Printable View
I know we have been getting hassle from the fai over this and have managed to stamp it out at home amongst our fans, but a few young fellas started a few up in ucd and we are getting hassle over this also but with clubs having videos on there own clubsites with fans basically giving a full flare display, what I am really asking is if the fai are bothering other clubs about this?
I think under controlled conditions there should be no hassle with it. I.E. if certain groups inside grounds make arrangements to use them, have buckets on hand for quenching etc.
Pats were allowed used them last friday for the minutes applause.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dD3cpvIe5Jo
kdjac
Were they allowed by the fai or was it by the club? Is there a health and safety issue, as it is a rule of the licensing, buckets or not they are not allowed.
Do some clubs allow it with buckets ?
GUFC released an official statement on the use of flares but no flares had been let off by home fans this year.:confused:
gufct has a bee in his bonnet about flares.
They're mainly just used by away fans-i don't see the harm in them.
Flares are great. All this health and safety bull is an attempt to ruin the atmosphere at games. Name an incident where someone was hurt by a Flare at a football ground under controlled conditions. A couple of years back I remember us getting fined for using flares at a game while shortly after on the UEFA website there was a picture of Liverpool fans using flares at a European match as an example of atmosphere.
we've had 2 this year, in Longford and Galway...
Is there any fai contact at all about this?
I agree flares a great but I only see my club being hammered it cant be one rule for 1 and another for another
and we fined for both as well afaik.Quote:
Originally Posted by Red&White Rover
While the FAI rule banning the rule of flares is pointless, stewards enforcing
that rule are only doing their (in many cases voluntary, and thankless) job.
The major problem is the FAI observers. An old school Hylandesque blazer "won't see" flares, while another observer will report the club or its supporters. The arbritrary fines then seem very unfair to supporters.
Supervised use of flares should be allowed, after consultation with the stewards of the home club. A supporters group could lobby the FAI on this issue.
I don't give a f**k what any of you think, trousers from the seventies have no place in Irish football.
Flares in confident areas are very dangerous especially when kids are waving them around. Some kids had them in the middle of City fans for Pats v City in the Setanta Cup & could feel the heat down the back of my neck. IF they had dropped one would burn anything & anyone they touched.
I agree they good for atmosphere but poor show if can't create atmosphere without them.
I think clubs could be liable legally for any accident as the FAI would claim they banned them & club had not policed correctly.
ndeNot by the FAI they weren't. In fact some bitch of a Garda confiscated two flares offs a Bohs fan despite the fact the situation was explained to her regards the tribute display for wws. Miserable ****.Quote:
Originally Posted by kdjaC
Its amazing how the guards hassle real supporters yet when there's real hassle in a ground, i.e. two sets of "schooligans" ****ing bottles etc. at eachother, they run and hide.
IMO if a club has a procedure in place for the safe use of flares at games (such as what we had at Bohs a few years ago until the FAI over-ruled us) then the said clubs should be given special dispensation to use them. But the FAI seem intent of following the UK example of sterile, boring, atmosphereless all-seater stadiums. If they bothered to look to the continent rather than England and Scotland, they'd soon realise how much more enjoyable a game's atmosphere can be.
The clubs should be campaigning on supporters' behalf on this issue.
a flare is in sense a firework and if they are set off amomgst a group of people then it is not under controlled conditions. i hate to see them inside any grounds in el mainly due to the case of an accident waiting to happenQuote:
Originally Posted by BohsPartisan
sorry pd. totally against them for the potential of a serious accidentQuote:
Originally Posted by Patrick Dunne
Has anyone actually been injured by a flare in an EL ground recently?
Where could you buy a flare? Its for an unrelated topic but I'm curious?
Thats not fair, they make my legs look longer so I will continue the fight for Flares at Football.Quote:
Originally Posted by Galway Harps
Theres a shop in Dun Laoighre does sailing supplies sells them.
They've been used at football accross the world for years. Name a tme there was an accident. Also what we are talking about here is their use in a controlled area with buckets to put them out in.Quote:
Originally Posted by scotsbeer
There was two people taken to hospital at a waterford game last year one a six year old boy, think it was the last game of the year but im not too sureQuote:
Originally Posted by Saint MacDara
Here's a few examples from a uefa.com search
The problem with flares is the potential for causing serious harm. It just takes one eejit with a few bevvies on board to let one loose in a tight crowd and you're in trouble.
Unfortunately, UEFA can't go round trying to legislate for every exceptional circumstance. I'm not sure if there is leeway at all - in terms of 'controlled conditions' - but you'd like to think that there's always scope for common sense out there. Maybe I'm being unrealistic though.
Yeah but were not asking to throw flares or bring Rocket Launchers into grounds.
FAI normally fine Pats €250 per flare
Without sand buckets to extinguish them in, they can explode if a mucksavage country bumpkin steward insists on it being put out on concrete or asphalt rather than being left to burn out.Quote:
Originally Posted by Saint MacDara
And yes, it did hurt. :D
The FAI are fining clubs week in and week out for this.Sligo and Pats were fined for letting off flares in Galway one for Sligo and Seven for Pats and 4 people were ejected from the games.
This league is cash strapped enough without fans costing their club fines of up to €2000 euro for lighting flares. Yes they are dangerous in a confined space ive had 2 jerseys destroyed by them and have seen numerous others have their clothes destroyed or hair burned when some muppet lets off a flare behind them.
I have suffered personal abuse from our own fans in Terryland over our regulations in relation to flares but they are the ones as laid down by the FAI who now control our league.
Should a club be fined for there fans setting them off at away grounds, how is the club supposed to police that?
Well we actually do Searches in Terryland on the way in at both entrances for Home and Away Fans but flares are so easily concealed that a full body search is the only way around it.
By fining the clubs who continually do it ie: St. Pats. it will eventually lead to the club banning the perpetrators from their games.
Rovers and Athlone got huge finesafter last years cup game and both clubs have cutrailed the use of flares since. Its not the clubs who introduced the regulations but its part of the participation agreements we all signed up for so every club should enforce the rules.
sorry but there is far to much potential danger involved in using them and to provide buckets would be to condone there use., i also think that some of the people who would use these would not be the most safety consious people in the first place
The reason that flares are banned is simple. They're illegal to use except for in an emergency.
The reason the cops couldn't sanction the Pats/Bohs fans to light flares during the tribute to wws was because they can't sanction something that's illegal.
We just lit them anyway and the stewards didn't hassle anybody given the circumstances.
Flares: If you can't stand the heat, get off of the terraces!!
maybe if the FAI was to provide people to read the instructions on the side of the flares to the users it may make them more safe
Quote:
Originally Posted by LukeO
completley agree with you:)
flares available on http://www.tifo.it
They are localized chemical fire and extremely dangerous!
Sooner or later someone will get badly burned by them, especially those cheap ones tifo.it sell as opposed to be proper more expensive ones sold in the sailing shops
;-)
blind eyes being turned some weeks by some FAI inspectors is a joke. either have a complete ban or do them safely on the edge of the pitch
bhs
if only the people using them could get burned then id support them
[QUOTE=gerrycarr;667775.it will be a while before you will see one let off bye a rovers fan[/QUOTE]
except if he.s at sea
Pats are allowed to use flares because Richmond Park officially falls under maritime jurisdiction due to the river. Old Dublin Corporation bye-law apparently.
But does their not have to be a genuine emergency?:confused:Quote:
Originally Posted by Jerry The Saint
There's always the chance that someone fishing the Camac might catch a passing Sligo fan with their hook so it's as well to have the flares on hand.Quote:
Originally Posted by sligoman
It seems the general trend here is for the anti-flares people to be the ones who don't have much call to use them. Sour grapes is all it is. As for people are in favour of their use being less safety conscious thats rubbish. I'm very safety conscious, however I'm also very atmosphere conscious and what gets people coming back to games, far more than the football is the atmosphere. That was certainly what hooked me. Most of us here in favour of flares want to see them used safely with propper safety procedures in place for their use. Yes mis-use should carry fines for clubs and bans for fans involved but their correct use should be applauded. To quote charliesboots
Quote:
Originally Posted by charliesboots
Ah will you go on out of that, Ive let off many a flare with nothing but the intention of creating colour and atmosphere or part of a display. Like I'm sure everyone else here who's used flares, I never used them in a dangerous manner or threw it or anything. Since we've been in the first division we've used a few and havn't been hasseled so far, but since the club are getting fined, with poor finances already, we've cut back latley. By the way, some places flares arn't even illegal to bring into a ground, France for example. And to those saying they are dangerous to those around, the most risk is with the person who lets it off.Quote:
Originally Posted by passerrby
joey im not saying all fans are ******* but ive met some "fans" around the crountry who would gladly use flares as a weapon if the opprtunity arose. and for a club to allow them could crucify them with compo claims