 2 draws out of 3 to date against Waterford, Kerry and Kilkenny with a very young team on average. In fairness Limerick are doing very well and good luck to them in the future - like the setup and enthusiasm at their venue but ground needs improvement.
Quote:
Originally Posted by new blue
Im not be smart or anything, but whats a nice, fancy ground without passion and atmosphere? Jackman Park is being developed in the near future!! I was impressed with everything when I was down in Wexford for the Cup Replay (expect the weather), and the fans tried to get an atmosphere going and they are probably the friendlist fans in the LOL imo!! So fair play to them and it will take time but I think Wexfords Youth will be a big club in a few years!! The Set-up there has potential and if fans + players keep up the hard work ye will go far, both on and off the pitch!
They are - following agreement last year between AFC, Franchise FC, and the FA.Quote:
Originally Posted by Sam_Heggy
MK Dons have given the replica of the FA Cup - which all winners get to keep - back to the Merton Borough Council (where Wimbledon is located).
MK Dons are not the original Wimbledon. No more than Dublin City were the original Wexford Youths.
Sam Hamman was the person supremely at fault here - not the Norwegians.Quote:
Originally Posted by EalingGreen
He got them all giddy about the prospect of moivng the club and persuaded them to buy into it. But without him, they wouldn't have been on the scene.
He was the root cause of the events that unfolded at Wimbledon FC. And then he got welcomed into Cardiff with open arms, where he implemented changes like putting the Welsh flag on their jersey, trying to change their home kit to Welsh red etc.....