Printable View
I think we all should start bombarding RTE for their no show last week at both semi finals and instead showing some game in Edinburgh between some team who wears the same shirts as shams and some other team.
sportsonline@rte.ie
If the get enough, you never know what may happen.
I think they stopped replaying to eL letters/emails or maybe its just ones from one...
:eek:
Can't say I agree with the deliberate vilification of our Scottish friends. After all, part of loving soccer is loving it OUTSIDE of your own country. I freely admit I sat down to watch Celtic v Rangers, even though it was pitifully short of quality. I also must express my EXTREME anger, frustration etc,etc that the Cup semis were not televised. In a word....ludicrous.
Murphy Out Now!!!
I think rte have my email address blocked cos of the amount of emails I´ve sent them about their "coverage" of the eL!!! They think we´re scum anyway, the usual reply is along the "how dare you criticise me peasant" line. Public Service Broadcaster/National Broadcaster me @rse. They´re beneath contempt that lot
RTE summed up to a T(!), isn't it? Refusing feedback from customers is a sure sign of a company on its last legs, or one that hasn't got a leg to stand on. National broadcaster? Self-styled bull**** I say.
Murphy Out Now!!!
I've been asking for ages does anyone have these, we could compare them to rugby/basketball on RTE/TG4 and see if we can have a real go at them.
I think the sunday sport show at 7.30 on RTE1 last year got close to 200k on occassions. I think the highest rating live mnatch was one of those 3 cup games (2 replays?) between Pats & Shel$ in the mid 90's at around 250k.
For what is worth i notice the Premiership on Net2 is only getting 160-170k this year.
Yeah, the viewing figures have never justified the outlay for that at all.Quote:
Originally posted by pete
For what is worth i notice the Premiership on Net2 is only getting 160-170k this year.
The silence by lack of reply is deafening. I shall be sending the same email to them again and again until the fools acknowledge it, and I ask all ya'll to do likewise.
Maybe people be better off checking out tv3's new eL show & posting or mailing their comments (good or bad) to them.
I emailed them and told them I was boycotting their sh!tty little station and explaining to them that they are neglecting their public service obligations, then I might have got a bit abusive!;)Quote:
Originally posted by GWA
The silence by lack of reply is deafening. I shall be sending the same email to them again and again until the fools acknowledge it, and I ask all ya'll to do likewise.
Anyway, I got a reply from some "postmaster" at RTE saying they will not accept correspondance of that nature and that they wont forward my email to the relevant department. I sent them another more toned down email asking them to explain their position but they did not reply.
As far as im concerned this attitude is an absolute disgrace and from my experience they are one of the few media outlets that do not respond to feedback, I suppose they know that no matter how few viewers they have the government will allways bail them out.
:mad: :mad: :mad:
Nobody let alone RTE will ever respond to abusive letters. You better off asking questions you know they don't want to answer while making your points at the same time.Quote:
Originally posted by COLM
I emailed them and told them I was boycotting their sh!tty little station and explaining to them that they are neglecting their public service obligations, then I might have got a bit abusive!;)
Anyway, I got a reply from some "postmaster" at RTE saying they will not accept correspondance of that nature and that they wont forward my email to the relevant department.
If RTE really getting to you have a look at their web site & theres info on how to make a complaint there to the RTE Authority - i think it says something alone the lines that they have to reply within so many days etc etc...
Yeah but the thing is that I didnt really get that abusive, I made a number of valid points and posed a number of questions regarding any future coverage of Irish football, I'd say what really got to them is the fact that I said I was boycotting their staion and advising everyone I know to do likewise.
I just think its outrageous that they replyed saying that they wont accept it yet we have to accept all the crap that they dish out.
sorry but youve got to read my e-mail from the bottom up. it was about their coverage of the uefa cup matchs. they dont answer me now.
it says on your web site that if you have any enquiries to e-mail your organisation. i have,yet i still have not had a reply. i am disappointed that you never bothered replying to my enquiry. i do have a tv licence. i tried listening to the match on the radio but there seemed to be some sort of religious ceremony on.
----- Original Message -----
From: Eoin Hurley
To: rte:soccer
Sent: Thursday, August 15, 2002 3:26 PM
Subject: Fw: what time
ive tried ringing as well. i got through to the switchboard, they put me through to the sports Department but no one answered my call. will you please answer my question?
----- Original Message -----
From: Eoin Hurley
To: rte:soccer
Sent: Thursday, August 15, 2002 2:04 PM
Subject: Fw: what time
i sent this earlier but i got no reply!
----- Original Message -----
From: Eoin Hurley
To: rte:soccer
Sent: Thursday, August 15, 2002 10:22 AM
Subject: what time
what time are the uefa cup matchs been shown on tv tonight? there was no mention of the match last night on the magazine i had got in its tv section. lets hope the boys can do us proud tonight! my little brother is a rovers fan and has been given permission to stay up late tonight to watch the match!
EOIN
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dear Mr Hurley,
We in the RTE Interactive department apologise for not
getting back to you sooner than now. Your related
question is with the RTE Sport's Department, which is a
different department to the Interactive department. You
made the right decision by phoning and asking for the
Sport's Department. If you have any questions in the
future regarding sports programme I would advice you to
ring the Sport's Department.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The email i replied to was on the sports section of the website and when i rang rte and the swirchboard put me through to the sports deptarment it rang for about 10 mins with no one answering until i put the phne down.
i know i really shouldnt put up their reply but i do pay for their service and this is the treatment recieved!
In my experience, RTE usually consider any form of criticism as "abuse." I remember emailing them before about something in which the worst words I used were "unaccpetable" and "disgraceful" in reference to their coverage and I was told I was being abusive. I´ll be onto them tonight :)Quote:
Originally posted by pete
Nobody let alone RTE will ever respond to abusive letters.
I went for the "very serious topped off with sarcasm aproach"
Interesting to see what they say to that :DQuote:
Dear Sir/Madam,
Although I am currently spending a number of months in Spain, I continue to take a keen interest in all things Irish, particularly sport. I regularly ask relatives to video programmes which may be of interest to me- such as matches. I had been keenly looking forward to receiving a tape of one (or both) of the recent FAI Cup semi-finals, either by post or on my next visit home. However, I was informed that RTE had decided not to screen either, instead choosing to spend tax-payers money on a game of much lesser importance in another country- i.e. Glasgow Rangers against Glasgow Celtic. While as a football fan, I enjoy watching all matches, particularly derby games renowned for their passion, such as the Scottish one screened by RTE, I can´t help feeling that it was an abuse of the money received by RTE in licence fees to ignore the second most important matches in the most important competition in Irish football. Bohs versus Shamrock Rovers is a derby known to many true football fans the world over as an intense rivalry (albeit on a smaller scale than other countries) which any football fan would relish the chance to watch. I seriously question the point in paying for a Television Licence upon my return when that money appears to designated for fast-tracking to another country at the expense of our own domestic product.
Does RTE intend ignoring Irish football in the future, or does it plan to fulfill it´s role as national broadcaster, even if this comes at the expense of those Scottish people who reside in Ireland?
regards,
Éanna Buckley
they´ve chopped that email address, I just got the email returned :rolleyes:
trying sport@rte.ie
I got a reply from some "postmaster" at RTE saying they will not accept correspondance of that nature and that they wont forward my email to the relevant department.
Postmaster is an account or alias that's required by standards, and it's usually routed to the system administrator. I've never met an RTE sysop, but I have dealt with some of their webops and they're a right bunch of pseudo-intellectual tossers.
That said, if your email was blatantly abusive, I'd've knocked you off the net meself. I've seen some of the sh1te that pours into "feedback" accounts, it can be horrendous.
adam
It wasnt blatantly abusive, maybe abusive was the wrong word for me to use in my earlier post because people seem to be hung up on that now. I didnt use any expletives and didnt really insult anyone, in fact the only things that could have ticked them off is when I called them hypocritical for pretending to care about Irish football as regards the Sky deal etc., and when I said I'd be encouraging people to boycott their coverage of foreign football.Quote:
Originally posted by Vetinari
[B]
That said, if your email was blatantly abusive, I'd've knocked you off the net meself.
If they refuse to accept this kind of feedback they are a disgrace. I really believe they should be privatised and then we'd see how they would survive as a commercial entity.
At this stage, I think im going to take Petes route and offer my feedback to TV3 as after all they have the rights and we seem to be wasting our time with that bunch of Dublin 4 dinosaurs!
It wasnt blatantly abusive
Fair enough, it was probably just the RTE sysops being muppets then. However, you can't blame all of RTE for the behaviour of their sysops, and you can't blame the sports people for not responding when they didn't have anything to respond to. Snail mail is still the best way of lodging a complaint against a legacy organisation like RTE, just like it is with politicians. If that doesn't work, you should write to the newspapers.
adam
Maybe CC RTE into the tv3 mail as well given that people seem to be saying tv3 turned up the sound at the cross when the shed signing "who the **** are RTE..."Quote:
Originally posted by COLM
At this stage, I think im going to take Petes route and offer my feedback to TV3 as after all they have the rights and we seem to be wasting our time with that bunch of Dublin 4 dinosaurs!
;)
you might be onto something there :DQuote:
Originally posted by pete
Maybe CC RTE into the tv3 mail as well given that people seem to be saying tv3 turned up the sound at the cross when the shed signing "who the **** are RTE..."
At the end of last nights show Trev invited people to email them saying "we are always happy to recieve your feedback" and he said that they will read out some of the emails on next weeks show.
still no reply to my mail. think i´ll start sending it to them every day til they reply.
I got a reply, the 3rd time I sent it:
Date: Wed, 23 Oct 2002 09:27:55 +0100
From: complaints@rte.ie
Reply-To: complaints@rte.ie
Subject: Re: Fwd: coverage of domestic football
To: sportonline@rte.ie
You will be aware that the FAI has negotiated a deal
for International Matches with Sky Sports. In these
circumstances you are asking RTE to broadcast
programmes which will receive a low audience and at the same time not commenting on Sky's exclusive contract with the FAI
for games that will attract a large audience. RTE will
be televising the Cup Final. The Irish soccer
authorities have turned their backs on RTE by denying
us access to their most popular games, yet you feel that
RTE should televise their less popular games. Should
you not address your concerns to the FAI.
Yours sincerely
P***** F*****
Public Affairs
RTÉ
He might as well have said he was going to tell his mammy too- completely ignores the complaint, whinges about how mean the FAI are, and then tells me to go talk to them. What a twerp. I replied saying the answers he had given me were unacceptable- lets see what happens now..........
Maybe somebody should point out that as a public service Broadcaster they are obliged to broadcast the Irish sports availible to them. They are receiving a liecence fee so they should not be basing what they show on viewing figures alone.
Also, surely the cant be getting huge audiences for "the premiership" and Celtic games when people can watch them on BBC/ ITV/ Sky etc.
It seems like a case of sour grapes to me.
Big time. And he was so condescending about it too.Quote:
Originally posted by COLM
It seems like a case of sour grapes to me.
Quote:
Originally posted by Éanna
I got a reply, the 3rd time I sent it:
Date: Wed, 23 Oct 2002 09:27:55 +0100
From: complaints@rte.ie
Reply-To: complaints@rte.ie
Subject: Re: Fwd: coverage of domestic football
To: sportonline@rte.ie
You will be aware that the FAI has negotiated a deal
for International Matches with Sky Sports. In these
circumstances you are asking RTE to broadcast
programmes which will receive a low audience and at the same time not commenting on Sky's exclusive contract with the FAI
for games that will attract a large audience. RTE will
be televising the Cup Final. The Irish soccer
authorities have turned their backs on RTE by denying
us access to their most popular games, yet you feel that
RTE should televise their less popular games. Should
you not address your concerns to the FAI.
Yours sincerely
P***** F*****
Public Affairs
RTÉ
Classic RTE :rolleyes:
1. RTE were offered the international rights at a discounted price to Skys but did not take it.
2. RTE bid 1.6m for 4 years of international matches = 200k per match if only 8 home competitive matches or 100k per any game if have 4 home games per year. IRFU got 3m for similar period of games.
3. RTE are broadcasting Celtic highligfhts on sunday afternoons now & i dount they get much viewers.
4. As far as i've noticed so far RTEs Premiership has got at a peak 170k viewers this season & counts 1m (is that correct) a season + costs of studio & pundits.
5. RTE were offered the FAI Cup semi finals but rejected them partially as had Scottish football scheduled already.
Time for an email along the lines of what Public Service Broadcasting is & what a low figure is......
;)
Isn´t it just. Not only do they completely ignore the question, but they tell you what to do as well :mad:Quote:
Originally posted by pete
Classic RTE :rolleyes:
Missed that joke.Quote:
Public Affairs
RTE
:D :rolleyes:
I am upset at your response to my email. I did not
intend to be rude. Indeed I do not think I was rude to
you. The simple truth is that the FAI have some
"pearls" and some "scraps". They've sold off their
pearls to Sky and you think RTE should be grateful to
accept their scraps. The economics of television are
that it is far cheaper for RTE to show Scottish
football where we simply pay a modest licence fee for
Irish rights than it is to send cameras and outside
broadcasting units to domestic football. There isn't a
large viewing audience for domestic soccer. You cannot
blame RTE for that - market forces determine that the
best Irish players play in the UK. I know the League
of Ireland does its best. But the public vote with
their feet and their zappers - and they are not
supporting Irish soccer in sufficient numbers to make
it attractive for RTE to televise their games.
Please don't take offence at what I'm saying. I was a
season ticket holder at Shamrock Rovers during the good
days. Now I couldn't name one player on their team.
P***** F*****
that was their reply when i reminded them that they were a public service broadcaster!
Yer man must have been a taxi driver before- seein as how he supported rovers in "the good old days" :rolleyes: :D
They must have been getting 40,000 a game in those days if all the people who say they were diehard Rovers fans in Milltown and haven't gone to a game since actually were. It's worse than the GPO in 1916!Quote:
Originally posted by Éanna
that was their reply when i reminded them that they were a public service broadcaster!
Yer man must have been a taxi driver before- seein as how he supported rovers in "the good old days" :rolleyes: :D
it´s verging on the unbelievable alrightQuote:
Originally posted by Schumi
They must have been getting 40,000 a game in those days if all the people who say they were diehard Rovers fans in Milltown and haven't gone to a game since actually were. It's worse than the GPO in 1916!
As a matter of interest, as you seem to be getting through to this bloke, any chance that you could ask him for comparitive viewing figures? Live matches, and the Sunday Sport......Quote:
Originally posted by Éanna
that was their reply when i reminded them that they were a public service broadcaster!
I must get on to the FOI department here and see whether a FOI request would get the viewing figures out of them..... We know how much (roughly) they paid, so we could work out the VFM of the investment.....
Probably the most sincere & least childish reply i've possible ever seen from RTE - that guy must only have started work there this week ;)
I can see RTE might get decent viewing figures for the Glasgow derby games (with BBC broadcasting they likely to lose a bit too) but does anyone know if even Glasgow Celtic diehards even watched those highlights of a celtic v non-Rangers team?
I think generally RTE have little chance of licence fee increase in the future anyway unless they start outlining what programmes ares public service & what are pure commercial.
IMO i wouldn't consider the FAI Cup final as PS as it should bring in enough viewers to at least break even. If thats the case theres pretty much zero public service broadcasting of irish football now...
as for FOI,
RTE have now to respond to FOI requests e.g staff salaries/contracts although they could use the act to say that releasing the viewing figures could be against their Commercial interest which is a legliamate reason under the act. You might in that instance have to appeal to the FOI commissioner Kevin Murphy and his descision is final.
Who says civil servants are taking up valuable oxygen :D :D
apologies for **** spelling as I forgot to spellcheck it
I very much doubt it. The footballs crap, there is nothing at stake and from what ive heard RTE's overall presentation of the package is far inferior to what BBC are doing.Quote:
Originally posted by pete
does anyone know if even Glasgow Celtic diehards even watched those highlights of a celtic v non-Rangers team?
Im pretty sure that they would get at least as much viewers for a live el match.
Would be interesting to see what kinda figures TV3 are getting for el weekly and what they will get when they start broadcasting live matches.