Printable View
I've seen a bit of Graham Stack between the sticks for both Ireland U21's and Arsenal lately and I genuinely think he's a realistic under-study for Given. I haven't seen or heard anything of Nick Colgan recently. On current form, is Stack our best option for 2nd choice keeper?
Not for me, Kerr has to pick Paddy kenny from Sheffield United for the upcoming friendlies. His form has warranted a call up with eighteen months now and i think he would have been called up against canada if it hadn't been for his injury.
He'd be my number two. Stack and Colgan, couldn't really pick between them, haven't seen enough of either, but at least Stack seem to get the occasional game, Colgan was out of favour last i heard.
How Plastic is Paddy Kenny?Quote:
Originally posted by tiktok
Not for me, Kerr has to pick Paddy kenny from Sheffield United for the upcoming friendlies. His form has warranted a call up with eighteen months now and i think he would have been called up against canada if it hadn't been for his injury.
He'd be my number two. Stack and Colgan, couldn't really pick between them, haven't seen enough of either, but at least Stack seem to get the occasional game, Colgan was out of favour last i heard.
Is Joe Murphy playing anywhere? Is he better than stack (who played a lot for Beveren in Belgium)?
Joe Murphy is a smashing keeper. Just can't shift Hault at WBA. Probably needs a move to further his career.
I was at the Arsenal Boro game last night and I was really impressed by Graham Stack. He made a couple of great saves and looked very comfortable. Admittedly he fluffed one cross but on the whole he looked good.
AFAIK, his father is Irish-born as are both his maternal grandparents. So how plastic do you think that makes him? ;)Quote:
Originally posted by Dodge
How Plastic is Paddy Kenny?
:D PP
Stack's a great keeper, had a really good game last night but I agree Paddy Kenny deserves a chance for the time being. Stack in 2-3 seasons maybe.
Kenny himself said he'd have an easier time getting into the England squad (which at the time when we had Given and Kiely) was true) but that he regarded himself as Irish and wanted to play for Ireland.
As for stack saw him play for the Irish U-21 a few times and wasnt overly impressed, hads a stinker against Scotland but im sure he's come on since then.
As plastic as Kieth Allen is to England?Quote:
Originally posted by Plastic Paddy
AFAIK, his father is Irish-born as are both his maternal grandparents. So how plastic do you think that makes him? ;)
:D PP
Long memory you have there Macy... :DQuote:
Originally posted by Macy
As plastic as Kieth Allen is to England?
:D PP
2 words
Greg Rusedski
2 more
John Barnes
ohh, another 2
Owen Hargreaves
terry butcher is another
While we're at it so is Martin Keown.
Watched Arsenal game last night. Was again impressed by Stack. Brilliant save from Maccarone but all round very solid and looks pretty unflappable which you can't say about Murphy who in fairness nearly sh@t himself against Turkey. Have seen him live twice this season too(league cup games are cheap and easy to get tickets for) and have liked what i've seen. For me Stack and Kenny have to be brought in as Given's understudies.
I agree with you there.Quote:
Originally posted by Bowsy
Watched Arsenal game last night. Was again impressed by Stack.
He was put under undue pressure from some poor defending and coped admirably. Couldn't fault him for the goals.
I hope Arsenals exit from the league cup doesn't see Graham fade into the background again. Taylor was on the bench last night which means he's coming back to fitness. Brian Kerr may have had other things on his mind last night but I hope someone gives him the video of the game.
will be interesting. Don't think much of Taylor and Rami Shaaban is the stiffest looking keeper i've ever seen. Both young though so if they get preference on their returns from injury and West Ham respectively it won't bode well for Stack's Arsenal future. If maintains current promise though will definitely have a future in top flight football.
I don't know about that. Lehman isn't exactly a spring chicken, so I'd expect him to leave if one of the younger players breaks through ahead of him, and Shaaban hasn't impressed me.Quote:
Originally posted by Bowsy
Don't think much of Taylor and Rami Shaaban is the stiffest looking keeper i've ever seen. Both young though so if they get preference on their returns from injury and West Ham respectively it won't bode well for Stack's Arsenal future.
Has Stack gone ahead of Taylor in the pecking order?
Taylor is fit again but Stack played last night. It would be very interesting if Stack was the No.2 coz afaik Lehman is 33 or so.
Might as well throw Lennox Lewis in there aswell, hold on there's also our very own Kieran Bracken who plays Rugby Union for Engerland.Quote:
Originally posted by finlma
While we're at it so is Martin Keown.
Kenny should be No.2 as he is playing every week. Stack sounds very promising. I would as soon see an eL keeper who is getting his game every week be in the squad ( 3rd choice keeper? ) rather than some reserve in England who has played a handful of games in their whole career.
Remember Jim Goodwin getting a cap against Finland when he had about a dozen first team games in his whole career behind him ( that said, he was a very promising underage international )? Surely a promising young ( 18-24 ) eL centreback who had a few seasons experience as a first teamer should have been given a chance in that case ( and would have put them in the shop window too ).
The Arsenal boss seems to stick with one keeper during cup campaigns. Last season I think Taylor played in every FA Cup game bar the final. I presume Stack was playing ahead of Taylor as a reward for his participation in the competition up until that point.Quote:
Originally posted by SÓCcfc
Taylor is fit again but Stack played last night.
Speaking of which, couldnt Steve Williams play for Ireland now that FIFA have changed the rule?Quote:
Originally posted by Shelsman
Kenny should be No.2 as he is playing every week. Stack sounds very promising. I would as soon see an eL keeper who is getting his game every week be in the squad
Be a better option than Joe Murphy