Printable View
Given.
Carr, O Brien, Breen, Harte
A Reid, Holland, Robbie Keane, Kilbane
Morrison, Elliot.
Will this line up frighten the Swiss?
Does it frighten you?
Are they all available?
Might use Robbie as a super sub though :ball:
Opps almost forgot the keeper.:o
Make the Swiss roll over with laughter, thats probably the worse back 4 i've ever seen... and the rest of it isnt much either...
Given
Finnan Cunningham Dunne Carr
S.Reid Holland Kavanagh A.Reid
Morrison Keane
Finnan was subbed and I don't think he is as good as last season.
Cunningham is getting on.
O Brien is *probably* a safer bet than Dunne.
Breen has been in good form (Actim top 100).
Harte can score from a free kick.
Holland is a safe holding player.
Kilbane is better on the wing were he can use his energy.
Robbie is decent in midfield and can score from there.
Two tall(ish) player up front.
Might start with O Shea rather than Keane (also more hight and keep Keane frustrated on the bench)
Not sure about Kav now, he may try too hard.
Anyway I just though I would throw some ideas in.
Don't know about the Swiss, but that team bloody terrifies me:eek:Quote:
Originally Posted by tricky_colour
I'd go with - Given, Carr, Dunne, Cunningham(Just)Finnan, S. Reid, Holland, Kavanagh, A.Reid, Elliot, Keane.
Kilbane should lose his place but I doubt kerr has the balls to drop him...
Holland for Kilbane
O'brien to come in for Dunne
Harte for O'shea
Morrison for elliot if Robbie starts doin crappy little flicks and acting the
bo!lox take him straight off for elliot.
S Reid for Duff
Kav stays cos there's no one else to play in the middle..
The middle of the pitch in fact scares the hell out of me.
--------------------Given
--Carr------Cunningham------Doherty------Harte
--S.Reid------Kavanagh-----Kilbane-------A.Reid
------------Keane---------Morrison
Quote:
Originally Posted by sligoman
Doherty! DOHERTY at centre half! Dear God noooooooo!
Dunne, O'Brien and Breen are all ahead of him! I'd even argue that Paul Butler of Leeds is a better centre half (or at least on par).
Doherty has had his chance. He shouldn't be in the squad as a centre half...and definitely not as a striker either.
I'd go with:
-----------------------------Given
-----Carr----------Cunningham------------Dunne-------Kilbane:eek:
----S. Reid-------Holland---------------O'Shea--------A.Reid
---------------Robbie-------------Morrison
Gray Breen - is he Gary's evil twin??Quote:
Originally Posted by ZoolEire
Here's what the team will be:
----------------------Given
Carr----Cunningham------Dunne------Harte
Finnan---Holland-------Kilbane-----A. Reid
---------Keane-----Morrisson
Personally I'd switch Finnan for Steven Reid but the above is what I think Kerr will go with.
We need his height for this game, that's why I picked him;)Quote:
Originally Posted by Kevin77
Well there is Gary Breen in one of the younger teams, so that's two for starters.Quote:
Originally Posted by finlma
Think Kerr will go with the team you have too .. he mentioned Harte yesterday. Maybe O'Brien for Dunne if Dunne is not fit. Personally, I think we're asking for trouble playing Harte .. but hopefully he can score one goal more than all the goals he causes.
------------Given---------
Finnan--Cunningham--Dunne--Harte
S Reid---Holland----Kilbane--A.Reid
-------Keane-----Morrison--------
I reckon this will be the team that starts, Elliott & Kav on the bench
When will the team be announced?
An hour before ko....i think
Doherty??? that's nearly as desparate as Uri Geller
Given
Finnan (much better than Carr now),
Cunningham,
Dunne,
Harte (Shea is rubbish and the deadball might be our best chance of scoring)
S.Reid (pace and workrate)
Kavanagh
Holland (Kilbane too poor in the middle)
A.Reid
Elliott
Morrison
Give Robbie a kick up the arse and he'll have something to prove off the bench.
I'd love to see this:
------------Given---------
Finnan--Cunningham--Dunne--Harte
S Reid-----Kavanagh----A.Reid
------------Keane-------
-------Elliott-----Morrison
But expect to see this:
------------Given---------
Finnan--Cunningham--Dunne--Harte
S Reid---Holland----Kavanagh--A.Reid
-------Keane-----Morrison
Given
Carr Dunne Kenny Harte
S Reid Kilbane Holland A Reid
Keano Clinton
what I think Kerr will pick
God i cant understand why some of you would still have kilbane in there at all, never mind in center mid. Before anyone starts, im one of his biggest fans but he is a total confidence player and MUST be dropped from this game.
It always irritates the hell out of me when I hear these di cks giving Kev abuse about games and years gone by. He was great against France away because he was having the season of his life for everton. He has been our worst player now for 2 games and has to go.
I would also drop Carr who looked nervous and was generally sh ite. O shea-goes without saying, should not have played the last 2 games. Bring in Stephen Reid.
Up front its 2 from 3-Kerrs only tough decision imo. Dunne-I'd still pick him over O brien, only just.
Given
Finnan---------Dunne-----------Cunningham--------Harte
S.Reid---------Kavanagh--------Holland------------A. Reid
Morrisson Keane
With elliott to come on after 45 when robbies done moaning about not getting frees/pennos.
I hope it's
-----------Given--------------
Carr-Cunningham-Dunne-O'Shea
S.Reid-Holland-Kavanagh-A.Reid
--------Elliot----Clinton--------
with Keano to come on after 60/65 mins for Clinto and maybe score.
Although there is a case for Harte for dead ball situations, is he worth the risk defensively? No pace IMHO. And besides, the Reids can both hit a good free kick too... (remember Cameroon in the WC for S.R and France recently for A.R)
Josser ain't the best left back, and seems more comfortable at CB or CM, but now isn't the time to ar$e with those postitions.
Given
Carr Cunningham Dunne Harte
A Reid Kavanagh Holland Kilbane
Morrison Keane
Thats the team Kerr will pick. Personally I'd have Finnan in for Carr, but otherwise the same.
Can't see why everyone is picking Steven Reid.
I think because Andy Reid can go Left Wing and Kilbane is not playing his best this season..
Kerr will not drop Kilbane for a big game like this. Simple as.
is he right tho'?
Surely the young guys on the bench would love to get in there tonight and show a bit of passion...
Although I called for Keano to be dropped and Elliott to stay in the team, in the immediate aftermath of the Cyrus game, I would say BK will favour experience over youthful passion (from the start anyway)......I would probably agree with him on that one..
I think I'd go for
Given,
Finnan, Cunningham, Dunne, Harte
S Reid, Kavanagh, Kilbane, A Reid,
Morrison, Keane.
Looks like he'll play Kilbane on the left though by all accounts. If you're at the game, don't start on him ffs if it's not happening for him. Get behind everybody and keep supporting.
I, for one, would NEVER start on BK (or any Ireland manager) no matter what. I'll be 110% behind the team.....
C'MON IRELAND !
**EDIT** ....wouldn't start giving stick to any player either....it's pointless....we're in this together!!
Fully agree ... if anyone starts giving Kilbane any stick, please give them back stick for not being a proper fan. The lads need our support tonight .. and Kilbane is one of the players who does give his all.Quote:
Originally Posted by drinkfeckarse
I second that motion. For tonight, its vital that we get fully behind every player on the Irish team. It seems to clear that Kilbane is going through one of his many lulls at the moment. The last thing he needs is the yobbo element getting on his case. In whats a must win game, we can't tolerate any negativity like that from 'supporters'.
From my vantage point here in Halifax, Nova Scotia. Can't even get to see the game out here! I'll be roaring encouragement at my computer screen here, for what thats worth.
Jaysus, I'm as nervous as a known, convicted rapist whose just been sent to prison... Well almost :p
Hart is playing left back,O'Shea in midfield with A Reid,kilbane and holland ,Clint and rob up front..What ye think??