Printable View
Would I be right in saying that no fewer than 11 different players have scored for City in the league this season and that we've only failed to score in 3 league games. 2 of which were during our bad start to the season. A result against Rovers on Friday would mean that we've failed to pick up points against a Dublin on just two occasions this season so far.
Gunter Out! :rolleyes:
har har har. true enough- but those of us who want rid of the grumpy one care not for results (god, i'm gettin all shakespearean)! It's a simple dislike of the man and his methods- nothing to do with results @ ALL! Dunphy never said charlton was ineffective, he just said he didn't like his style/methods/lack of both- that's more or less where i stand with gunther.
bye bye liam :D
You're right Éanna. Bring back Mountfield.Quote:
Originally posted by Éanna
bye bye liam :D
Especially for the Rovers game.
We had such success against Rovers under Mountfield!
never said that at all! derek ain't comin back, and i ain't callin for his reinstatement! i just wanna see the grunter get the boot.Quote:
Originally posted by Barry's Tea
Bring back Mountfield.
I wonder how many of us would trade positions with our Bohs fan Barrys Tea above & their "fulltime" squad?
CCFC can't afford a fulltime setup on the pitch (although could at least attempt off the pitch) so better Gunther takes us through a season or two & bring in a professionla manager if thats what evereyone wants then.
IMO foreign managers haven't worked in the eL. Good local fulltime managers is whats needed & I don't see any alternatives to Gunther at the moment. How could you sack him with his league record to date anyway??? :rolleyes:
We've rode our luck in games this season but also been unlucky on other occasions. If Gunther can teach the team to hold onto a lead there may be no stopping us.
DM record v rovers: 1-4 (away) 1-2 (home)
Gunthers record: 2-1 (away) 2-1 (home)
clean sheets on the other hand are much harder to come by these days :DQuote:
Originally posted by Barry's Tea
Goals Can Come From Anywhere
lads, i'm not arguing with gunthers record, or his effectiveness- i just think he's bad for the medium-and-long term future of the club. short term he's fine. the sooner we get a replacement who has experience of professionalism-be he english, irish, indian, brazilian or , god help us, even from dublin :D - the better.
How can yea say he bad for the future of the club, 6 players that played on Sunday were under 21 and 4 are from Cork. If we can keep this group of players together for the next few seasons we'll have some team. Also he hasn't spent a penny since he took charge. Fair enough some fo his decisions are suspect but to wan't him sacked when were joint second is fickle in the extreme.Quote:
Originally posted by Éanna
i just think he's bad for the medium-and-long term future of the club.
The last thing I can be called in relation to gunther is fickle! I've said I never wanted him to have the job from the start, and that will always be the case- like I already said, it's nothing to do with results at all. May I also say, even if he wins us the champions league he won't have my support- it's as simple as that! If I called for his head and then changed my mind over a few results, that would make me as hypocritical and fickle as you can get- and I'm not.Quote:
Originally posted by Sid
Fair enough some fo his decisions are suspect but to wan't him sacked when were joint second is fickle in the extreme.
Well you would have to admit Éanna if he won the champions league, that might sway things just a tad, well for me anyway. For now winning is kinda cool too. There are alot more parties involved for everything else to change aswell. It is not ALL up to Liam off the pitch.
Don't go and score an own goal. Its great that goals can come from anywhere but to score an own goal by sacking murphy is stupid. Cop yourselves on. We're dam lucky to have murphy.
yea i take it all back
Goalside has slow clearly explained to me the error of my ways...thanks goalside :D
:D
isnt it past youre bedtime though goalside
Sorry dad. Going right now :D . What a stupid reply james. :confused:
Don't go accusing anyone else of stupid replies when this is the crap you come out with. I'm not gonna say it again- it's nothing to with results: i just think the guy is bad news. end of story. murphy out. I'm not saying he's a BAD manager, i just thing he's the wrong manager for city.Quote:
Originally posted by goalside
......stupid. Cop yourselves on. We're dam lucky to have murphy.
p.s. face- not even champions league would change me- i don't wanna be a hypocrite.
Just to be clear:Quote:
Originally posted by Éanna
it's nothing to with results.....I'm not saying he's a BAD manager, i just thing he's the wrong manager for city.
p.s. face- not even champions league would change me- i don't wanna be a hypocrite.
1) The results are OK
2) He's not a bad manager
3) A champion's League success would make no difference
4) You just want him out
Did I pick it up wrong?
Gerry
No, you're spot on Gerry. I have my reasons-none of the above- and I've been thru them all before, I'm not dragging it up again and I'm not going to change my mind.Quote:
Originally posted by Gerry Desmond
Just to be clear:
1) The results are OK
2) He's not a bad manager
3) A champion's League success would make no difference
4) You just want him out
Did I pick it up wrong?
Gerry
Imagine the headline - city -champions of curope - sacked by chairman eanna. Not going to change his mind.
Great. with supporters like that who needs rovers fans. you'll be with them on friday no doubt eanna
goalside i PMed you re above. I'm fed up of taking flak for what i think- i'm not shoving anyone else's opinion back at them, nor am i asking them to agree with me- i'm certainly not going on about gunther; until someone started this thread, i hadn't mentioned the guy in quite a while! think what you want to think, that's what i do- but just respect what other people think too. it's only fair and decent.
On the subject of goalscorers, does anyone know much about
Mchugh who plays for Finn Harps. I see he's scored 17 goals
this season, which is no mean feat, even in Div1. Can't see why he hasn't been snapped up yet by Premier clubs.
carlisle moved for him a few weeks back but he said he wasn't leaving! apparently derby countyare showing some interest- big move:eL div1 to england div1; or are they in the premiershi*- I can't remember?! ah well, don't really care anyhoo!
oh yeah and, he played for the eL U-21 side that lost 6-2 to the full ireland team in a 60-min training match before the 2 playoff games. apparently don givens said he has a better chance of making it at international level than some of the strikers who've played u-21 for ireland over the least 2 years. high praise indeed!
Eanna - What does "i PMed you re above" mean? I was just saying in my post that i can't understnad how you could still want the manager out even if he lead his team to the top. Thats all.
it means i sent you a personal message- have a look at it. I've already explained that my opposition to murphy has nothing to do with how well the team is doing- i can't and don't deny that it is doing well.Quote:
Originally posted by goalside
Eanna - What does "i PMed you re above" mean? I was just saying in my post that i can't understnad how you could still want the manager out even if he lead his team to the top. Thats all.
Only seen him once this season when he scored against the Ramblers at St. Colman's Park. He has a really good partnership going with Jonathan Speake and the fans adore him, not surprisingly.Quote:
Originally posted by rebel yell
On the subject of goalscorers, does anyone know much about
Mchugh who plays for Finn Harps. I see he's scored 17 goals
this season, which is no mean feat, even in Div1. Can't see why he hasn't been snapped up yet by Premier clubs.
Who'll get on the score sheet tonight?
That's the big question.
Devine maybe?
Carey deserves a goal.
Bennett wants another goal.
Ollie likes a long range goal.
Deccie needs a goal!
In truth I fancy Coughlan to pop up for one.
Having said that I'd settle for an own-goal if we won 0-1.
This is the big problem with Cork City supporters, especially people who have links to the club. They are happy enough to settle for "OK" results, happy enough to trundle along with a manager that "is not bad"! What a joke!Quote:
Originally posted by Gerry Desmond
Just to be clear:
1) The results are OK
2) He's not a bad manager
Gerry
"Sure we'll get the oul InterToto place again", "Yera the lads deserve another trip to Europe", "Sure as long as we beat the shower from Dublin that's all that matters", "Sure we're only amateur"
There are too many people like this within our club. They make me sick. They can be seen from the top to the bottom of our club and the point Eanna has been trying to make is that Liam Murphy is one of them. Gerry backs up Murphy by saying "1) The results are OK, 2) He's not a bad manager" Sure I suppose it's all we can expect considering we're only amateur.
Michael O'Leary has got to you Gerry. That was his response to every question asked at the recent supporters Club meeting. Why is there not more advertising of games? A few posters even? "Sure we're only amateur"
We're only amateur but the *******s managed to have a fairly 'professional' looking trip to Latvia last year. The rounds of golf at the clubs expense could hardly be described as amateur.
Everything them ****s do is in a professional manner but asked why they don't hang a poster outside Turner's Cross to advertise the next game.. "We're only amateur".
If the people in charge of our club have only dreams of survival I want the priks out. I want people who will make it their business to drag this club off it's arse. I want to see posters, ads on 96fm, a manager who wants his team to train full-time, an assistant manager who doesn't smoke 40 Major, a Chairman who is willing to hang the ****ing poster himself if it means getting a step closer to his dream.
I continue to criticise the Directors (title would suggest some directing required wouldn't it?) but I can't se how all this is Liam Murphys fault.
Murphy is getting the results so whats the problem?
I'm not saying Murphy is the best we could get but why sack him just for the sake of it?
Directors could be removed due to poor performance by a manager but i've never heard of sacking a manager cos of a crap Board! :eek:
Just to be clear, Casegrande:
Those were Éanna's points, NOT mine. You also omitted two of them, btw.
I was merely trying to see if I was picking up his drift correctly.
Apparently I did. Apparently, you didn't read what I was saying.
It seemed bizarre in the extreme to me to suggest a manager could win the CL and still be unsatisfactory...does that NOT seem strange to you? :confused:
Gerry
Imagine the fun we'd have! Coming back into town having won the CL and rubbing it in Éanna's face while he stood there unable to celebrate. I remember something my mother used to say about spite, nose, face and some cutting.Quote:
Originally posted by Gerry Desmond
It seemed bizarre in the extreme to me to suggest a manager could win the CL and still be unsatisfactory...does that NOT seem strange to you? :confused:
Gerry
Eanna used the CL to make a point, some persons have taken him seriously. Cork City will never in our lifetime win the CL. BUT, we should be looking to progress to a point where we can hope to make the group stages.
Gerry and Mr.T - how do we come to a stage where we can hope to qualify for the CL?
The way we get to qualify for the CL is by going on as Liam Murphy is showing us. Winning the eircom League. Winning three qualifying rounds of the CL and Bob's Your Marley, we're there, in the CL group stages.Quote:
Originally posted by Casegrande
Gerry and Mr.T - how do we come to a stage where we can hope to qualify for the CL?
It's not beyond belief.
Don't get me wrong here, Casegrande:Quote:
Originally posted by Casegrande
Eanna used the CL to make a point, some persons have taken him seriously. Cork City will never in our lifetime win the CL. BUT, we should be looking to progress to a point where we can hope to make the group stages.
Gerry and Mr.T - how do we come to a stage where we can hope to qualify for the CL?
In NL terms, Cork constantly underachieves IMO.
3 league titles in half a century says it all.
Cork Hibs: 1 title - underachievement!
Cork Celtic: 1 title - underachievement!
Cork City: 1 title - underachievement!
It may be easy to target current directors etc. You may be right to criticise them, you may be wrong.
However, it is neither my duty nor my desire to defend them on this MB or elsewhere. But I would say this much about them - they ARE the directors of CCFC because at least they got involved. The question to ask, IMO, about EVERY club in the league, is why are the directors the only people involved with their clubs?
I don't have any simple solutions other than the club obviously needs more people involved, needs positive support from fans, the general public and especially the business community of the city.
I'd love to be a director, for instance, but I ain't got the bobs. It's a problem with the way clubs are set up. Have money and you can get in. Brains are not necessarily required. Quite often people with a passion for their club and a vision for its future are excluded simply because they are in a different financial situation to what is deemed to be acceptable. It always struck me as an apalling waste of resources and talent...Imagine if it were only possible to become a footballer if you had sufficient moolah to get you in.
Barcelona is a people's club. The people built the club, the stadium, everything. Irish clubs generally follow the British model, though there are a couple of exceptions. As a result, clubs too often are merely the playthings of the rich.
There is no simple solution to your answer, Casegrande. A major change of attitude is required.
Gerry
You are living in a world of makebelieve. You don't honestly think that with our current set-up we can progress to the CL?!!!Quote:
Originally posted by Barry's Tea
The way we get to qualify for the CL is by going on as Liam Murphy is showing us. Winning the eircom League. Winning three qualifying rounds of the CL and Bob's Your Marley, we're there, in the CL group stages.
It's not beyond belief.
I'd be doubtful that we can win the league (if we do it's because the other teams are the worst in years). We could not even beat a shower of Latvian plodders.
But to me, at any rate, it's more than just winning the league or getting into the CL. It's about structure and ambition. We need good people running our club. We need to start offering younsters the option to follow a professional football team in Cork as a preferance to 'following' ManU or the Dream Team on the telly.
damn right Casagrande, but until somebody with both money and a love / ambition for the club comes along to buy out the useless shower we have, then we are stuck with what we have. :mad:
But why the **** should the business communities of the City come knocking on the Directors doors offering money when any half-case could see that they are a shower of no-hopers. They have no dream. Would you give money to Cork City FC? So that they could go out and blow it on their Golf-trips and holidays in Latvia.Quote:
Originally posted by Gerry Desmond
I don't have any simple solutions other than the club obviously needs more people involved, needs positive support from fans, the general public and especially the business community of the city.
Where did all the money from the '98-99 league campaign go?
You ask for positive support from the fans:
There is a limit. I have supported City since '89 and in all reality not much has changed since then. How long more do I offer my unwaivered 'positive support'? There are hundreds of others like that. Positive support is nice but covers up the cracks that can ruin a club permanently.
I'm sick of this ****.
You need to chill out, Cas! Take some time to smell the roses, or have a break in Latvia.Quote:
Originally posted by Casegrande
But why the **** should the business communities of the City come knocking on the Directors doors offering money when any half-case could see that they are a shower of no-hopers. They have no dream. Would you give money to Cork City FC? So that they could go out and blow it on their Golf-trips and holidays in Latvia.
Where did all the money from the '98-99 league campaign go?
You ask for positive support from the fans:
There is a limit. I have supported City since '89 and in all reality not much has changed since then. How long more do I offer my unwaivered 'positive support'? There are hundreds of others like that. Positive support is nice but covers up the cracks that can ruin a club permanently.
I'm sick of this ****.
You think you are the only frustrated fan that ever walked?
Gerry
get off the fence Gerry they are either doing a good job or a bad one?
IMO almost every bunch we had right back to Plonk and his stadium of dreams in bishopstown,( where we were told would be good enough to hold full internationals :D )have been cowboys..in it for a fast buck
how exactly are people to get involved?..its a cosy cartel..the only way in is too buy those already there out..
what more do you want the fans to do besides turning up for games?
No I don't. But, unlike you, I'm not happy to just plod along pretending everything is just fine! You are an intelligent person - put some conviction behind what you write. Don't always sit on the fence to keep your employers happy.Quote:
Originally posted by Gerry Desmond
You think you are the only frustrated fan that ever walked?
Doubt if you know whether I'm happy or not, or plodding along for that matter. I can, however, confirm that I am not pretending EVERYTHING is fine. I'm almost definite I've been attending LOI soccer longer than you (1968), have seen more, experienced more AND suffered more. You don't know what frustration is. I was a member of the Cork Celtic SC in 1978-79. When you go through something like that, then you can whinge. Then you will know what a club can do to its supporters.Quote:
Originally posted by Casegrande
No I don't. But, unlike you, I'm not happy to just plod along pretending everything is just fine! You are an intelligent person - put some conviction behind what you write. Don't always sit on the fence to keep your employers happy.
You've already misread one of my earlier posts, I would suggest you pay more attention to what I am saying before drawing further incorrect conclusions.
I don't always sit on the fence, and CCFC are not my employers. I edit a programme for them; do you think they confide their decisions/opinions with me? Get a life!
You are asking questions that ONLY the directors can answer. Either ask THEM the questions or else, as I suggest, chill out before you embarrass yourself.
Life is good,
Gerry
gerry i'm a little confused by what u are posting so i reread the thread and then read it again to besure...
ok here goes
Gerry any chance of elaborating on that or explaining it, cause from i know of in CCFC the club is practially held together by one woman, and financed by the hard and valuable work done by loto volunteers who are fans, doing it cause they love CCFC..the supporters club run buses, hold table quizes and support the team as best they can...apart from mountfield when has a city manager turned up, or until recently a director for a supporters club meeting,Quote:
Originally posted by Gerry Desmond
The question to ask, IMO, about EVERY club in the league, is why are the directors the only people involved with their clubs?
I don't have any simple solutions other than the club obviously needs more people involved, needs positive support from fans, the general public and especially the business community of the city.
and what about the quizes organised to raise money for the club..ie directors back pocket IMO...at least the directors could have the f-ing common courtesy to turn up for them....after the all the hard work thats done by CCFC fans and voluteers to help out the club ..
we all have to work you know, and there are a few people i know that do so much more for the club then any any director has..
now gerry what do you think ?
its off the fence time??-
and i'';; repeat your earlier quote
also in longford there was tireless work there by not only the great directors that they have but also the many many volunteers to get flancare ready for europe, as there is in i would suggest every club in ireland.Quote:
Originally posted by Gerry Desmond
The question to ask, IMO, about EVERY club in the league, is why are the directors the only people involved with their clubs?
it's not too much to ask for is it..a director who cares about the club and not what club to hit off the tee on the 17th at fota?
Gerry don't get in a tiz. You offer one of best arguements that can be found here that's why I bug you about it.
Ok, that's a start. But you **** me off because you never say anything against the club and hammer me when I make my opinion about particular things wrong with the club that YOU are afraid to bring up (or agree with, when I do).Quote:
I can, however, confirm that I am not pretending EVERYTHING is fine.
I don't really see what relevance this has to the points I am making about CORK CITY FC and it's owners.Quote:
I'm almost definite I've been attending LOI soccer longer than you (1968), have seen more, experienced more AND suffered more.
Again, what difference does this make? You can still offer your honest opinion.Quote:
do you think they confide their decisions/opinions with me?
I am putting these questions forward here in the form of a discussion among fans. I don't see why YOU are getting up-tight about the allegations I am making against the Board.Quote:
You are asking questions that ONLY the directors can answer. Either ask THEM the questions or else, as I suggest, chill out before you embarrass yourself.