Tipp South & District League 2009/10

Printable View

Show 40 post(s) from this thread on one page

13/05/2010, 2:29 PM
nononsense

Quote:

Originally Posted by complexman

Thats a fair point and I do agree with you. Yes you are correct Lewis would get the blame. Surely though the registered letter is proof and that is black and white or am I missing something. Anyway, we will find out soon enough. I am more concerned with the suspensions

It is nice to see good and honest discussion here between Town Fan, Soccer Fan, Complexman and Ronburgundy. If you ask the right questions from the right people in the proper manner you will get the right answers. I have enquired about the Robbie Costigan affair. If you ask any fair-minded Clonmel Town person he/she will tell the truth. There is a very serious problem with his registration. The TSDL brought Clonmel Town to a meeting and pointed out the problem. The TSDL told Town, after explaining the problem and likely consequences, they could play him if they wish. The TSDL are investigating the registration fully. It appears Clonmel Town have decided not to use him as he has not played any game yet.
Finally, yes, it was most disappointing to see a great and proud club like Clonmel Town snub the presentation to Peake Villa. It was Peake's proud moment, a moment many teams shared with Town through the previous six years. Lets hope, someday, the management and players of Clonmel Town will realise what they did was wrong.
14/05/2010, 8:38 AM
complexman

Quote:

Originally Posted by nononsense

It is nice to see good and honest discussion here between Town Fan, Soccer Fan, Complexman and Ronburgundy. If you ask the right questions from the right people in the proper manner you will get the right answers. I have enquired about the Robbie Costigan affair. If you ask any fair-minded Clonmel Town person he/she will tell the truth. There is a very serious problem with his registration. The TSDL brought Clonmel Town to a meeting and pointed out the problem. The TSDL told Town, after explaining the problem and likely consequences, they could play him if they wish. The TSDL are investigating the registration fully. It appears Clonmel Town have decided not to use him as he has not played any game yet.
Finally, yes, it was most disappointing to see a great and proud club like Clonmel Town snub the presentation to Peake Villa. It was Peake's proud moment, a moment many teams shared with Town through the previous six years. Lets hope, someday, the management and players of Clonmel Town will realise what they did was wrong.

I have to agree with you. Irrespective of what went on previously, this was wrong. I am very, very dissapointed to hear this. Just hope as you say the management and players realise they did wrong.

Any news from Arbitration? anyone know when we will have news of their ruling
14/05/2010, 9:20 AM
saintsfan

Today, there will be definitely be news on the Arbitration. Can I just add, it was a pity to see what Clonmel Town team/management did last Sunday - Saints have had to look at them collecting domestic cups for a couple of seasons and never once, did I see anyone walk off to the dressing room, no matter how hard it is to look at another team get a Cup.
14/05/2010, 12:46 PM
tipp man

Quote:

Originally Posted by nononsense

It is nice to see good and honest discussion here between Town Fan, Soccer Fan, Complexman and Ronburgundy. If you ask the right questions from the right people in the proper manner you will get the right answers. I have enquired about the Robbie Costigan affair. If you ask any fair-minded Clonmel Town person he/she will tell the truth. There is a very serious problem with his registration. The TSDL brought Clonmel Town to a meeting and pointed out the problem. The TSDL told Town, after explaining the problem and likely consequences, they could play him if they wish. The TSDL are investigating the registration fully. It appears Clonmel Town have decided not to use him as he has not played any game yet.
Finally, yes, it was most disappointing to see a great and proud club like Clonmel Town snub the presentation to Peake Villa. It was Peake's proud moment, a moment many teams shared with Town through the previous six years. Lets hope, someday, the management and players of Clonmel Town will realise what they did was wrong.

If Muiris Walsh resigned because of this, will other heads roll as a result??????????
14/05/2010, 1:04 PM
complexman

Oh that is a very dangerous question!!! Are you suggesting that Muiris was guilty of some inappropiate behaviour. I think that is way off the mark. Muiris is a man of great integrity and I think anybody who knows him would agree with my opnion. I think this whole Muiris Walsh resigining issue, should halt now. Its been going on for to long and as somebody here who spoke to him said, he wants time out. I think we should respect that
14/05/2010, 1:23 PM
tipp man

Quote:

Originally Posted by complexman

Oh that is a very dangerous question!!! Are you suggesting that Muiris was guilty of some inappropiate behaviour. I think that is way off the mark. Muiris is a man of great integrity and I think anybody who knows him would agree with my opnion. I think this whole Muiris Walsh resigining issue, should halt now. Its been going on for to long and as somebody here who spoke to him said, he wants time out. I think we should respect that

I'm not suggesting he did anything wrong at all. I am floating the idea that his integrity was important to him so he walked rather than attempt to justify a dodgy player registration, somehting he has nothing to do with
14/05/2010, 1:24 PM
tipp man

Saints won the arbitration.
14/05/2010, 1:29 PM
complexman

I have to say, I think you are a million miles of the mark there. Could ot see Town involved in anything sinister. I would drop this now
14/05/2010, 1:39 PM
saintsfan

Quote:

Originally Posted by tipp man

Saints won the arbitration.

Yes, word is getting through, Saints are playing Town in semi final next weekend, what a game it promises to be!
14/05/2010, 1:41 PM
tipp man

Quote:

Originally Posted by nononsense

If you ask any fair-minded Clonmel Town person he/she will tell the truth. There is a very serious problem with his registration. .

Maybe Mr. Complexman you should read this post. Way off the mark my arse.
14/05/2010, 1:45 PM
complexman

Quote:

Originally Posted by tipp man

Maybe Mr. Complexman you should read this post. Way off the mark my arse.

I am not doubting that there is a problem with the registration but I think your suggesting of Town or Muiris deliberately doing anything inappropriate is wrong.
14/05/2010, 1:46 PM
Dirk Diggler

Somebody needs to explain how Saints are going through. Shouldn't Clonmel not get a buy into the final. That would be the fairest thing.
14/05/2010, 1:52 PM
tipp man

Quote:

Originally Posted by complexman

I am not doubting that there is a problem with the registration but I think your suggesting of Town or Muiris deliberately doing anything inappropriate is wrong.

If anyone got the impression that I was suggesting inappropriate behaviour by Muiris Walsh then I apologise and retract that.
14/05/2010, 1:59 PM
Pearoso27

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dirk Diggler

Somebody needs to explain how Saints are going through. Shouldn't Clonmel not get a buy into the final. That would be the fairest thing.

Where have you been for the last 4-5 weeks all that has been explained and frankly were all sick of it so lets get on with what matters now and that is FOOTBALL! Everything else is irrelevant decision made end of story!
14/05/2010, 3:24 PM
MerchantsView

serpico no sour grapes now. yer gone get over it.
14/05/2010, 3:45 PM
blackjack

best of luck to clonmel town in semi if john delaney has anything to do with it ye will not get to final (st micheal v barcelona 31 july cooke park free entry to all micheals supporters)
14/05/2010, 3:49 PM
the 12 th man

There's a new thread opened up for the FAI Junior Cup,it's up to you lads how long it lasts.
14/05/2010, 3:56 PM
saintsfan

Quote:

Originally Posted by blackjack

best of luck to clonmel town in semi if john delaney has anything to do with it ye will not get to final (st micheal v barcelona 31 july cooke park free entry to all micheals supporters)

that is below the belt - sour grapes, is that all people have to say, Pike done wrong, not St. Michaels. Get over it, it's over and done now. If Saints hadn't spotted the problem, I guarantee you, some other team would have. What if Carrick get a bye into Final with Town in Munster Junior Cup, will ye badger Carrick also and Limerick Teams who look for points from Pike, will they get the same going over? As 12th man, there is a new FAI thread started, go on that, if you want to have a pop & leave the TSDL thread alone. Also if you notice, no genuine Tipp Town Fans have gone on any thread and had a "told you that would happen" pop at Pike. Leave the matter lie at this stage.
14/05/2010, 4:07 PM
blackjack

Quote:

Originally Posted by saintsfan

that is below the belt - sour grapes, is that all people have to say, Pike done wrong, not St. Michaels. Get over it, it's over and done now. If Saints hadn't spotted the problem, I guarantee you, some other team would have. What if Carrick get a bye into Final with Town in Munster Junior Cup, will ye badger Carrick also and Limerick Teams who look for points from Pike, will they get the same going over? As 12th man, there is a new FAI thread started, go on that, if you want to have a pop & leave the TSDL thread alone. Also if you notice, no genuine Tipp Town Fans have gone on any thread and had a "told you that would happen" pop at Pike. Leave the matter lie at this stage.

just to let you know saints didnt spot any problem,thats why they went up with no proof whatsoever.if there is any justice ye will not win fai junior cup.
14/05/2010, 4:13 PM
the 12 th man

Quote:

Originally Posted by blackjack

just to let you know saints didnt spot any problem,thats why they went up with no proof whatsoever.if there is any justice ye will not win fai junior cup.

blackjack,drop it,this is a thread for the TSDL in general,there's a new thread for the FAI Junior Cup.

Show 40 post(s) from this thread on one page