Brian Murphy-Bohs keeper

Printable View

25/09/2008, 5:36 PM
Spoons

Brian Murphy-Bohs keeper

I read the "Ireland" squad to play Notts Forst in Dalymount Park on Thursday 9th October. What an absolute disgraceful insult to all eircom League players especially young Murphy that he is not involved....Dont give me the match the following night he may be playing blah blah blah.....the game could be played on the Saturday 11th (would probably save on flying players in and out!) if logic was used.................this guy has conceeded EIGHT goals in TWENTY SIX MATCHES all season as Bohs run away with the League........ a fella playing with Scunthorpe, another who is two months left Carlise are chosen ahead of him..............get a grip Trappatoni you clown, Staunton would be pilloried if he did this...................:mad::mad::mad:
25/09/2008, 6:01 PM
Saint_Charlie

The reality is if you play in Ireland it's highly unlikely you'll get picked.

Unfortunate but true.
25/09/2008, 6:13 PM
Bohemian1890

Let them know who we want to see.

Irish players like Murphy,not some mercenary like Westwood.

Andrews got in,he only moved about 3 weeks ago from League One.

Playing an English team:o,suppose half of them are English.

We probably have more English players than them:o
25/09/2008, 6:26 PM
robertob

I'm disappointed too. I think players like Fahey and Brian Murphy would deserve a nomination for Irish nationalteam. In so an unimportant match like now against Forest they could get a chance to show her skills absolutely.
25/09/2008, 6:39 PM
brianw82

I think a "Murphy for Ireland" chant is in order on the night. :)
25/09/2008, 6:57 PM
Cymro

At least the players he did pick are playing in a fully professional league. You can't blame Trapattoni for going for the safer bet, especially considering he is an Italian.

Also, Brian Murphy failed at Swansea. When we were in League Two.
25/09/2008, 7:01 PM
holidaysong

Is this an Ireland B team playing Nottingham Forest?
25/09/2008, 7:05 PM
Rovers1

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cymro

Also, Brian Murphy failed at Swansea. When we were in League Two.

how long ago was this?
who was your first choice keeper?
25/09/2008, 7:08 PM
Bohemian1890

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cymro

At least the players he did pick are playing in a fully professional league. You can't blame Trapattoni for going for the safer bet, especially considering he is an Italian.

Also, Brian Murphy failed at Swansea. When we were in League Two.

How many players failed at the small clubs,before going on to play well for the bigger clubs??

Murphy was also chased by bigger clubs than Swansea in the summer,he turned them down.
25/09/2008, 7:09 PM
brianw82

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cymro

At least the players he did pick are playing in a fully professional league. You can't blame Trapattoni for going for the safer bet, especially considering he is an Italian.

Also, Brian Murphy failed at Swansea. When we were in League Two.

Maybe so. However, I've seen Murphy in action several times this year, and some of the saves he's made were Given-esque.

It would be no harm for Trap and Alan Kelly to run the rule over him, surely?
25/09/2008, 9:05 PM
lofty9

Murphy played the best performance I have seen in a long long time at the Brandywell this season by any visiting player.
25/09/2008, 10:01 PM
Dodge

He's a superb keeper and I genuinely believe if we had him in goal and Bohs had Barry Ryan, we'd be 16 points clear. Brilliant all round keeper

This is only an Irish XI kickabout. I'd be disgusted if a Pats player played in it with our schedule. I'm sure the lad himself is disappointed but he's bigger than this, frankly embarrassing, game
25/09/2008, 11:21 PM
NeilMcD

Yeah I would rather that Murphy plays for Bohs the following night against Drogheda and maybe wins the league title that night or goes pretty close to clinching it. The point is that the LOI is not scheduled to facilitate call ups to international squads as it requires the players to miss games etc.

BTW I think that Murphy is clearly good enough to be in this squad though but he is not available to be picked.
25/09/2008, 11:37 PM
El-Pietro

Brian Murphy, Keith Fahey, Colin Healy/Joe Gamble Quigley and Mooney all deserve to be looked at.
26/09/2008, 12:29 AM
Boh_So_Good

Notts Forest. I mean is this some kind of joke.

Bohs would beat them in Dalymount. The Britishness of the Ireland senior squad has actually accellerated under Trapatoni.
26/09/2008, 12:48 AM
sligoman

Quote:

Originally Posted by Boh_So_Good

Notts Forest. I mean is this some kind of joke.

Bohs would beat them in Dalymount. The Britishness of the Ireland senior squad has actually accellerated under Trapatoni.

Trap did say ideally they'd have liked to play a LOI team but it wouldn't suit our season. He's right.
26/09/2008, 12:53 AM
rambler14

Those of you who are complaining about the lack of Eircom League players in the squad seem to be missing the fact that there are league matches that weekend so rather than annoy EL managers Trap did the sensible thing and didn't call up any.
26/09/2008, 8:04 AM
razor

From a goalkeeping perspective Alan Kelly is probably the go to man.
He hardly watches much Eircom League.
26/09/2008, 8:11 AM
Dodge

Quote:

Originally Posted by rambler14

Those of you who are complaining about the lack of Eircom League players in the squad seem to be missing the fact that there are league matches that weekend so rather than annoy EL managers Trap did the sensible thing and didn't call up any.

I agree but the argument (and its equally valid) is that they didn't have to play this game on a Thursday night, and could easily have fit it around the majority of the league and cup schedules.

I fail to see how playing Nott'm Forest will be any sort of measure for budding internationals though
26/09/2008, 9:24 AM
gustavo

I think its fair to say Bohs will win the league at a canter regardless of whether Murphy plays in that game or not
26/09/2008, 9:36 AM
NeilMcD

You may think that but maybe the reason that Bohs are top is that the Bohs players have not that lke that and Fenlon as not let them think like that.

This game had to be played either on the Thursday or the Saturday night as it needed to be played during an international break and the full squad are arriving on the Sunday so it needed to be played before then. The Friday would not have worked as the Eircom League is on that night.
26/09/2008, 9:47 AM
disabledrog

Murphy was actually offered another deal at the swans and turned it down,he is a better keeper than westwood and murphy of scunthorpe.
also think fahy should be playin at the very least the championship
26/09/2008, 1:02 PM
Cymro

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bohemian1890

How many players failed at the small clubs,before going on to play well for the bigger clubs??

Rather irrelevant. The point is that you can read more into success in a fully professional league than you can into success in a league where half the players have day jobs. Not being disrespectful here, it's simply a fact.

Carlisle and Scunthorpe might not exactly seem like the biggest clubs in the world, but their teams are actually tidy enough, and both are top-end League One sides which is a fairly decent standard.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bohemian1890

Murphy was also chased by bigger clubs than Swansea in the summer,he turned them down.

Source please. Not rubbishing your claim, but I've been following his progress since he left us and I haven't heard of any bigger clubs than ourselves making any bids.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rovers1

how long ago was this?
who was your first choice keeper?

3-4 years ago. At the time Willy Gueret would have been 1st choice for us.

Quote:

Originally Posted by brianw82

Maybe so. However, I've seen Murphy in action several times this year, and some of the saves he's made were Given-esque.

It would be no harm for Trap and Alan Kelly to run the rule over him, surely?

True, Brian no doubt has some talent. Even though he couldn't hold down a regular first-team place with ourselves, he still had his moments.

My point is that I don't think it's unreasonable for an international manager to go for the players playing at higher levels, especially if those players are also uncapped. Maybe if this Westwood fella had already had a shot in the Irish team and failed you could argue in favour of Brian getting a shot. I just think some of the comments here are a little strong considering all things.

Quote:

Originally Posted by disabledrog

Murphy was actually offered another deal at the swans and turned it down. he is a better keeper than westwood and murphy of scunthorpe.
also think fahy should be playin at the very least the championship

He left because he wanted first-team football, think that says it all.

He could very well have improved significantly since leaving us......or he could simply be being flattered by the opposition.
26/09/2008, 1:13 PM
Dodge

Cymro, without being funny but you've admitted you don't watch the league so why are you commenting onit?
26/09/2008, 1:26 PM
BohDiddley

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dodge

Cymro, without being funny but you've admitted you don't watch the league so why are you commenting onit?

In his defence, he's in the company there of 90% of the Irish sporting media, and it's never stopped them!