Printable View
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jock MIB
I would think he was,surely the player who "lifts"the ball has touched it more than once in the movement to set it up which I think is illegal,If I remember this was allowed up to a point but after this goal it was outlawed.http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wjq2xT-tx38
I would agree, but want to know what did you type in search box to get that goal , the sneakiest goal as second choice and that nice picture of Whats Going with lady in little red number as third choice :DQuote:
Originally Posted by the 12 th man
No - Laws 13 states "For both direct and indirect free kicks, the ball must be stationary when the kick is taken and the kicker must not touch the ball againQuote:
Originally Posted by rambler14
until it has touched another player." I cannot see how the player can play this by only touching the ball once from a stationary position.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jock MIB
I just typed goal coventry and scrolled down,as for the lady in red:p
Ye, that was legal in 1970, but was outlawed soon after to prevent this type of goal!Quote:
Originally Posted by the 12 th man
i believe you :rolleyes: more like coventy and red light :DQuote:
Originally Posted by the 12 th man
Ref,just finished ref course,should be allocated league next 2 weeks to start,any advice..?
Don't do what Buttimer did!:rolleyes:Quote:
Originally Posted by gaffer33
Prepare the night before a game, plan your route and allow for traffic. Bring two different colour jerseys in your bag.Quote:
Originally Posted by gaffer33
Join the referees society
Seek advice from fellow referees, there is a wealth of experience that can be tapped into.
Make your reputation, be consistent and fair. Never pre-judge a game, the easy ones are the ones you least expect as are the difficult ones.
If you are nervous, try not to let it show, players will try to exploit any weakness.
Only give what you can see, don't be swayed by players, managers, supporters
Be prepared for games where you feel your performance is poor, honestly evaluate your own performance and learn from your mistakes.
Enjoy the good ones, because the next one might not be so good.
Enjoy it, you will make more friends than enemies!
The goal scored by Cousin, should this be allowed to stand:
http://videos.sapo.pt/aYJVrc2gZzNVwFuZqu8N
Cause the ref blew the whistle and Marney picked up the ball after it was blown.
Nothing wrong with it.Quote:
Originally Posted by TheBoss
The ball is dead until it's kicked! So technically Marney could have picked it up and thrown it to the fella who hit the free and then re-placed it.
That is what I thought in the first place but something is telling me, once the ref blows the whistle, the ball is in play.
Goal is legal, Law 13 provides that the ball is not in play until it is kicked and moves. The referee blowing his whistle is nothing more than a signal to inform players that he is happy that the kick may be taken.Quote:
Originally Posted by TheBoss
hi i am just wondering what is the story with the jerseys in the munster junior cup, is it the home team or away team that change. not sure about this as i think it is different rules for different competitions.
Not familiar with MFA rules so I checked their website.Quote:
Originally Posted by celticlads
Rule 5 States "Players in each competing team must wear the registered colours of the club for which they are playing except when opposing teams have similar colours, in which case the visiting team shall have choice. A goalkeeper must wear a shirt or sweater of different colour, provided that said shirt or sweater is of a colour distinctive from that of his opponents. Referees shall have power to instruct a player to change his shirt or sweater if they consider the colours not quite distinctive from that of his opponents. Referees shall have the power to deal with any player refusing to comply with their instruction in this respect."
So according to this visiting teams have choice.
A query about the penalty Ireland got, it appears the Georgian player changes his mind about handballing it, so could the ref give a foul for intent to handball or does it not exist, since intent is used for most fouls.
Hi The Ref!
Can you give me any idea what's happening after you fill in a form for Referee School of Excellence?
Thanks!
You have entered the Dark Side and there is no return :DQuote:
Originally Posted by snams
Should Stillian Petrov have been sent-off for handling on the line vs Everton in the FA Cup even though Everton scored from the rebound?
I think he should!
I'm not sure the officials spotted it as I think the refs view was obscured.Quote:
Originally Posted by rambler14
What if they did and were just playing advantage?Quote:
Originally Posted by the 12 th man
I know they didn't spot it like!
Quote:
Originally Posted by rambler14
Well if they were playing advantage the ref would have gone and red or at least yellow carded him after the goal.
Could you qoute me the rule about referees and permission to let people enter the field of play??
In what context,Quote:
Originally Posted by daz22
Is it a player, substitution, physio, manager, spectator?
Quote:
Originally Posted by The Ref
Manager and a person who is an coach who not on the card
I had a game during the week and at one point a shot was taken from outside the box, our keep wasn't too confident about catching it so he palmed it down infront of him, it bounced once and then he caught it. I taught this was alright but the ref blew up and gave an indirect freekick to them, and said he couldn't do that. Was he right?? Is there a rule on that??
No.....i'd say that referee was on the take!Quote:
Originally Posted by sligo23
Any League of Irelands Referees on here?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Im doing a thesis on referees on whether they contribute to home advantage. I need referee assessor sheets from league of Ireland games to measure it for my study? no manes used in study , everything is strictly confidential. please help if can????
I was thinking that meself:p:mad:Quote:
Originally Posted by rambler14
Manager and coach must stay in the technical area (as if in Junior football)Quote:
Originally Posted by daz22
In the interpertation of the Laws of the Game it provides:
Team officials
If a team official enters the field of play:
• the referee must stop play (although not immediately if the team official does not interfere with play or if the advantage can be applied)
• the referee must have him removed from the field of play and if his behaviour is irresponsible, the referee must expel him from the field of play and its immediate surroundings
• if the referee stops the match, he must restart play with a dropped ball in the position where the ball was at the time when the match was stopped, unless play was stopped inside the goal area, in which case the referee drops the ball on the goal area line parallel to the goal line at the point nearest to where the ball was located when play was stopped
Back in 1992/3 season when this Law was changed this caused a lot of problems. I remember the referees seminar when John Scanlon explained this rule that he spent over an hour dealing with it. A number of Referee Society branch meeting were taken up arguing about it.Quote:
Originally Posted by sligo23
Law 12 provides:
An indirect free kick is awarded to the opposing team if a goalkeeper, inside his own penalty area, commits any of the following four offences:
• controls the ball with his hands for more than six seconds before releasing it from his possession
• touches the ball again with his hands after he has released it from his possession and before it has touched another player
• touches the ball with his hands after it has been deliberately kicked to him by a team-mate
• touches the ball with his hands after he has received it directly from a throw-in taken by a team-mate
If the referee deemed that the goalkeeper released the ball from his possession when he palmed it down i.e. the goalkeeper could have held and was palming it down to waste time, then theoretically a free kick could be given. In practice, from the way you explain it, I wouldn't have given it.
:confused: If as Sligo23 says he "palmed" the ball down, does that not imply that the keeper has 1. controlled the ball, 2. directed it to where he has control and 3. taken the ball back into his control before touching another player? This as opposed to the GK being allowed to bounce the ball from his hands so long as he releases the ball within the 6 second rule!Quote:
Originally Posted by The Ref
What are your toughts on the two CL semi-finals Ref??
The first ref had a good game. Last night the ref was harsh in the sending off because the Chelsea player tripped over his own feet. Replayed it a number of times and the defender did clip his heel, the attacker moved one step forward and then you can see his right foot connect with his left and down he goes. There was a defender coming from the left who could have intercepted and that makes it a hairline decision for the ref. Both claims for handball were invalid as the law is hand to ball not ball to hand and always the intention has to be taken into account. That's my opinion on the 2 refs. As for Chelsea, they did not play there own usual game and always seemed uncomfortable, fair play to Barca they had what Chelsea lacked - determination to win. :ball:Quote:
Originally Posted by sligo23
if a match is fixed for 7pm a team is late due to traffic.
arrives 6.45 on the pitch 7pm is the team entitled to warm up in the interest of the welfare of the players?
In Clare they don't allow any late start, referee can pick up the ball and walk away. It has happened to us on a couple of occasions when teams were late arriving.Quote:
Originally Posted by renovater
if a match is fixed for 7.00pm then that is the starting time, the rest is down to the referees discression.Quote:
Originally Posted by renovater
lads just wondering can we be forced to play a cup final in the oppositions home ground. we are in 2 cup finals and agreed to play in said venue if we could play the 2 games there but as this was not accommodated we said we want it neutral, can we be forced to play in their home?
Lads if a player has picked up 2 yellow cards in previous games and ends up getting sent off for two yellow cards in the next game, is this now counted as 4 yellow cards for the season and does he then go back to scratch. And therefore if he is suspended for the sending off should he serve a further game for 4 yellow cards, or does he only get credited for 1 yellow as a result of the dismissal :confused: :confused:.These circumstances would refer to the Mayo League rules, in case you were wondering.
Hiya lads,
Unfortunately, both of your questions relate to league rules, rather than the Laws of the Game. Neither situation is something the referees have any control over or can get involved in.
In the case of the cup game, while we would all say that this situation is not ideal, the administrators may be well within their rights. Request a copy of the rules pertaining to this cup competition from your league secretary (or from the FAI if it is a national cup).
In the case of the yellow cards, the referees just give them & then report it. What happens after that in Disciplinary Committees etc does not involve us. Again, get a copy of the league rules from your secretary.
In both cases, if your leagues have websites, the rules may be available for download there.
HTH!
GiB