Harsh talk , worse than pub talkQuote:
Originally Posted by fruice
Printable View
Harsh talk , worse than pub talkQuote:
Originally Posted by fruice
All I’ll say is we were told points in bag not there not can’t say more till we look into it
MFA will be the next step. Grattan will get points there. Makes a mockery of the Premier Division that the league can't sort themeselves.
Did Grattan lodge a protest against the original result?
Once again it all depends on what the findings by the AUL were.Quote:
Originally Posted by Play it out
There is a lot of “TALK” on here but nothing concrete so that one could say ya City Wanders are right or wrong.
You would need the full story
Ah stop the lights Fruice. The galacticos had a different team out every week.
Ye mad our what ! coachford will probably get the points!! even dho it was Notting to do with them coachford are well looked after ..and do the Aul want another cup in the Northside..castleview winning primer A knocknaheeny celtic Henry healy then grattan with the premier..and you might yet have village with aoh if the win be some year for Northside teams to be fear
I'd grattan get the points be alot pressure on coachford to win anything?
Once again all talk nothing specific.
The rule book is clear and easy to identify an illegal player via FAI connect.
I ask again did Grattan lodge a protest against the original result?
Just confirmed Grangevale have left the Aul
Sad enough really. Down to business league to try pick up a few handy cups.. hopefully there better players don’t follow suit there is 2/3 lads there plenty good enough to play for a decent side.Quote:
Originally Posted by Harsh ref
Fear? What are you afraid of?Quote:
Originally Posted by Who?
Confirmed where and by?Quote:
Originally Posted by Harsh ref
By their committee member gone to business league didn’t see that coming
So its not actually confirmed then. Wasn't it confirmed that Grattan had the points as well :rolleyes:Quote:
Originally Posted by Harsh ref
It was indeed Kevin and that’s why where cutting out the middle man and going over his head
A loss to the AUL they have put a lot of work in to become successful.
They will fit right in the business league no ground of their own and playing out of Mayfield will fit in seamlessly.
Be interesting to see what division they go?
I’m assuming only 1 will be relegated from premier now
Only a matter of time before we lose a division
until it actually happens dont believe a word harsh says hahaQuote:
Originally Posted by fruice
Kevin no need I supported you all year on here man I have a man in all club in premier tgat feeds me information it’s all true
You support City Wanderers?Quote:
Originally Posted by Harsh ref
Suspended.
Tough seeing the way Glenthorne gone very bad
Be interesting to see what Cathederal produce tommorow, if they lose they go down
Donoughmore with they go up so slot to play for
Big game for both sides for different reasons, assuming Cathederal will want to stay up despite the rumours of manager gone and players heading to village and other clubs etc
Just getting my head around the Grangevale announcement.
Some kick in the rollers for the Aul.
They back there claim for points against Wanderers an then they do this.
Grattan if they go to the MFA could not only win the title all hands down but force the AUL to expell Wanderers by applying their own rules.
I'd make that Grangevale gone.
Wanderers gone.
Corkbeg relegated.
Glenthorn relegated.
Grattan, Coachford, Village, Springers an UCC left.
No wonder the Aul dismissed the Grattan appeal,,,,,,,,the reality of what could happen could destroy premier football altogether.
If Grattan win that appeal , the Aul would in a terrible spot.
Oh to have to sort out all that mess
Unfortunately AUL is declining the last number of seasons. They don't do anything to promote it or help themselves. Clubs have always come and gone but normally lower down the leagues. If those 3 teams go for the premier it's a right disgrace and embarrassment. Who's strong enough to replace those 3 teams? Watergrasshill? Castleview? I doubt catherdal will be around next year from what I'm hearing, I could be wrong. Surley the AUL know they need to re brand the whole thing. Then again will be having this conversation this time next year. Sad to see this league go to pot
What rule would they use to expel wanderers?Quote:
Originally Posted by Jason Bourne
I’m assuming fruice that will be their third time caught playing illegal player cause the talk is grangevale and Corkbeg got points Grattan didn’t
If a team is dedicted points for fielding illegal players for 2 games then the league reserve the right to remove that club. It's an old rule but for anyone who has an old rule book it's a rule .
If a club falls to field a side for 2 games the that side can be expelled.
If Grattan win the appeal, Wanderers are on 14 points , loose 3 , down to 11,,,,docked 3 for the offence as per rule , down to 8.
Springfield & Corkbeg stay up, wanderers an glenthorn go
I don’t know what the panic is. Grattan beat Coachford they are league champions.
There are fellas on here all year about how Grattan are miles ahead of everyone. Just beat Coachford at home and the league is theirs. Do the double then by beating them in the mossie final which is what is expected. Job done. Double won. Season complete
I think that rule could be gone about expulsion after non fielding of a team more than twice.Quote:
Originally Posted by Jason Bourne
They now within the rule book speak about applying a bond when re applying for membership.
They can relegate them if they qualify it as a non completion of a season.
But key to this is did grattan protest the original result?
Sorry Fruice but didn't the Grattan oricale of knowledge tell us all they lost their original appeal , hence him goin on about the MFA.
What points did Corkbeg get.
Grangevale got 3 points an Wanderers were deducted 3 afterwords ,,,, didn't see Corrk beg awarded 3.
The rules , even old ones are still rules.
Just because the Aul do not chose to inform them to all is all the mote reason to check the earlier rule books.
Rules don't go away,,,, there just forgotten ,,,,,,they still apply
Now I’m no solicitor but surely the current rule is the rule book and you can only work from that.
Rule books get updated all the time.
IF Grattans protest failed there must be a reason for this to fail.
The AUL will have to state why it failed.
The MFA will back the AUL if the AUL have used the rule book correctly.
If they haven’t things will most likely change.
But the key to this is Wanders actually playing an illegal player and if so who reported it
Because from my reading of. the rule book it allows differing outcomes depending on certain circumstances.
Again I’m no law man and am open to correction
Grattan are going to beat coachford anyway according to this blog so what’s the issue ?
I’m lost
Congratulations to grattan b on beating Shandon Celtic tonight. That was a huge result.
And Blackpool in a city challenge final again. There are cup teams and then there is Blackpool Celtic. Well done lads a great final in place there
Agree with Goal all Grattan have to do it beat Coachford again did it away so can’t see any problems at home beating teams for fun up there
Just shows how important those cups are to keep clubs going, Blackpool probably relegated from Div 1Quote:
Originally Posted by goal-achio
and Grattan may just fall short on honors in div 2 but still have a cup final to build towards.