When it comes to how I identify myself politically, that post sums up my own feelings beautifully (though no doubt Ardee Bhoy's fingers are already straining at the keyboard to educate me as to what I do/should/must feel etc)
However, whatever one feels on the vexed political questions of "nationality" and "identity" etc, I genuinely feel it is (or should be, at any rate) entirely irrelevant to the debate over footballing eligibility.
For as a Southern GAA fan put it so eloquently on another forum:
"So by virtue of the GFA agreement people can be Irish within* Northern Ireland and have that right secured. So why would they need to play for another sports team, when their Irishness is assured within Northern Ireland? The GFA argument actually works against those who want to play for the Republic"
Otherwise, if representing the ROI at football is somehow essential towards "being Irish", would that mean eg a brother of Darron Gibson who has never played for ROI, is somehow "less Irish" than he? Would someone like to tell eg Gerry Taggart that he is somehow "less Irish" for having played 51 times for NI? (I'd pay good money to see that one!) What about eg Gerry Armstrong? Are his NI caps cancelled out by his also having played Gaelic Football at Croke Park for his club? And where does Martin O'Neill stand on the issue? I mean to say, can he offset his NI caps by his own GAA career? And does his management of Celtic offset his acceptance of an MBE from Her Majesty? Perhaps someone like Kingdom Kerry can solve this conundrum, seeing as he knows everything else about NI (from a distance of 200 miles...)
Of course, there is actually a much simpler solution staring us in the face, if only people would acknowledge it. Namely, there are two Football Associations in Ireland, each with its own territory, jurisdiction and international football team. So that if you are born within the territory of one, that is whom you represent; whereas if born within the territory of the other, then the same applies. For that way, both the IFA and FAI would be treated in exactly the same way as all of the other 206 Member Associations of FIFA, whereby being born within one Associations territory does NOT automatically give someone a choice to represent some other Association (outwith the normal exception of ancestry or residence, deriving from Dual Nationality).
Of course, such a suggestion will no doubt raise the ire of small-minded individuals who cannot see beyond their own petty political prejudices towards the wider interests of sport. Nor do they appear to possess the integrity to acknowledge it when others reconcile their personal political allegiances etc with representing one Irish international football team over another.
Speaking of which, the most recent example comes from this morning, when Damien Johnson issued the following statement on the occasion of his retirement from international football:
“It has been a huge honour for me to have represented Northern Ireland and I have enjoyed many special moments throughout my international career,” said the 31-year-old, who has been capped 56 times for his country.
“I would like to take this opportunity to thank everyone who has helped me during my time with the Northern Ireland team: the managers who I have played under; the backroom staff; all of the players I've played alongside; and the incredible fans for their support.
“It hasn't been an easy decision for me to make but, with the help of my family, I feel it is the best decision for my career.
“I'd particularly like to thank Nigel Worthington for his support and understanding over the last couple of weeks. I wish Nigel and the team every success in the forthcoming European Championships.”Read more: http://www.breakingnews.ie/sport/nis...#ixzz0v66Xr6OT
Quite honestly, I wouldn't swap the privilege of watching a true Gentleman and Professional like DJ for 10 x Darron "Irish" Gibsons or 10 x Shane "Catholic" Duffys. Indeed, I should probably pity those ROI fans from "the North" who will never feel the pride I and my fellow NI fans feel when 11 players from the same wee bit of the world as theirs, put aside whatever political allegiances they may have and march out to take on all-comers from the rest of the world, win, lose or draw.
* - The GFA specifically includes: "Recognition of the birthright of all the people of Northern Ireland to identify themselves and be accepted as Irish or British, or both, as they may so choose"