Nominees here
:confused:
How the hell has Richard Dunne not being nominated for Senior Player of the Year??? He's been Man of the Match in nearly every game!
Printable View
Nominees here
:confused:
How the hell has Richard Dunne not being nominated for Senior Player of the Year??? He's been Man of the Match in nearly every game!
John O'Shea, you've got to be kidding me.
McGeady and Doyle for me
How the hell is Stephen Rice there, he's not that good.
I could make a gay joke about his nomination but it'd be in bad taste!:D:cool:Quote:
Originally Posted by irishfan86
Don't get me wrong, he's been a pleasant surprise alongside Dunne in the centre of our defence in the early stages of our campaign, but if he gets player of the year I won't know what to do.Quote:
Originally Posted by rambler14
Hope it goes to Shay.
I'd imagine it's because of the new under 23 team, they decided to have one nominee from that and he played well for them and scored the last minute winner against the North. No chance of him winning.Quote:
Originally Posted by sligoman
Good for a LoI player to be in that company though, it's the kind of thing that catches the attention of casual supporters.
He has been very good so far under Trap, definately one of our most consistant players.Some people have it so drilled into their heads that they think he is crap that they cant even admit it to themselves when he plays wellQuote:
Originally Posted by irishfan86
I've been one of his biggest critics but no doubt he has improved, which, in fairness, wasn't that hard to do. Still having lapses of ball watching, first Polish goal for example.Quote:
Originally Posted by Razors left peg
No way should he be in line player of the year. Should be between Doyle, Dunne and Given.
Agreed, the Dunne/O;Shea partnership has started well.Quote:
Originally Posted by Razors left peg
How many times has Shay won the senior player award ?
The last 2 years I think.Quote:
Originally Posted by co. down green
The 1st bit is obvious sarcasm so please put in the :rolleyes:!Quote:
Originally Posted by Ciaran
As for the Duff thing.......well that definetley deserves a :rolleyes:!
Didn't Given miss half the games due to injury???
I'm not one of these people. I think he's done very well under Trap.Quote:
Originally Posted by Razors left peg
But there is no question in my mind that he is the weaker half of the Dunne-O'Shea axis, and thus there is no way he should be nominated ahead of Richard Dunne for player of the year.
If there was a "most improved," then I'd consider giving it to him, but this isn't a U-13 side.
For the record Rice is a better player than all three and played more international football for his country this year than Gibson or LongQuote:
Originally Posted by Ciaran
Given, but why isn't Dunne nominated?Quote:
Senior
Kevin Doyle - Reading
Shay Given – Newcastle United
John O’Shea – Manchester United
McGeadyQuote:
Young/U23
Aiden McGeady - Celtic
Andy Keogh - Wolves
Stephen Rice – Shamrock Rovers
Close call between Garvan and Quinn. Garvan.Quote:
U21
Owen Garvan – Ipswich Town
Stephen Quinn – Sheffield United
Darren O’Dea - Celtic
The build up to Doyle and Keane's goals were brilliant, the finish was simple enough. But I'm going to go with Keogh's goal.Quote:
International Goal of the Year
Robbie Keane v Cyprus (H) 15/10/08
Andy Keogh v Serbia (H) 24/05/08
Kevin Doyle v Georgia (A) 6/09/08
FaheyQuote:
League Of Ireland
Owen Heary (Bohemian FC)
Brian Murphy (Bohemian FC)
Keith Fahey (St. Patrick’s Ath/Birmingham City)
Spillane, played more first team football than the other twoQuote:
U19 Nominees
Michael Spillane - Norwich
Brendan Moloney – Nottingham Forest
Garry Breen – Hereford United
Doran seemed to change the game when he came on in the recent qualifiers for the U-19s, so he gets the nodQuote:
U17 Nominees
Conor Hourihane – Sunderland
Ger Hanley – Salthill Devon
Aaron Doran – Blackburn Rovers
Don't know enough about the rest of the categories to comment
Senior John O'Shea - looks really good under Trap and has also won the CL and premiership.
U23 Aiden McGeady
U21 Stephen Quinn
LoI Keith Fahey
U19 - can't really judge that one as i didn't see them.
U17 - Ger Hanley looks a great keeper but needs to grow. - Hourihane missed most of the games I saw and Doran did well also.
Errr....Quote:
Originally Posted by gspain
Eh? part 1 ... You may have missed it but there is a forum on this very website which tells you more than you ever need to know about the likes of Stephen Rice and other locally based players.Quote:
Originally Posted by Ciaran
Eh? part 2 .. the clue is in the u23 part of the nomination title. Again you may have missed it but we have an u23 team - again that's been covered at length elsewhere on this website.
ciaran............
........................................
.................................................. ..
:rolleyes:
I didn't think Spillane was still u19. Remember seeing him play u19s about 2/3 years ago at centre half beside Noel Haverty and thinking he was the only player likely to make the senior side. He was a man amongst boys
He's one of those players that developed earlier than the norm i.e. he was about 6ft tall at 16, so it wouldn't be hard to look like a man amongst boys :)Quote:
Originally Posted by Dodge
Will be interesting to see how he gets on later in his career when he won't have such an obvious advantage.
Ceremony online already on rte.ie: http://www.rte.ie/sport/soccer/2009/...awards_av.html
Not much interest in this affair but I'd say it was a big night for all the young footballers in for the many underage awards.
U19 Michael Spillane, at last a decent sized midfielder.
U21 Owen Garvan
LOI POTY Brian Murphy, looks to be a fine goalkeeper, as good as I've seen since 3 or 4 recessions ago.